Fernandes has always been the emodiment of a stat fans player.
For me, though the premiership techncally and qality wise is superb now, the slower possesion based football, the almost sheep like tactical play of sides copying Guardiola, the over analytical emphasis on tactics and stats.....the football isnt as entertaining and hich octane as it used to be.
Fernandes fits firmly into that in discussions with what he does or doesnt do in a formation, playing a certain position and all his numbers being exceptional.
Yet, it has only bee the last season or so people have started to criticise him and even then as soon as he has a good game or in all honesty moment within a game, the tide turns on anyone criticising him.
Often see him compared to KDB with stat comparisons, Cantona and Rooney, labelled world class and being a United great. KDB can give the ball away, Rooney had poor periods and Cantona often struggled in Europe with his back to goal....but Fernandes for me isnt close to the level of those three players.
For me he is more comparable wth Pogba here. And it took for Pogba to leave for the vast majority to agree he failed here.
For me Fernandes is a good player capable of great decisive moments in a game who generally gives his all and works hard in a game. But bar the first few months here ad a couple of spells, he has NEVER been a great player here.
He often gets caught n possesion, gives the ball away not just in Hollywood passes but standard ones too, his workrae chasing the ball down in the final third of the pitch often seems to see him struggling when chasing back against counters.
For me as a starter week in, week out, we will never win a league title with a player like Fernandes, who would never get close to th first eleven of our best ever sides. He should have far more competition for his place than he has had, he shouldnt have been made captain with some of the whining he does and his inconsistency and he shouldnt have been tied down to a hefty new contract when nearing 30, considering he was poor for so long beforehand.
Fernandes is a good player as an option for the position he plays, but there are a lot of players who bring something different that could quite possibl be better in his position, look at Maddison, Eze....maybe Mount may actually be that player here if he can get back to some of his best Chelsea form.
Personally within about 18months of Fernandes being here, always thought though a good player he has been seriously over rated in terms of standing not just by our fans, but loads of pundits.....he is literally still living off those first 6months whwen in reality, his career here overall individually has been decent.
Both he and Rashford are far from irreplacable, think there are plenty of options out there that could well give us more and they are part of the group of players that seem to have let down a few managers here and rather than giving them huge contracts we should have been considering cashing in on them for big money.....its very mch like the Pogba situation....only we seem scared of losing players for nothing rather than being ruthless with star names that havent been good enough in rality