Club Sale | It’s done!

Status
Not open for further replies.

MTF

Full Member
Joined
Aug 17, 2009
Messages
5,244
Location
New York City
They have a strange business model. Lots of JV with multiple companies using the INEOS like some franchising platform.
Businesses with high capital intensity and multi-step supply chains, such as petrochemicals, are full of JVs. Sometimes one party doesn't have/want to put up all the capital for a project they want to see done nonetheless, due to it maybe integrating strategically well with their existing assets.
 

MackRobinson

New Member
Joined
Dec 30, 2017
Messages
5,134
Location
Terminal D
Supports
Football
Yes, like you said, was not worded right.

Oh so when we are in a bad spell, twitter / caf can be blamed but when the atmosphere is good, only match day going fans are good? Not all the twitter / caf fans who are positive and people in Australia in pubs with chants at 4am.

You can argue that but you dont know how much each person abroad spends on TV subscriptions to watch games. Just quick research in the UK, Sky sports is £25 a month and BT sports is £28 a month. Totals to £638 a year on those. A Manutd season ticket is average say £700? The reason TV revenue is so high is because there is demand, without it, the club wont be where it is.
I never said Twitter/the Caf should only be blamed when things are bad so not quite sure where you are getting that from. I specifically said the match-going fans are responsible for the atmosphere (good and bad). I just pointed out that when things are bad the vitriol extends beyond the ground. Honestly, this has nothing to do with who is responsible for the atmosphere on the ground, which everyone watches on TV, is clearly match-going fans.

It's a fairly reasonable inference to make that match-going fans spend more on average and demand has nothing to do with it. In terms of reasonable inferences, what percentage of non-matching going fans are paying for both of those subscription services? What do matching-going fans spend while at the ground? I could go on but you get my point.
 

Plant0x84

Shame we’re aren’t more like Brighton
Joined
Jun 23, 2020
Messages
13,732
Location
Carpark and snack area adjacent to the abyss
You wonder if across the UK, there is a belief that you should support your local club and go to games? You think it is only Man United fans who are known for suggesting local fans mean more?

errrrm….
Back off Barbara, I wasn’t talking about you. This isn’t about supporting your local club, but about the dynamics within the fan base, for any given club.
It seems to me there is a schism between ‘match going fans’ and ‘online fans’. There’s probably a difference between season ticket holders and those who only get there occasionally. Then there are the tourists for whom attending a match is a major life event and for which they may have saved for years. But at the end of the day we all want success for this club, can’t we all just be friends?
 

MackRobinson

New Member
Joined
Dec 30, 2017
Messages
5,134
Location
Terminal D
Supports
Football
This is exactly it
I have posted about ten examples on this thread of posters hating Qatar and suggesting how evil they are up until the point they offered to buy us. That is exactly what happened.
I wish people would just own it. More respectable than throwing up smoke and mirrors to give the impression INEOS are bunch of clowns
 

glasgow 21

New Member
Newbie
Joined
Apr 27, 2022
Messages
1,259
Crikey the response to the saudi guy , really. Im from Northern Ireland and if a billionaire from there (we don't have any) was in poll for winning bid i would probably as a result feel a bit closer to United as supporter. Exactly what is wrong with that ?.

As for another comment "I can imagine Matt Busby for example turning in his grave at the thought of a state (let alone Qatar) owning Manchester United." well im surely Dear Matt has had a few turns before now at the "state" of the club finances ,the stadium and all round mismanagement for profit of our current group. To all we are not in a position to choose as mostly anyone below billionaire status would run a mile seeing the books. Can we all just calm down until we know the result.
 

romufc

Full Member
Joined
Apr 30, 2019
Messages
12,837
I never said Twitter/the Caf should only be blamed when things are bad so not quite sure where you are getting that from. I specifically said the match-going fans are responsible for the atmosphere (good and bad). I just pointed out that when things are bad the vitriol extends beyond the ground. Honestly, this has nothing to do with who is responsible for the atmosphere on the ground, which everyone watches on TV, is clearly match-going fans.

