I wonder if any of the defenders Infront of him have any confidence in Andre
24
Season Average Rating
- Appearances
- 49
- Clean sheets
- 12
- Goals
- 0
- Assists
- 0
- Yellow cards
- 6
-
In the latest episode of the United Hour Podcast, Nik @Rood and Imran @Annihilate Now! start with the good news by celebrating Manchester United Women's emphatic FA Cup win over Spurs at Wembley and the future of manager Marc Skinner.
Then it's the bad news and the ever worsening form of our Men with losses to Arsenal and Palace.
Finally the main debate - ETH Out now or keep him until the end of the season - if not longer. Are you Team Nik or Team Imran?
Judging by how many are in the box whenever the opposition attack, I 'd say they don't.
The fact Martinez was there to head the ball off the line says a lot.
I am just happy whenever he gets to use his body to block a shot. Rarely expect him to actually save and hold with his ands. He is almost like a defender/goalie.
I don't think he's going to win our player of the month or even man of the match at any point. That's not the standard we should aspire to.
His passing is a disaster.
He's on 5.4 overall, I have him on 2.9, I really don't rate him do I ?
His confidence is clearly shot. There's a good goalkeeper in there.
Did he ever have it since he joined us? I have zero confidence we ll go far with him in goal. It feels a bit like Barthez coming in with expectations only to have a lot of howlers.
He just doesn't seem to be good at anything and I have zero confidence in him, neither do our defenders it seems. We need a new goalkeeper in the summer.
He is really poor keeper. Ten Hag should have dropped him after Copenhagen, we could still be in CL. Give Bayindir a chance.
I Know he won't, but ETH really should give Bayindir 2 or 3 games, see what we're working with there and give Onana some time out of the firing line. The guys a shambles, this cannot be his top level.
He's error prone, his technique is very odd and not working and basically any decent shot on target stands a very good chance of going in.
He's been a terrible signing so far.
He's been a terrible signing so far.
Not a good game for him for sure. Fecked up going for a cross and looked a bit shaky overall.
3rd goal was not easy to save, but there was 0 anticipation. His passing was solid. We cut through Wolves easily.
He needs to improve.
3rd goal was not easy to save, but there was 0 anticipation. His passing was solid. We cut through Wolves easily.
He needs to improve.
The only way ETH drops Onana is if he's injured.
Who is worse? Onana or Antony?
Worst keeper in the Premier League
Worst keeper in the Champions League
Worst keeper in AFCON
At least he's consistent.
Worst keeper in the Champions League
Worst keeper in AFCON
At least he's consistent.
The froward decision to use Onana by ETG will eventually cost him this job
two of the 3 goals conceded were savable.
penalties straight at the middle shall be savable.
penalties straight at the middle shall be savable.
nope. Onana can’t even save a contact on his phone at the moment. His level of confidence is so low now. He is not doing anything right. Can’t save a ball, very poor reflex and his distribution (a reason everyone was excited about) is very average. Does nothing right unfortunately.
This drop in performance is stunning. Last year, he was key to inter’s champions league run. What has happened when he joined united!
I like the guy but questions have to be asked again, especially for the third goal. His positioning there is dire. It's begging to be hit in that area to his left and he's failed to move towards the ball.
Unlike us Inter realized he is incontinent and leaky and let in too many goals to win any league effort. His deficiencies were masked by stellar defense and a top goal output to win games. We have no stellar defensive to mask his deficiencies and no goal output to compensate his brain farts. I don't rate his UCL efforts either since they had one of the easiest routes to a final ever. EtH smalltime recruitment. He need to let go of his nostalgia recruitment.
My 93 years old grandma can be a better goalkeeper than Onana. If Ten Hag get sack… Please bring Onana and Anthony with you (Ten Hag)
Didn't see the game, just the goals, so no idea about the other incidents, but
Can't believe anyone is blaming him for the second goal clusterfeck, equally can't believe anyone can absolve him of his positioning for the third. Literally *much* more open space on the near post!
Can't believe anyone is blaming him for the second goal clusterfeck, equally can't believe anyone can absolve him of his positioning for the third. Literally *much* more open space on the near post!
You just described Paddy Roche
I dont blame him for the goals - I blame him for the ones that luckily didn't end up as goals. Especially the one Martinez cleared off the line. He is just an awful goalkeeper - and if anyone claims he is an upgrade on DDG, they are mad
Yeah he's awful, I don't see a single aspect of his game that he's even decent at, never mind great.
ETH won't get rid yet but he absolutely should. Pep gave Bravo the boot after 1 season and massively upgraded, we really need to do the same
ETH won't get rid yet but he absolutely should. Pep gave Bravo the boot after 1 season and massively upgraded, we really need to do the same
People like to deny it but if De Gea was our keeper we’d be top 4. This guy is taking the piss.
Onana may be gash but De Gea wasn't answer either let's not pretend otherwise and no it's not certain we would be in top 4 with De Gea in Goal .
Last edited:
I always get very nervous whenever we concede a corner. He does not fulfill me with confidence at all. To be fair some of his passing yesterday was better so with the right people in front of him he might at least look better in that regard.
Hold on. What's he being blamed for yesterday? He flapped at the cross that got cleared off the line but he was fine other than that.
I think he's pretty shit btw. So no blind faith over here.
I think he's pretty shit btw. So no blind faith over here.
As if. He'd invest in groundbreaking exoskeleton technology to play him on two broken legs rather than let our poor Bayindir have a go.
Where is this coming from? We've scored the same amount of goals as Luton FC, we would not be Top 4. Whilst conceding goals has been bad, it's not been as big of an issue as scoring goals. We've actually conceded less than Spurs.
After scoring 4 goals yesterday, United are on 28 goals scored in the league. The top 4 teams - City - 51, Liverpool - 51, Spurs - 47, Arsenal - 44.
Last edited:
His technique or lack of it, causes a lot of the issues. Its like he only learned to be a goalkeeper in his late teens and missed a bulk of the development
At least SAF had the balls and sense to ditch Taibi. I fear we're stuck with this clown as long as we're stuck with ETH.
We scored feck all goals last season and were being saved by De Gea all the time. So many 1-0s.
Yep we scored 4 yesterday, but our GD has only improved by 1, or did you miss Wolves putting 3 past him?
As things stand we are on a GD of -4
I'm slowly but surely loosing my faith in this player. Although the first and second Wolves goals were not his fault, the third definitely felt like we are playing without a goalkeeper.
Unfortunately there's nobody who would pay to have this guy in his team. Pray to whoever you pray that the Saudis come for him. I'm sorry if someone will take this personally, but this goalkeeper is not the answer. And is a rather expensive mistake tbf.
Unfortunately there's nobody who would pay to have this guy in his team. Pray to whoever you pray that the Saudis come for him. I'm sorry if someone will take this personally, but this goalkeeper is not the answer. And is a rather expensive mistake tbf.
Same way losing our best defenders to injury has cost us wins and put top 4 in doubt.
You missed the one where he got caught flat footed on his near post.......................again?