Argentina NT

Peyroteo

Professional Ronaldo PR Guy
Joined
Jan 11, 2016
Messages
10,884
Location
Porto, Portugal
Supports
Sporting CP
If you put three defenders on Messi no one will step up in the National Team, if you put three defenders on him playing for Barcelona, Coutinho, Suarez or Dembele will make the diference, thats, basically the problem.
Dybala, Higuain/Aguero/Icardi, Di Maria aren't worse than Coutinho, Suarez and Dembele.

The same problems Argentina have offensively also happen in Barcelona. It's the exact same thing. The difference is Barcelona come up against teams at their level a lot less often and they're a lot better in defense, even if this year they seem a lot more vulnerable.
 

IFC 1905

New Member
Joined
Aug 24, 2014
Messages
2,727
Location
Buenos Aires, ARG
Dybala, Higuain/Aguero/Icardi, Di Maria aren't worse than Coutinho, Suarez and Dembele.

The same problems Argentina have offensively also happen in Barcelona. It's the exact same thing. The difference is Barcelona come up against teams at their level a lot less often and they're a lot better in defense, even if this year they seem a lot more vulnerable.


Performing for argentina they have been MUCH WORSE.
 

SCP

Full Member
Joined
Sep 29, 2016
Messages
5,941
Location
Lisbon
Supports
Sporting Clube Portugal
Quite frankly can't see them winning this competition. Even with Messi. Then the same tiring arguments from the Argentinian press or fans demanding him to play like at Barcelona when they are calling average players like Acuna, Battaglia or Salvio. :lol:

And I am not a Messi lover nor do I believe he is the best ever, but as a squad even Uruguay looks more solid and complete, what Argentina has is a lot of good to great attacking options, because their fullbacks, keepers or even current CB's are worse than Uruguay, not even compared to Brazil. Also they even look incompetent to take the best from Banega. They need the right manager to implement a style untill 2022.

Maybe a guy like Gallardo would fit well there. If the Boca press wouldn't go after him.
 

Peyroteo

Professional Ronaldo PR Guy
Joined
Jan 11, 2016
Messages
10,884
Location
Porto, Portugal
Supports
Sporting CP
Performing for argentina they have been MUCH WORSE.
They haven't, but they have clearly been below their club form. Why do you think that happens?

You're talking about 3 of the top 10 strikers in the world, they don't all just magically turn to shit as soon as they put an Argentina shirt on.
 

Fenomeno9

Full Member
Joined
Apr 21, 2014
Messages
1,241
Location
USA
They haven't, but they have clearly been below their club form. Why do you think that happens?

You're talking about 3 of the top 10 strikers in the world, they don't all just magically turn to shit as soon as they put an Argentina shirt on.
The international game and the club game is different. Different coaches, different systems, players might not be compatible with each other, not enough chemistry, there is also a different kind of pressure you deal with especially for a team like Argentina.
 

Peyroteo

Professional Ronaldo PR Guy
Joined
Jan 11, 2016
Messages
10,884
Location
Porto, Portugal
Supports
Sporting CP
@Peyroteo Because they can't play all together?
They don't need to play together though, they need one of their three world class strikers to play world class football.

All of Higuain, Aguero and Icardi have led the line for Argentina. You can't excuse them being bad on lack of quality since they're incredible for their clubs, you can't put it on a mental problem since it happens to all 3 of them... so what's the problem?
 

SCP

Full Member
Joined
Sep 29, 2016
Messages
5,941
Location
Lisbon
Supports
Sporting Clube Portugal
They don't need to play together though, they need one of their three world class strikers to play world class football.

All of Higuain, Aguero and Icardi have led the line for Argentina. You can't excuse them being bad on lack of quality since they're incredible for their clubs, you can't put it on a mental problem since it happens to all 3 of them... so what's the problem?
Instability regarding the constant changes of managers, wrong lineups, unbalance between attacking options to normal midfield options, to even worse fullback options (except Tagliafico) and to have Romero as a keeper option isn't even debatable. But true they are still underperforming. Ffs we won a final with Éder scoring the winner. :)
 

FootballHQ

Full Member
Joined
Nov 17, 2017
Messages
18,256
Supports
Aston Villa
Performing for argentina they have been MUCH WORSE.
Kun was actually o.k in the world cup when he was allowed to play.

