- Joined
- Nov 18, 2001
- Messages
- 6,156
I can see SAF here for another 5 years
Mate top 5 in the world. I should of been clearer but I think there's no one that mad on these forums to assume we are a sixth place EPL squad...rubbish!
our midfield needs a bit of tweaking but do you honestly believe our defence and attack don't stand up to spurs, arsenal or city?
Based on what then? Go on, if it's a horror show let's hear your opinion instead of leeching off other people.
The whole post was a horror show but I'm liking your reaction to the worst bit.
Even then. Barcelona, Real Madrid, Chelsea (debatable but I'm not convinced), Inter (debatable but I'm not convinced). Go on who else has a better squad than us?Mate top 5 in the world. I should of been clearer but I think there's no one that mad on these forums to assume we are a sixth place EPL squad...
At one of his first Madrid press conferences he said it's not that important - "you get more points for one win, than two draws."wtf!
didn't know thatMourinho has not lost a home league match since February 23, 2002 when Beira Mar beat Porto in his sixth game in charge.
Read more: Holy Jose! Mourinho mayhem in Madrid, Pep going potty in Denmark and La Liga already looking ahead to El Clasico | Mail Online
fair enough, thought you'd got your mouth and arsehole confused.Mate top 5 in the world. I should of been clearer but I think there's no one that mad on these forums to assume we are a sixth place EPL squad...
.
It may be true that he has not worked with one team for a long period of time. But to do what he has done with every team so far is brilliant. It is not easy to just walk into a team regardless of its strength and still win titles in your first year - Chelsea and Inter. He finds a way to gel his players together even in the first game like he has been with the team for like 5 years.I don't know if it's a question of can Mourinho stay for more than three years, I think it's a question of if he's good enough.
Fergie always talks about a three year cycle of players. Mourinho has never been at a club over that time. Has he got the ability to continually make great squads, or is he just the best at getting the best out of what he has.
And like Roy at Pool, it is a fair point.I think it will be so interesting to see the first lean spell with a new manager after SAF leaves. If its someone like Mourinho then the fans will give him time, but if its someone a bit more lowkey like Moyes the spastics would be out after 2 loses calling for his head ala citey!!
Yes, let's hire a manager that's based in the cayman islands, no harm can come of hiring the man who brought Pompey to there knee's, especially in our financial situation...I'd like to see Redknapp given a chance. He has proven to be pretty good in the transfer market. Could stay for a good few years also! But I think he will take the England job. But if not Redknapp then Mourinho. Some other manager will have emerged by the time Fergie calls it a day that we will all be waking over but Harry and Jose would be my favs right now!
I can understand your thinking but you'd still have to take a step back and look at the cold hard facts.I'd love to see Steve Bruce back at OT but the only, only, way that would happen is if he got Sunderland into the Europa league this season and won it the next, then I could see him getting the job, no probs. Realistically, unfortunately, that is never going to happen.
Took the words out of my mouth.Mourinho not good enough for United
Because it's the first time in 24 years this job has come up.To be fair, I don't see a better candidate around than Mourinho. HOWEVER, a lot of people seem to be assuming that Mourinho will drop everything wherever he is (whether it is at Real Madrid or somewhere else) to come and manage United. If we can't compete with the likes of Real and Barcelona for some of the best players in the world, why should we believe that we will be able to compete with other big clubs when it comes to recruiting world class managers (especially in the Glazer era)?
Maybe I'm just cynical, but I think ultimately money is going to decide whether Jose comes to us or not.Because it's the first time in 24 years this job has come up.
On a purely egot level, unlike every other job in football that has had at least 10 managers in the last 24 years, you'd have a chance to put yourself in the spotlight and take on the biggest job in Football. If it isn't now, it will be when Ferguson retires.
Let's get all Chef on this and compare it to a beautiful woman
1. Is stunning, but everyones had a go on her.
2. Is also stunning but has just come out of a long term relationship where everyone has wanted to have a go on her but shes been so devoted to her husband, she's unavailible.
