David Silva also played for a far worse City team.
Bernardo Silva - Footballer
- Thread starter roonster09
- Start date
Far worse? Kompany, Sterling, Aguero, KDB, Fernandinho etc? I know he joined a long time ago and was one of their first statement signings but he played with their current crop of 'legends'
Ya City have far more options and depth of talent now then during Silva time.
I am not saying your wrong, I’m not sure who was better tbh but I don’t think the fact Bernardo does not start every game is a negative in this comparison.
True, giving players a say in executive matters is a disaster waiting to happen but to be fair we're not actually sure if they did that or not.
Aren't they drastically different?
Similar stature and offensive skill set but I would argue Bernardo is more versatile and a better dribbler.
It's not a great question. I don't know a single City fan who thinks Bernardo is even in the same stratosphere as David Silva as a player
David Silva offensively is probably better I agree, plus he is one of their first legends in their history so he has more lore to him.It's not a great question. I don't know a single City fan who thinks Bernardo is even in the same stratosphere as David Silva as a player
True but I get the impression of David playing deeper than Bernardo does now but it might just be my faulty memory.
Don’t know how many he scored or if his record was even all that, but can remember being surprised and impressed with how much of a goal threat for Spain David looked as a false 9
He's simply a better player, and yes he's more revered.
What?
Sane Aguero Sterling
Silva
Fernandinho (in his prime)
De Bruyne (younger)
Arguably a better team.
That was the end of D Silvas time at City, the Mancini/Pellegrini teams were obviously not as good as Peps.
David was the far superior player, would run the show week in week out, Bernardo is very talented but simply not able to exert the same sort of influence on a match.
You could argue it was inferior for most of his time there.
He came there at 2010 the team you named came at the tail end of his career.
gerardromero] on his stream “Right now, people from FC Barcelona are telling me that tonight will be beautiful. Bernardo Silva wants to leave Manchester City & join FC Barcelona. Bernardo Silva has decided to leave Manchester City, like João Cancelo! He wants to join FC Barcelona NOW.”Tweet
— Twitter API (@user) date
From reddit
City would be absolutely bonkers to let him go.
Romero
It would leave a Jude Bellingham shaped hole in their midfield. And Foden is probably better in Bernardo's position than out wide anyway.
Tweet
— Twitter API (@user) date
I keep forgetting he exists.
Another player that needs a new challenge.
Are Barcelona going to pay for him in exposure?
Vastly overrated player.
Being a robot in Peps system gets old
There’s been something off at City all season, pretty alarming if 2 of their best players both want out within a few days.
That being said I’d be amazed if they let him go.
That being said I’d be amazed if they let him go.
Is there another source other than Romero who is claiming this to be the case?
Both Portuguese, not in the best form and have both also had their minutes severely limited as well, iirc.
Off-season they had a 80m price tag on him. Unless it's a loan with an obligation to buy, i just don't see it happening - least not this late in the window.
Barca could then try to offload Raphinha or someone offseason to buy Bernardo.
Didn't he want to leave in the summer?
If City could not implode before playing Arsenal in the league, that’d be great.
He's wanted to go for a couple of years now. Citys attitude seems to be if a decent offer comes in and they have time to find a replacement they'll let him go.
Dont think either of them criteria will be filled
Why are Barcelona so committed to not being able to register as many of their players as possible?
Romero or Silva?
Silva! I could never forget Mr. Hot.
he toyed with our hearts all summer mate No way this is happening, just Romero looking for some relevance on deadline day. His show was a shitfest during deadline day in the summer.
Bernardo's wanted to leave for 2 seasons. Pep has said he's happy to let him go if an acceptable offer comes in but it never came. Barca will either cough up or wait till his contract runs down in 2025.
City have seen the best of Silva the Younger methinks, bar a last gasp push for the CL.
Barcelona need to stop being cheap and take him, it's getting boring
Barcelona need to stop being cheap and take him, it's getting boring
He must be crazy wanting to leave
Its the usual tale of his missus hating the English weather, nightlife and food.
Personally think him and David Silva are on a similar level. Don't think David Silva is on a whole different stratosphere as said on here.
He's already performed much better in Europe for City than D.Silva has. Similar consistency in the league. David Silva's best league campaigns(2011-2012 & 2017-2018) are somewhat marred by disappointing CL campaigns individually.
Don't really see the argument that David Silva is much much better. I think David's a better passer, but they're both similarly press resistant(Bernardo probably shades him here). Bernardo's probably a better ball carrier too and even a better dribbler.
He's already performed much better in Europe for City than D.Silva has. Similar consistency in the league. David Silva's best league campaigns(2011-2012 & 2017-2018) are somewhat marred by disappointing CL campaigns individually.
Don't really see the argument that David Silva is much much better. I think David's a better passer, but they're both similarly press resistant(Bernardo probably shades him here). Bernardo's probably a better ball carrier too and even a better dribbler.