Dybala really needs to establish himself while Messi is in exile but looking at the Brazil game he was on the fringes although nearly score a nice fk.

Icardi is having same problem as Higuain, keeps hitting the keeper/post with chances he'd score with his eyes closed for his club team.

Maybe skip a generation and give Laturo Martinez and Simeone's son more chances perhaps.
 

IFC 1905

New Member
Joined
Aug 24, 2014
Messages
2,727
Location
Buenos Aires, ARG
They haven't, but they have clearly been below their club form. Why do you think that happens?

You're talking about 3 of the top 10 strikers in the world, they don't all just magically turn to shit as soon as they put an Argentina shirt on.

Dybala and Icardi haven't scored a single goal for Argentina yet. And Dybala has gone missing in so many games incluiding the last one against brasil, that people are starting to take it against him. Icardi didn't show up when needed back in the qualifiers, he had many chances to score and he failed them. And we needed them both.


Higuain has failed in the most important moments, basically he had a sitter in every final and he's lost it. And after 2014 WC he's been absolute shite for the NT, not even being called for some 2018 WC qualifiers matches.


Aguero is the one who's performed better but hasn't delivered as he's supossed to. He's been under Tevez's shadow for a long time, until 2012. Then he had a decent period but came to play totally broken in 2014, and didn't do much in the Copa Americas 15/16. His best moment for argentina was during the WC, he scored vs Iceland and france, and we don't know why Sampaoli didn't use him more.

If you actually follow Argentina, you will notice that Sampaoli used like 3 different formations with different styles and players during a world cup, he had no clue at all about the team he wanted. In that situation, there's no Messi, Maradona or Pele that can save you. Even less if your teammates can do absolutely nothing and if the rivals close Messi, then it's done.
 

Skorenzy

Full Member
Joined
May 2, 2011
Messages
5,945
Dybala, Higuain/Aguero/Icardi, Di Maria aren't worse than Coutinho, Suarez and Dembele.
They aren't worse players obviously, but they sure do perform a lot worse with Argentina.

Dybala: 0 goals in 16 caps
Icardi: 0 goals in 6 caps
Higuaín: 31 goals in 75 caps which is good/great, however no goals in his last 11 matches (since Oct 2016) and has a history of missing clear chances in decisive moments.
Agüero: 39 goals in 89 caps which is very impressive but he never seems to be able to definitively nail down a sport in the starting XI due to inconsistency (decent WCQ'10 cycle, underwhelming WC'10 apart from SKo match, good CA'11, excellent WCQ'14 cycle, invisible WC'14 due to fitness, quite good CA'15 as starter, then suddenly poor CA'16 as sub, very poor WCQ'18 cycle mixed starter/sub from one game to the next and eventually a decent enough WC'18 but again started first two games, then a sub in the latter two)

Over the past two years, of those only Kun can claim to be performing at an acceptable level for world class players.
Dybala and Icardi also have time on their side of course but it's quite a familiar discrepancy in goalscoring fortunes between club and NT.
 
Last edited:

Peyroteo

Professional Ronaldo PR Guy
Joined
Jan 11, 2016
Messages
10,884
Location
Porto, Portugal
Supports
Sporting CP
Instability regarding the constant changes of managers, wrong lineups, unbalance between attacking options to normal midfield options, to even worse fullback options (except Tagliafico) and to have Romero as a keeper option isn't even debatable. But true they are still underperforming. Ffs we won a final with Éder scoring the winner. :)
Their biggest problem is by far the system in which they've played in the past 2/3 years, not lack of quality of their players. We were good enough to win the Euros because we played football that made sense for the players we had in the squad at the time. You can tell now that with the likes of Cancelo and Ruben Neves coming in we're already playing differently.