It's a fairly reasonable inference to make that match-going fans spend more on average and demand has nothing to do with it. In terms of reasonable inferences, what percentage of non-matching going fans are paying for both of those subscription services? What do matching-going fans spend while at the ground? I could go on but you get my point.
I get that match going fans are a huge part of the club, this is for every club. I would say alot of the PL clubs have atmosphere created by match going fans, those clubs are not as big as United. Why? They still have atmosphere, they still have match going fans.

Also, a few people dont even see eye to eye with match going fans who are not from Manchester, take Wum for example, saying they have to be local. Season ticket holders who travel hours for each game spend even more to get to a game.

When Manutd go abroad on pre season, why do we always have the sell out crowds? Is it those local fans going in their 50,000's numbers to watch pre season? No, its the fans in those countries who fill out a pre season game, speak to any player who has every played for Manutd, they will tell you they dont realise how big the club is until they go on pre season.
 

devilish

Juventus fan who used to support United
Joined
Sep 5, 2002
Messages
61,888
Don't think their quoted anywhere, who owns the other third? Can't imagine their happy with their pursuit of United, far better places to make a return on that level of investment.
Andy Currie and John Reece. They are expected to be part of Ineos contingency visiting OT. The positive thing is that the team lead by SJR look stronger then the Qatari one. All owners of I eps are being involved while Jassim had limited himself to send bankers. The downside to that is that Currie and Reece might not be as eager to buy United as Ratcliffe is.
 

sglowrider

Thinks the caf is 'wokeish'.
Joined
Dec 27, 2009
Messages
25,253
Location
Hell on Earth
Businesses with high capital intensity and multi-step supply chains, such as petrochemicals, are full of JVs. Sometimes one party doesn't have/want to put up all the capital for a project they want to see done nonetheless, due to it maybe integrating strategically well with their existing assets.
Ok. Thanks. Didn't know that. Petrochemical ain't my area of expertise. Closest thing I have got is the GF. She builds oil rigs, plants incl the two nordstream plants from the russian end.
 

devilish

Juventus fan who used to support United
Joined
Sep 5, 2002
Messages
61,888
Ok. Thanks. Didn't know that. Petrochemical ain't my area of expertise. Closest thing I have got is the GF. She builds oil rigs, plants incl the two nordstream plants from the russian end.
Wow that's cool
 

Plant0x84

Shame we’re aren’t more like Brighton
Joined
Jun 23, 2020
Messages
13,732
Location
Carpark and snack area adjacent to the abyss
Don't know much about Ineos, what % of the company does Jim Ratcliffe own?
Andy Currie and John Reece I believe own about 19% each. That would leave the remaining 62% with Sir Jim.
It’s worth noting that Reece is estimated to be worth $5.7bn and Currie is worth $6.1bn on top of Sir Jim’s worth and the value of INEOS. We need have no worries about finding with the INEOS bid.
 

sglowrider

Thinks the caf is 'wokeish'.
Joined
Dec 27, 2009
Messages
25,253
Location
Hell on Earth
Andy Currie and John Reece. They are expected to be part of Ineos contingency visiting OT. The positive thing is that the team lead by SJR look stronger then the Qatari one. All owners of I eps are being involved while Jassim had limited himself to send bankers. The downside to that is that Currie and Reece might not be as eager to buy United as Ratcliffe is.
It's strange to bring in the big guns in phase 2 though. It's the due diligence visit requesting specific details like financial number, plans for the future, legal & financial obligations etc to crunch/analyse and then propose a firm offer to the glazers in a week or so.
The big guns aren't going to be doing all that heavy lifting. I suspect not all are buying into Jim's legacy project
 

Tiber

Full Member
Joined
Apr 22, 2014
Messages
10,308
feck the Goldman Sachs delegation arriving tomorrow, get the deal signed today so Joel can clear out his office before the weekend
 

MackRobinson

New Member
Joined
Dec 30, 2017
Messages
5,134
Location
Terminal D
Supports
Football
I get that match going fans are a huge part of the club, this is for every club. I would say alot of the PL clubs have atmosphere created by match going fans, those clubs are not as big as United. Why? They still have atmosphere, they still have match going fans.

