What bollocks have I said? De Gea has carried us in the post SAF era.You call somebody's post bollocks and then follow it up with some of your own bollocks.
Good effort
But apparently he makes Smalling, Jones and Young “worse”
De Gea contract talk | Signs new deal
- Thread starter Samid
- Start date
-
In the latest episode of the United Hour Podcast, Nik (@Rood) was joined by comedian Ali Woods to look back at the best and worst moments of a rollercoaster season with the annual United Hour Awards.
Has Ten Hag been sacked yet? We're not sure and we hope not, but it's looking more likely as the days pass.
Who should replace him and why is it taking so long to make a decision?
- Status
But apparently he makes Smalling, Jones and Young “worse”
Going to a team that are guaranteed CL football and also that will win titles even if it's in a lesser league. Compare that to competing for the top 4 cup.
Some of our fans are living in the past. We aren't the best anymore. We're not even second or third.
Don't blame if he goes. He wasting his best years in a big club but a very very average team.
Im not living in the past. Im simply stating that being keeper for PSG is the easiest job in football. Its not as if he would go there for their CL pedigree ffs.
Nobody gives a shit about the French league title hence the meltdown every season when they are eliminated from the only competition they care about.
Not everything needs to be this overreaching arc that signifies this and that. Narratives in football means nothing no matter how many essays are written
Bollocks. They may play in a tinpot league but it's better winning that than nothing.
We are lucky he's stayed as long as he has. He's won 1 title and 0 CL's. That's not good enough for a player of his calibre.
Winning a title in an oil club against outmatched opposition means nothing to fans outside of France.
Literally nothing. Have you posted in their league thread this year? How many watch alongs have you participated in?
Not all trophies are created equal. A lot of players value competition and challenges over walkover titles.
He may as well join Celtic as PSG
PSG really don’t take losing to teams lightly do they.
Looking forward to seeing Henderson in the prem. Stars are aligning for him.
He's not going to sign a new contract. Get the money and move on.
PSG are really taking that loss to United hard. Can’t wait for their world record bid for Lingard next.
For Ole, retaining the services of David De Gea would be his first big signing of the season. I must confess, I was veering towards supporting the sale of De Gea because I do not under any circumstances support the idea of players holding the club to ransom. No-one, but no-one is bigger than the club.
Current performances, notwithstanding, David De Gea is for me the best goalkeeper in the world and one of probably two truly world class players that United have. If United can convince De Gea to sign, it will be a massive statement of intent, especially given that we will be in the Europa League next season. Hopefully, it will also be a positive sign to other current players (eg: Paul Pogba) who are hedging their bets and options for next season.
That said, if United cannot convince him to sign, we should try and get as much money as we can for him and move on. We need to be rid of him quickly to minimise disruption to the squad.
Current performances, notwithstanding, David De Gea is for me the best goalkeeper in the world and one of probably two truly world class players that United have. If United can convince De Gea to sign, it will be a massive statement of intent, especially given that we will be in the Europa League next season. Hopefully, it will also be a positive sign to other current players (eg: Paul Pogba) who are hedging their bets and options for next season.
That said, if United cannot convince him to sign, we should try and get as much money as we can for him and move on. We need to be rid of him quickly to minimise disruption to the squad.
Bye, next.
It appeared he was gone a while ago.
Last edited by a moderator:
I say feck them all. Not one player this season apart from McTominay deserves anything. NBC just showed the highlights of our league competition smashing it in Europe while this team celebrated just as much after a fluky win in Paris.
I love De Gea but this isn't the 1st time te has tried to get out of the club. I also think this club needs a keeper with better distribution, more dominance in the box and with VAR coming in (ffs Smalling will be a common utterance) someone who can save a penalty not taken by Leighton Baines.
Happy for him to stay but right now I feel the same if he leaves for a big chunk.
Also, thinking long-term, it's not inconceivable that DDG is a Casillas category keeper in terms of how he's most likely to age.
Currently, he's the best shot stopper in the world but, as others have said, he hasn't really come on leaps and bounds in other areas. It seems downright unlikely that he'll look like a VDS five years from now.
If he wants out, this could be the right time for both parties.
Currently, he's the best shot stopper in the world but, as others have said, he hasn't really come on leaps and bounds in other areas. It seems downright unlikely that he'll look like a VDS five years from now.
