I think the lack of any surprises (though this isn't really their fault, as there's even more leaks these days with social media managers and all that added to the mix, it's no longer a few devs having a little too much whiskey and saying too much on forums) or big drops stops it being anywhere near the best for me. But as I said, we did get games and for that I'm happy with it.
Though with my old memory and the fact most of my favourite ones would have been live there, I'm not the best placed to remember what ones were better and what were worse historically