Both Barcelona and Argentina give Messi too much responsability in attack, they base it completely around him. Then they keep persisting with it because he often saves them from situations they wouldn't even have needed to be saved if they played a coherent attacking system that got the best out of the players they have. It would actually mean they wouldn't turn to shit every time he's not on the pitch too.

While Messi has such a big role, Barcelona aren't going to win the CL and Argentina aren't going to win anything. The past 3 years are going to keep repeating themselves and Higuain, Aguero, Icardi, Dybala, Suarez, Alcacer, Dembele, etc. will keep on being called shit.

That's a criticism on the managers, not on Messi btw before I start getting insults left and right.
 
Last edited:

SCP

Full Member
Joined
Sep 29, 2016
Messages
5,941
Location
Lisbon
Supports
Sporting Clube Portugal
Dybala and Icardi haven't scored a single goal for Argentina yet. And Dybala has gone missing in so many games incluiding the last one against brasil, that people are starting to take it against him. Icardi didn't show up when needed back in the qualifiers, he had many chances to score and he failed them. And we needed them both.
If they are not used they hardly will perform. And when they are used expecting them to be the new Evita Perón to bailout Argentina is always the same drama. No wonder even players like Messi struggle when you see how Dybala or Icardi are misjudged by the media or fans.

Quite normal to see Boca or River fans saying their players are better than those who play in Europe. I suspect they don't have the minimal notion regarding the current difference between top level football in Europe and South America. This isn't the 80's or 90's where Maradona alone could win games and tournaments.

@Peyroteo agree 95% with what you said. Not bad. :lol:
 

Peyroteo

Professional Ronaldo PR Guy
Joined
Jan 11, 2016
Messages
10,884
Location
Porto, Portugal
Supports
Sporting CP
Dybala is a tricky player to find a spot in the team, especially in big games and he's been benched several times for Juve because of it but the way his situation has been handled by Argentina has been incredibly bad too. He's 25 and hasn't scored a single goal...
 

the_irish123

New Member
Newbie
Joined
Jun 2, 2018
Messages
865
I don't know about this new Argentina team, because I don't follow their young players, but I was having an argument with a friend pre-World Cup, that people acted like Ronaldo was carrying a bunch of dross, while Messi had way more help.

My argument was that even Portugal had better depth of talent than Argentina (imo), who had an awful defense/midfield going into WC.

GK : Patricio = Romero

LB : Guerreiro > Tagliafico
CB: Pepe > Funes Mori
CB : Fonte < Otamendi
RB : Cancelo > Mercado

CM : Moutinho, Carvalho, Danilo Pereira > Old Mascherano, Enzo Perez, Biglia

Wingers/AMs : Ruben Neves, Gelson, Adrien Silva, Quaresma > Acuña, Salvio, Di Maria

Striker : Higuain > Andre Silva.

It's not that surprising that Ronaldo won a title, and Messi didn't. Although Copa America is a easier task than Euros, and I take this into account to state that Ronaldo had a much better international career.
 

hasanejaz88

Full Member
Joined
Dec 3, 2017
Messages
5,919
Location
Munich
Supports
Germany
I don't know about this new Argentina team, because I don't follow their young players, but I was having an argument with a friend pre-World Cup, that people acted like Ronaldo was carrying a bunch of dross, while Messi had way more help.

My argument was that even Portugal had better depth of talent than Argentina (imo), who had an awful defense/midfield going into WC.

GK : Patricio = Romero

LB : Guerreiro > Tagliafico
CB: Pepe > Funes Mori
CB : Fonte < Otamendi
RB : Cancelo > Mercado

CM : Moutinho, Carvalho, Danilo Pereira > Old Mascherano, Enzo Perez, Biglia

Wingers/AMs : Ruben Neves, Gelson, Adrien Silva, Quaresma > Acuña, Salvio, Di Maria

Striker : Higuain > Andre Silva.

