That would be fair. They need to make an example of them to send a strong message to Newcastle.
City schadenfreude - what would you like their punishment to be?
- Thread starter Bastian
- Start date
-
In the latest episode of the United Hour Podcast, Nik @Rood and Imran @Annihilate Now! start with the good news by celebrating Manchester United Women's emphatic FA Cup win over Spurs at Wembley and the future of manager Marc Skinner.
Then it's the bad news and the ever worsening form of our Men with losses to Arsenal and Palace.
Finally the main debate - ETH Out now or keep him until the end of the season - if not longer. Are you Team Nik or Team Imran?
Yeah lets warn Newcastle who've done nothing wrong about their potential financial cheating because City cheated. Not Todd Boehly who's already making bids on the titles City are having revoked.
Never mind Pep and the players but will the owners want to stay around if they are relegated? I don’t think they will.
Look, these posts seem over the top, but they have literally fraudulently abused their position in the footballing pyramid for 15 years. They have stolen valour. It shouldnt be out of the question that they be expelled from the league. That goes for anyone who does that. Us included.
City's lawyers have used the chewbacca defence
It's all over folks
It's all over folks
Chelsea deserve to be punished as well. The fact that two oil clubs have 11 PL titles between them is a disgrace.
Send them to the NFL where they can play football using their hands.
They should be thrown out of the game
Probably a 30 points reduction for this season, relegation for next and 3 year transfer ban.
They cant survive expulsion. If they found guilty on few of these charges they will face expulsion.
Fire them into the sun
The artificial sponsorship deals are the most difficult ones for city to defend. That alone will get them relegated.
But they have to clarify the Roberto Mancini shadow contract (4 years paid more in Abu Dhabi than in England) and the fake players salaries.
https://resources.premierleague.com...7857da2/PL_Handbook_2022-23_DIGITAL_18.07.pdf
here is the rulebook of the PL
But they have to clarify the Roberto Mancini shadow contract (4 years paid more in Abu Dhabi than in England) and the fake players salaries.
https://resources.premierleague.com...7857da2/PL_Handbook_2022-23_DIGITAL_18.07.pdf
here is the rulebook of the PL
Jessie Marsch as manager....
Or Nathan Jones
Or Nathan Jones
sacrifice Shaun’s Goater
Jokes aside they genuinely should lose all Premiere Leagues + Cups won in the period they've been investigated for.
This is a team owned by people richer than most people could imagine.....A fine is pointless.
Deducting points or relegating them is also pointless, it just means they get to keep anything they've won while cheating.
Reality is, they'll prob get a fine and some points off next season. The Prem want to keep attracting the big investors.
This is a team owned by people richer than most people could imagine.....A fine is pointless.
Deducting points or relegating them is also pointless, it just means they get to keep anything they've won while cheating.
Reality is, they'll prob get a fine and some points off next season. The Prem want to keep attracting the big investors.
Keown proves he's a feckin moron, once again.
'If City provide the information then one assumes they clear their name'
What the feck???
Punish Arteta as well, he was an accomplice.
15 points deduction to Arsenal and City
15 points deduction to Arsenal and City
Give them a test.
If they manage to fill their stadium for every game until the end of the season, no action will be taken, fail and you're relegated - no actors or blow up dolls allowed.
If they manage to fill their stadium for every game until the end of the season, no action will be taken, fail and you're relegated - no actors or blow up dolls allowed.
Stripped of all prem titles, which are then awarded retrospectively to second placed clubs.
Assigned to 20th place in prem at end of season.
3 year transfer ban.
Long bans for owners and others implicated.
Assigned to 20th place in prem at end of season.
3 year transfer ban.
Long bans for owners and others implicated.
1. Stripped of all their titles - no champions for those seasons, not even second place get it for obvious reasons.
2. Twenty points deductions for current season or potentially relegate the cnuts.
3. Transfer ban for the next 3 windows.
2. Twenty points deductions for current season or potentially relegate the cnuts.
3. Transfer ban for the next 3 windows.
Now we’re talking
Nice one alright.That and City having to be run by the same folk that run Everton.
Surely no one deserves that much punishment though?
Last edited:
Strip the titles, relegate them with no promotion clause for few years.
Stripped of ownership and titles, relegation, points deduction for each season they cheated in, transfer and sponsorship bans.
For season 2005-2006 calciopoli Juve got relegated and Inter became champions. This should be applied to City.
Relegation paired with a transfer ban is the only option that actually punishes them.
A point deduction just means they wont play Champions League next year which would all but guarantee them another title in 23/24. A financial penalty against people with unthinkable amounts of wealth will do nothing and might even encourage more cheating. You have to remove them from top flight competition and stop them from spending their monopoly money or you might as well drop the charges right now.
A point deduction just means they wont play Champions League next year which would all but guarantee them another title in 23/24. A financial penalty against people with unthinkable amounts of wealth will do nothing and might even encourage more cheating. You have to remove them from top flight competition and stop them from spending their monopoly money or you might as well drop the charges right now.
owners should be banned from owning a PL club and forced to sell
Strip their titles and award to second place, don't need to relegate them but a points deduction, and going forward have an independent arbiter given complete and ongoing access to all their accounts with the ability to review sponsorships and the like to make sure they reflect fair market value.
Seems fair to me, not overly punitive but ensures fairness going forward and removes their success gained previously, it's not as massively unlikely as things like relegation to league 2 or whatever
Seems fair to me, not overly punitive but ensures fairness going forward and removes their success gained previously, it's not as massively unlikely as things like relegation to league 2 or whatever
You do know who came in second place more often than not right?
Nah, strip of all titles during that period and do a rangers on them too by forcing them to begin again from the bottom. They can compete with wrexham.
If its up to 2017/18 then us twice. If up to the present day both us and Liverpool get 3 more each
Normally I’d be against title stripping and relegations but the fact they have behaved arrogantly about everything, I think they deserve the harshest of punishments. They have done everything in their power to prolong and derail investigations. If they were so innocent they would have just handed everything over and given everyone the middle finger when the results were published. Honestly they’re disgusting.
just like how everyone said that those breaches are unprecedented, so the punishment should also be as harsh as they should be. Relegation is a minimum I think if we consider poorer clubs who got relegated for 'less serious'' issue.
I hope Pep absolutely destroys them in the media and walks away, he's Pep, he'll find a job in football. Then hope no reputed/talented manager works for them.
This will hurt them in the long run more than a point deduction or stripping them off any titles.
This will hurt them in the long run more than a point deduction or stripping them off any titles.
Juve got relegated just for a little match fixing. Should also be stripped titles and a Euro ban for five years. That stops the attraction for top players no matter how much money they can offer.
The phrase "hypothetical punishment" needs to there in the title.
They will get away with it, just like always.
They will get away with it, just like always.
UEFA won’t be taking away their Champions League Medals that’s for sure.
If they get caught they will be punished or no one would take EPL serious anymore.
What would be point of the league if one team can cheat for over a decade and get away with it. And teams and fans would always ask did they cheat again.
I feel this is the most fair solution. Also all the directors and executives that were involved should be banned from doing any functions again. They can give a ban to the club for few years or something but the fans shouldn't suffer as much as the people who cheated and tainted the club's name.