Also, a few people dont even see eye to eye with match going fans who are not from Manchester, take Wum for example, saying they have to be local. Season ticket holders who travel hours for each game spend even more to get to a game.

When Manutd go abroad on pre season, why do we always have the sell out crowds? Is it those local fans going in their 50,000's numbers to watch pre season? No, its the fans in those countries who fill out a pre season game, speak to any player who has every played for Manutd, they will tell you they dont realise how big the club is until they go on pre season.
When I say atmosphere I mean on the ground because it's the most salient and directly contributes to the spectacle everyone spends their time and money watching. The atmosphere on social media pales in comparison.

I'm talking specifically about a match-going fan (even though would assume the majority of match-going fans are from the greater Manchester area). The distinction between local and matching-going isn't that important.

Preseason tours are a one-off and the fans comprise a relatively small percentage of the overall fan base. Remember I'm saying on average the match-going fan spends more than the non-match-going fan.
 

devilish

Juventus fan who used to support United
Joined
Sep 5, 2002
Messages
61,888
It's strange to bring in the big guns in phase 2 though. It's the due diligence visit requesting specific details like financial number, plans for the future, legal & financial obligations etc to crunch/analyse and then propose a firm offer to the glazers in a week or so.
The big guns aren't going to be doing all that heavy lifting. I suspect not all are buying into Jim's legacy project
Well SJR is dragging INEOS into it so it makes sense that the other major shareholders are involved. If I own 15%-19% of a company then i would want to be involved in a 5B buy especially if such acquisition stinks of a vanity project. Having said that it kind of show that SJR cannot act on his own. His business partners will always have a say
 

MTF

Full Member
Joined
Aug 17, 2009
Messages
5,244
Location
New York City
Andy Currie and John Reece I believe own about 19% each. That would leave the remaining 62% with Sir Jim.
It’s worth noting that Reece is estimated to be worth $5.7bn and Currie is worth $6.1bn on top of Sir Jim’s worth and the value of INEOS. We need have no worries about finding with the INEOS bid.
There's a bit of double counting there. They all derive their net worth from their respective stakes in INEOS.
 

devilish

Juventus fan who used to support United
Joined
Sep 5, 2002
Messages
61,888
She got pulled out of China in June for the Putin's artic gas project -- $40+billion project. Her company was complying with the EU embargo. Was supposed to have been there for 3-4years but had to leave after a year.
Still its quite amazing. I am fascinated by women who makes it to the very top. They have it far tougher then we do. Respect towards your GF and yourself for supporting her
 

Tiber

Full Member
Joined
Apr 22, 2014
Messages
10,308
Whoever handles PR for Ineos needs to be replaced. Ratcliffe started this process as the clubhouse leader and every word he has leaked since the club went up for sale has made his bid more unappealing
 

jm99

New Member
Joined
Apr 18, 2011
Messages
4,667
But why aren't they being viewed the same what if they run us the same way, everyone thinks new owners is going to be some kind of pancea to all our woes as a football club when in reality it might not be, just some critical thinking before crowning anyone the answer to all our prayers and dismissing someone out of hand, I mean in this same thread people have called SJR a fraud I mean he is the UK's richest man and probably does have red flags in some ways but a fraud nah not for me.
I think because Al thani has said specifically his bid will leave the club debt free and will invest in infrastructure and so far Jim hasn't. Even as a United fan, the club clearly isn't worth 6bn, that's mental, so anyone spending that, then the extra 700m to clear the debt and 1bn for the stadium, is going to need a hell of a reason. We know Qatar care more about advancing their image in the west and aren't so concerned about a return on investment, Jim might be a United fan but he's a businessman, and I think people are rightly concerned about how he's going to see a return on 6bn plus clearing the debt plus infrastructure and it would require taking a lot of the profits out of the club, whereas with Qatar we know that a return on investment isn't their primary concern
 