It's not that surprising that Ronaldo won a title, and Messi didn't. Although Copa America is a easier task than Euros, and I take this into account to state that Ronaldo had a much better international career.
Argentina had a much better squad at the start of the decade though and that is reflected in their 3 lost finals (World Cup, 2 x Copa America). All three were lost in ET/Penalties so it shows how close Messi did come to a title. Ronaldo had a wondergoal from Eder to thank while Messi saw Higuain miss one gilt edge chance all three finals, sometimes luck just doesn't go your way.

With the squad Argentina had, they definitely should have won atleast one major competition, they had very good players throughout the field. Demichellis, Otamendi, Garay and Zabaleta in defense; Masherano, Gago, Pastore, Biglia, Banega in midfield and ofcourse we already know the amount of talent they had in attack. The problem was always trying to get a coercive system in attack, part of that I feel was that they didn't have a world class playmaker like Germany had in Ozil, Spain had in Iniesta/Xavi. Messi had to play too many roles, through neccessity or his choice, noone knows, and ultimately it made for a loopsided system with no connection between the midfield and attack.

But again, had Higuain put away those chances, who knows what history would say about Messi for his country.
 

Lay

Correctly predicted Italy to win Euro 2020
Joined
Jan 29, 2013
Messages
20,002
Location
England
Dybala is a tricky player to find a spot in the team, especially in big games and he's been benched several times for Juve because of it but the way his situation has been handled by Argentina has been incredibly bad too. He's 25 and hasn't scored a single goal...
If you look at Argentina strikers post Crespo and Batigol, so many have failed. Tevez has only 13 goals in 70+ games. Milito always looked like a fish out of water. Dybala, Icardi etc failing just seems to be following a familiar pattern.
 

SCP

Full Member
Joined
Sep 29, 2016
Messages
5,941
Location
Lisbon
Supports
Sporting Clube Portugal
@hasanejaz88 Ronaldo went to 2 European Championship Finals, 1 WC semifinal and another European Championship semifinal, and the team from 2012 was far bellow than anything Messi had with Argentina. Trying to use Éder goal or Higuain misses is a relative poor excuse. Lets face it Messi never did nothing similar like Maradona with Argentina. Those are facts.
 

Peyroteo

Professional Ronaldo PR Guy
Joined
Jan 11, 2016
Messages
10,884
Location
Porto, Portugal
Supports
Sporting CP
@hasanejaz88 Ronaldo went to 2 European Championship Finals, 1 WC semifinal and another European Championship semifinal, and the team from 2012 was far bellow than anything Messi had with Argentina. Trying to use Éder goal or Higuain misses is a relative poor excuse. Lets face it Messi never did nothing similar like Maradona with Argentina. Those are facts.
If we had won it in 2012 instead of 2016, I think a lot of people would look at it very differently.
 

SCP

Full Member
Joined
Sep 29, 2016
Messages
5,941
Location
Lisbon
Supports
Sporting Clube Portugal
If we had won it in 2012 instead of 2016, I think a lot of people would look at it very differently.
In 2012 we had a good Moutinho, Pepe, Coentrão and Nani. We lost the semifinal against Spain on Penalties. The Spain of Guardiola and a few days after they won the final by 4:0. So this constant excuse that Messi never won nothing because Higuain missed goals and Ronaldo was lucky because Éder scored a goal its a myth.
 

hasanejaz88

Full Member
Joined
Dec 3, 2017
Messages
5,919
Location
Munich
Supports
Germany
@hasanejaz88 Ronaldo went to 2 European Championship Finals, 1 WC semifinal and another European Championship semifinal, and the team from 2012 was far bellow than anything Messi had with Argentina. Trying to use Éder goal or Higuain misses is a relative poor excuse. Lets face it Messi never did nothing similar like Maradona with Argentina. Those are facts.
The reason why I'm bringing up Eder is because Ronaldo had very little to do with Portugal in the knockout stages. He was brilliant the group stages, no doubt, but he got injured early in the final and generally was poor in the knockout stages.

Ronaldo didn't win them the Euro's, he needed one of his teammates to score a wonderful goal to get a trophy. Messi also couldn't win them a tournament single handedly, but, unlike Ronaldo, one his best teammates deserted him when they could've won it. That's a difference I'm trying to make.