Everyone dreams of getting with 2. People only have a fleeting fantasy of 1.
MourinhoMaybe I'm just cynical, but I think ultimately money is going to decide whether Jose comes to us or not.
By the way, I know Fergie is extremely well paid - but does anyone know who the top paid football manager in the world is?
I don't think that will be a problem, we can afford Rooney's package, I'm sure we can afford to match Mourinho's package.Maybe I'm just cynical, but I think ultimately money is going to decide whether Jose comes to us or not.
By the way, I know Fergie is extremely well paid - but does anyone know who the top paid football manager in the world is?
So number 2 is just a hooker on a long term leaseMaybe I'm just cynical, but I think ultimately money is going to decide whether Jose comes to us or not.
By the way, I know Fergie is extremely well paid - but does anyone know who the top paid football manager in the world is?
which is just one of the reasons why you're posting rubbish on an internet forum and not running top flight football clubsIm not joking, I would have billy the fish with biffa fecking bacon as his assistant before I chose that prick everyone else wants.
young, scottish, not a utter failure, has brought through some youth at everton....I don't begrudge anyone who has a romantic inkling of wanting to bring moyes as the successor, but the fact is he is a massive step behind jose.Why is everyone jumping on the Moyes bandwagon? Just because Fergie might have suggested him?
Here's a left field choice, Giggs/Scholes/Neville managerial partnership...or perm any one or two from 3...I can understand your thinking but you'd still have to take a step back and look at the cold hard facts.
Has he won a league before? No.
Has he even been involved in a league title race? No.
Has he ever taken a team beyond the last 16 in the Champions League? No.
Has he even played in the group stage of the Champions League? No.
Has he any Champions League experience whatsoever?! No.
So how many managers fit these brackets? I can think of two.
Jose Mourinho, who is the standout candidate due to his success in the Premier League and his success at two other clubs where he won both the League and Champions League.
Pep Guardiola. I overlooked him earlier on in this post when I mentioned Wenger as the most unlikely to take the mantle at Old Trafford. Guardiola is at a successful club where he had a similar career to Giggs so it would be very difficult to get him.
Thats my take on the situation in a nutshell. In all honesty, right now, I am just so greatful Ferguson is still here. We really don;t know just how lucky we really are.
Ian Holloway: I enjoy chess match with Moyes, who must be next United manager - News & Comment, Football - The IndependentMoyes is one of my favourite managers and he is destined for even bigger things. I heard Sir Alex Ferguson talk about David as someone who could replace him when he retires. In all honesty I'd be surprised if anyone other than David becomes Manchester United's next manager.
He is top drawer. The job he has done at Everton is outstanding and he has done it without the resources that would be in place at United. But more important than that, I believe he is a chip off the old Fergie block. He has the character to be the United boss. If Everton don't get any financial backing, he has more or less taken them as far as he can.
Sir Alex rates him highly. He must have done because he wanted to take him as his assistant at one point. Who can argue with the main man about who he wants as his successor?
David ticks all the boxes. It speaks volumes that he has been a Premier League manager at the same club for eight years. He has left me standing for years. I remember vying for promotion with him when I was at Bristol Rovers and he was at Preston. He got promoted, I didn't and look what he's done since. He went galloping on; I ran out of diesel.
Let me get this straight - you're basing Mourinho's suitability on a quote from Mourinho himself, while dismissing Moyes as 'not United standard' despite the fact that Alex Ferguson (who one would assume might know a bit or two about 'United standard') has apparently endorsed Moyes' candidacy?Back to David Moyes. He is a very good manager, but just because he has done very well for Everton does not make him United standard, what is a very good achievement for Everton is usually a mediocre achievement for Utd.
As Mourinho said, "the Manchester United job is special and only a special manager is good enough to take the job on if and when it does become available." At the moment, there is only one special manager who can take up that challenge and succeed.