Chief123

Full Member
Joined
Dec 27, 2013
Messages
12,787
Not to mention meeting some local fans who live inside the stadium.
There’s a fan who has an apartment on the centre circle of OT. He’s been invited as a VIP to meet the Sheikhy boys. His views have been regarded as priority on the agenda. He was born in the South stand toilets when they were piss free. He went to school in the physio room. Got a degree in the old tunnel.
 

sglowrider

Thinks the caf is 'wokeish'.
Joined
Dec 27, 2009
Messages
25,253
Location
Hell on Earth
Well SJR is dragging INEOS into it so it makes sense that the other major shareholders are involved. If I own 15%-19% of a company then i would want to be involved in a 5B buy especially if such acquisition stinks of a vanity project. Having said that it kind of show that SJR cannot act on his own. His business partners will always have a say
But shouldn't you be doing the buy-in part much earlier? The Qataris maybe be pushing the agenda and want to close it faster. I bet ratcliffe's team will be late on the 1st firm bid/offer like they were with Chelsea.
 

TsuWave

Full Member
Joined
Oct 12, 2013
Messages
14,527
There are a lot of foreign fans at Old Trafford every week. But they're not the same individual fans turning up over and over again.

In terms of an individual fan attending games regularly, they're very obviously more likely to do so the closer they are geographically to the club.

And (all else being equal) that individual fan who attends regularly is inarguably worth more to the club than an individual fan (like myself) who doesn't. Because I'm not contributing as much to the club. If the club had to lose one of us, they'd unquestionably lose me.
Brother, I don't know if you're genuinely not reading what I'm saying to you - there are a lot of people that are at OT every weekend who aren't "locals". I know because I know them. There's no need of hypotheticals or to argue "likely" positions when the reality is that a lot of the faces at OT - religiously - every weekend are not Mancunians.

Your whole "more important fans" thing hinges on "the closer you are to the club the more likely you are to go - therefore local fans are more important". It's an example of the "observation: clouds - conclusion: dinosaurs" fallacy.

Again, why is there a need for a hierarchal system of importance when it comes to supporting a football club?

And I can see that it's now being reframed as "worth/value" from a monetary club perspective - which again, is shortsighted seeing as plenty of non-local fans pump thousands of pounds/dollars into United - even without attending games - and that's without mentioning that Wumminator's whole local fans superiority babble was being presented as emotive and romantic

that's the thing about waffle - it always has to shift to seem like it's valid
 

sglowrider

Thinks the caf is 'wokeish'.
Joined
Dec 27, 2009
Messages
25,253
Location
Hell on Earth
Still its quite amazing. I am fascinated by women who makes it to the very top. They have it far tougher then we do. Respect towards your GF and yourself for supporting her
She's in Jakarta now on a project for BP.

What's funny is she can build structures that can withstand intense pressures a few kilometres deep in the sea. But I have a suspicion that she doesn't know how to change the light bulbs in her service apartment! :nervous: :rolleyes:
 

Marcelinho87

Full Member
Joined
Aug 4, 2010
Messages
7,308
Location
Barnsley
I am happy to be educated, that's why I asked the question. Please expand a bit, it's been a bit of a pointless reply so far.
It's an incredibly vast amount of money and will be very complex as that amount of cash isn't readily available... It will take multiple lawyers, bankers etc to iron it all out and ensure the transaction goes from one to the other smoothly.

I couldn't even tell you a bank that will do such a transaction.

Max protected in a standard account for us plebs is only 85k I believe so imagine the fees, insurance etc in this.. many hands wanting to play in the pie.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.