In 2012 we had a good Moutinho, Pepe, Coentrão and Nani. We lost the semifinal against Spain on Penalties. The Spain of Guardiola and a few days after they won the final by 4:0. So this constant excuse that Messi never won nothing because Higuain missed goals and Ronaldo was lucky because Éder scored a goal its a myth.
How is it a myth? Eder scored the winner, didn't he? Higuain missed two absolute sitters in the ending stages of each of the two Copa America finals, is that wrong as well? Luck has alot to do with football and it's understated. Using only trophies as an indicator that Ronaldo has done better than Messi on the international stage is ignoring the circumstaces IMO. I'm not saying Messi has done better, but there are more ways to look at this argument.
 

Peyroteo

Professional Ronaldo PR Guy
Joined
Jan 11, 2016
Messages
10,884
Location
Porto, Portugal
Supports
Sporting CP
In 2012 we had a good Moutinho, Pepe, Coentrão and Nani. We lost the semifinal against Spain on Penalties. The Spain of Guardiola and a few days after they won the final by 4:0. So this constant excuse that Messi never won nothing because Higuain missed goals and Ronaldo was lucky because Éder scored a goal its a myth.
We got lucky in 2016, but we got unlucky in the way we got knocked out in plenty of previous tournaments. 2004, 2006, 2008, 2012... even in the last WC, Uruguay went to our goal twice and scored two goals.

The point is that we should be looking at the whole picture and at the high level we’ve shown in this period in relation to the quality of players we’ve had and not at just one tournament in isolation.

If we win the penalty shootout against Spain in 2012 and lose the penalty shootout against Poland in 2016 a lot of people would rate Ronaldo’s international career differently which doesn’t really make sense. He’d have won player of the tournament and I believe we’d have won the final against Italy too.

Incredibly small margins that change the whole narrative.
 

SCP

Full Member
Joined
Sep 29, 2016
Messages
5,941
Location
Lisbon
Supports
Sporting Clube Portugal
The reason why I'm bringing up Eder is because Ronaldo had very little to do with Portugal in the knockout stages. He was brilliant the group stages, no doubt, but he got injured early in the final and generally was poor in the knockout stages.
Not turning this into the entire Messi vs Ronaldo thread which is a bit tiring and useless by itself. By the way I think Messi is the best Barcelona player ever. And possibly the best from the last 25 years. But he definitely wasn't better for Argentina than Maradona.
 

hasanejaz88

Full Member
Joined
Dec 3, 2017
Messages
5,919
Location
Munich
Supports
Germany
Not turning this into the entire Messi vs Ronaldo thread which is a bit tiring and useless by itself. By the way I think Messi is the best Barcelona player ever. And possibly the best from the last 25 years. But he definitely wasn't better for Argentina than Maradona.
Agree.
 

SCP

Full Member
Joined
Sep 29, 2016
Messages
5,941
Location
Lisbon
Supports
Sporting Clube Portugal
We got lucky in 2016, but we got unlucky in the way we got knocked out in plenty of previous tournaments. 2004, 2006, 2008, 2012... even in the last WC, Uruguay went to our goal twice and scored two goals.
2004 Scolari was tactically inept vs Rehagel, in 2006 France scored early and imo the team wasn't at the same level as in 2004. 2008 we played well against Germany and they had a good tournament, must be said it was a good Germany but not as strong as the teams between 2010 to 2016 imo.

If we had the chance to get to the final in 2012 I don't know if we would beat Italy, but this is more based on my irrational fear on our ability to bottle under real pressure. A taboo broke by Santos on 2016. Oh and we should have played better in 2018, even Santos knows it, big mistake to not call Cancelo at least, not to mention Neves or playing Mário Rui instead Guerreiro who since he moved to Dortmund looks a bit lost on injuries and lack of confidence.

Regarding Argentina I don't see in the near future them winning big titles, they have good to great players on some areas of the pitch but other areas are quite disturbing imo.
 