No I'm basing Mourinho's suitability on his record as Inter, Chelsea and Porto manager. I have dismissed Moyes as I think Mourinho would be a far better candidate and it's clear he wants the job. The Mourinho quote sums up how I feel about the person who needs to replace Sir Alex, and that is they have to be a very very good manager (or special). Moyes does not fall into that category.Let me get this straight - you're basing Mourinho's suitability on a quote from Mourinho himself, while dismissing Moyes as 'not United standard' despite the fact that Alex Ferguson (who one would assume might know a bit or two about 'United standard') has apparently endorsed Moyes' candidacy?
Nice logic there.
Correct...No I'm basing Mourinho's suitability on his record as Inter, Chelsea and Porto manager. I have dismissed Moyes as I think Mourinho would be a far better candidate and it's clear he wants the job. The Mourinho quote sums up how I feel about the person who needs to replace Sir Alex, and that is they have to be a very very good manager (or special). Moyes does not fall into that category.
He's hardly using the quote to say Mourinho is the right guy, simply saying that what Mourinho said encapsulates what he, and many other people, feel - that we can't just go for any promising manager, we need someone who is proven to be one of the best in the world.Let me get this straight - you're basing Mourinho's suitability on a quote from Mourinho himself, while dismissing Moyes as 'not United standard' despite the fact that Alex Ferguson (who one would assume might know a bit or two about 'United standard') has apparently endorsed Moyes' candidacy?
Like I said earlier. They won't win leagues but certainly Everton are good enough to win cups. His tactics in the FA cup final were shocking.How is Moyes meant to prove himself capable of winning trophies until a trophy-winning club gives him a chance(no disrespect to Everton)?
Mourinho has a damn sight more trophies than 2-3 at every side he's been at.How is Moyes meant to prove himself capable of winning trophies until a trophy-winning club gives him a chance(no disrespect to Everton)?
It's an unfair criticism IMO, it's like Porto not taking a chance on Mourinho when they did due to him not winning trophies. Trophies aren't the only currency in which success can be measured, Moyes work at Everton is probably the equivalent of 2-3 trophies at a top 4 club. Most people are too busy wanking themselves dry over Mourinho to realise this.
I'm not saying Moyes should succeed SAF, just that he deserves a crack at a top job soon and he should be considered along with Mourinho and whoever else is in the running when the United job comes up.
I agree with that. He needs to take the step up from Everton. But the truly top teams are more than just one step up, we're up a flight of stairs, hop in an elevator and ride up to the penthouses.I'm not saying Moyes should succeed SAF, just that he deserves a crack at a top job soon
Erm...Blanc for me.
The biggest problem for Mourinho is that he's never stayed at one club long enough. he might do it at United, but is he good enough.
Pretty shite? They lost the title by 2 points (Would have lost it on GD had Bolton not scored in the last minute) and came within an inch (literally) of being crowned European Champions.After he failed in his last year at Chelsea, the squad went through a period of being pretty shite. It took another three managers to win the league with all that money spent, and all the signings he made. At Inter he left Rafa an aging side after the team spent millions.
Interesting, don't watch a huge amount of Everton (Aside from when they're on live TV and highlights on MOTD), but of course we all know they're not a thrilling side. Which makes the likes of Baldwin and others a wee bit hypocritical considering one of their main reasons for not wanting Mourinho to take over is the fact they think his sides play boring football.Nothing specifically sticks in mind. I watch most Everton games though as my wife is an Evertonian. I see a lot of them live and on TV.
Moyes without fail will wait until 70 minutes to make a substitution for example, regardless of what is happening on the pitch. He'll be chasing a goal and take a striker off for a third right-back. They often seem to settle on a 1-0 lead (much like us at the moment) and inevitably are not good enough to hold onto it (ditto). He fields players constantly out of position, all over the pitch, regardless of the availability of other players who actually play in that position. He plays in an unattractive manner specifically to accomodate a one-trick-pony player (Cahill) who offers very little bar the knack of getting goals from set pieces. Everton very rarely play attractive attacking football and are content to spend large portions of games playing hoofball. Moyes has been in charge for enough time to stop this and he surely has the players to do so now, but he has still not addressed any of these faults.