If he wants out, this could be the right time for both parties.
Definitely not this season. Put someone like Lloris, Allisson, Ederson, Fabianski, Guaita, Leno, Foster in goal, and I would argue that we'd much better off. De gea has performed no better than a midtable goalkeeper this season.
Granted that our defence has to do more defending than Liverpool's, but Allisson also doesn't need to save many shots because he helps his defence to stop the opposition from getting shots away. Liverpool defend with four defenders and a goalkeeper; we defend with four defenders, and a shot stopper. Our centre forwards do more defending than our goalkeeper.
He's nowhere near to being the best keeper in the world, he's severely limited, he's just a shot stopper, doesn't command his area and most certainly doesn't organise the defence in front of him which are major failings in a top class keeper.
We didn't try to sell him.
"Trying to sell" indicates that we were the active part in him potentially leaving.
Did we try to sell Cristiano Ronaldo as well ?
This.
So Dave handed in a transfer request and wanted to leave for Real? Or he was dithering on a contract so we accepted a bid from Real to shift him before he went on a free? Which one is it?
Sell him. Goalkeeper is the least of our problems. We can use the money to strengthen areas where we really need to improve: RB, Midfield, RW, and Stricker.
Bizarre that you're actually trying to spin this....He wasn't dithering on a contract, we wanted him to stay and he wanted a move to Real Madrid (hardly a surprise). The club was happy for him to see out his contract unless we received a good enough offer for him. We were in no way whatsoever the active part in that transfer saga.
So lets make it a problem by selling the reason it's the least of our problems ?
Indeed
If he doesn't want to renew then ok we loose him on a free next summer, we've got enough to do this summer without replacing the keeper as well (and no Romero is not good enough before someone chimes in with that)
Mitten saying we offered him a highly paid contract and he hasn’t taken it.
Looks like we should just cash in if that’s the case.
Looks like we should just cash in if that’s the case.
Ciao adios.
If he doesn't sign a new contract anytime soon then
we should tell him he will be benched if he tries to remain at United and get a better contract from another club next year.
Need to avoid another Herrera situation
we should tell him he will be benched if he tries to remain at United and get a better contract from another club next year.
Need to avoid another Herrera situation
He should hand in a transfer request if he wants to leave. Hate these games.
Which clubs are moving on to sign him ? PSG ?
At this point just get rid before he ends up leaving on a free. Cash in while you can ffs...
DDG off then? Pogba probably too? Ole hasn't got a prayer next season. Our fanbase and the media just won't afford him the time this job now needs. I'm willing to give it to him as I can see just how long the way back is. Don't think many will though.
PSG, Juve are the only ones I can think of that would be a step up for him and could actually afford him.
French league shouldn't be all that appealing, of course, but who knows, he will definitely get top dollar there..
I don't really see an option out there for him. Maybe PSG, but they surely have bigger needs and also have to keep FFP in mind. But other than that? I doubt Juve would make a move, neither would Bayern. No option in Spain either right now.
Yeah same. Can't think of other two teams. Madrid are crazy but with Courtois and their current state they won't need to spend loads on other positions first.
PSG seems to be the most logical thing as Buffon was a stop gap.
PSG would be doing us a favor offering anything around or north of £50m this summer.
Can go join his mate at PSG, if those stories about wages on offer are true. He’s certainly not helped his case over the last year.
Would PSG invest that much money in GK tho? They don't strike me as a team that would prioritize the GK position. Can keep up with Areola or Trapp who will return from loan.
Henderson and Romero are more than good enough for next season. I just hope we get as much money for him as possible and invest it into outfield signings..
They might have a reason as their defensive side is usually the reason of their downfall every year in CL so might think of getting a top shot stopping GK as David to improve it.
This attitude will see us end up as 9th or 10th best club in England. DDG had a bad season but he's still one of the best keepers in the world.
If we lose DDG n Pogba this summer god only knows what's going to happen to us and Ole next season. It won't be pretty.
De Gea is unraveling. He’s been poor for over a year now and a total liability in spells for us and Spain.
I’m so sick of hearing how Manchester United will perish if he and our other supposed talisman leave.
It’s total rubbish.
I’m honestly more worried about no one stumping up a proper fee this summer and us ending up with two uncommitted players again next season.
- Status