Himannv

Full Member
Joined
Dec 11, 2017
Messages
5,794
Location
Somewhere in the draft forum
Their biggest problem is by far the system in which they've played in the past 2/3 years, not lack of quality of their players. We were good enough to win the Euros because we played football that made sense for the players we had in the squad at the time. You can tell now that with the likes of Cancelo and Ruben Neves coming in we're already playing differently.

Both Barcelona and Argentina give Messi too much responsability in attack, they base it completely around him. Then they keep persisting with it because he often saves them from situations they wouldn't even have needed to be saved if they played a coherent attacking system that got the best out of the players they have. It would actually mean they wouldn't turn to shit every time he's not on the pitch too.

While Messi has such a big role, Barcelona aren't going to win the CL and Argentina aren't going to win anything. The past 3 years are going to keep repeating themselves and Higuain, Aguero, Icardi, Dybala, Suarez, Alcacer, Dembele, etc. will keep on being called shit.

That's a criticism on the managers, not on Messi btw before I start getting insults left and right.
That's on the money I reckon. Additionally, I think it's a case of lot of their best players wanting to operate in the same general areas of the pitch. However, with Messi in the team they're all either playing out of position to accommodate him and each other or not featuring in the starting XI at all.
 

FootballHQ

Full Member
Joined
Nov 17, 2017
Messages
18,256
Supports
Aston Villa
Same old same old.....

They remind me so much of England "golden generation". Trouble is this is when that generation hit their 30s between 2010-2014 and the tournament results were really poor.

Wonder if they might miss next WC given how close they came to missing out last time. Guess Chile and Uruguay 11s also getting old together will help them.
 

Bruno Marques

New Member
Newbie
Joined
Jan 12, 2017
Messages
486
Location
Setúbal, Portugal
Supports
Vitória de Setúbal
Messi at barcelona = the team doesnt matter. he is the best there is. bla bla bla

Messi at NT = his team mates suck. It's all the team fault. bla bla bla.

Funny how things change. :D
 

RoyH1

Full Member
Joined
Jul 22, 2014
Messages
5,981
Location
DKNY
Same old same old.....

They remind me so much of England "golden generation". Trouble is this is when that generation hit their 30s between 2010-2014 and the tournament results were really poor.

Wonder if they might miss next WC given how close they came to missing out last time. Guess Chile and Uruguay 11s also getting old together will help them.
The thing is for Argentina’s standards, this generation is pretty bad. Look at the Argentina WC squads of 98 or 2002. Messi is the only one who would make those sides.
 

Ekeke

Full Member
Joined
Aug 1, 2006
Messages
53,283
Location
Hope, We Lose
The thing is for Argentina’s standards, this generation is pretty bad. Look at the Argentina WC squads of 98 or 2002. Messi is the only one who would make those sides.
Lo Celso would make it in too and Aguero on club form. Tagliafico maybe as well.

Its nothing to do with talent, for their club sides most of those players are very good.

Argentina didnt attack like their club sides though, they played like a mid table team afraid to get beat so they barely pushed anyone forward.

Lo Celso was playing right midfield for some reason instead of centrally. Parades and Guido Rodriguez is a defensive minded midfield, did that pay off? Paredes at least made 4 tackles, Rodriguez made just 1 and was subbed on 66 mins. Guido Pizarro who came on for him made 1 interception and no tackles. He's another DM.

So clearly despite going for a solid/defensive CM setup and a CM on the right and it still didnt work out because Columbia's midfield outplayed them especially in the 2nd half.

Even in the first half Columbia had just 3 or 4 attacks but when they went forward they looked dangerous. Argentina never looked dangerous because they were so rigid and afraid to put players forward
 

bucky

Full Member
Joined
Apr 5, 2011
Messages
9,598
Asking again here, why is Walter Benitez not in their squad, let alone their first choice GK?
 

Infordin

Full Member
Joined
Sep 7, 2016
Messages
3,900
Supports
Barcelona
Asking again here, why is Walter Benitez not in their squad, let alone their first choice GK?
No idea.

Geronimo Rulli is also better than the goalkeepers they have called up.