Go. I've been a supporter until now but the players we have are good enough to be doing so much better. If Moyes can't get anything out of these then buying more won't solve the issues.
End of Season. Moyes to Stay or Go Poll
- Thread starter Dracula
- Start date
-
In the latest episode of the United Hour Podcast, Nik @Rood and Imran @Annihilate Now! start with the good news by celebrating Manchester United Women's emphatic FA Cup win over Spurs at Wembley and the future of manager Marc Skinner.
Then it's the bad news and the ever worsening form of our Men with losses to Arsenal and Palace.
Finally the main debate - ETH Out now or keep him until the end of the season - if not longer. Are you Team Nik or Team Imran?
Cheers.
I voted that I want him to go but that is only if we can get a world class manager who has won things and can get us playing good football. I don't want him sacked if it means taking a punt on a Hughes/Bruce/Martinez and the like. Look at actual credentials this time maybe, like any other job in the world.
Do I want him to go yes, do I think he will? No
He's probably the most secure manager in the league.
He's probably the most secure manager in the league.
Every time I convince myself he needs to go we end up winning the next game which prompts me to think he should be given more chances, then we get embarrassed.
Nah, I'm a fan of democracy.
Good lord what a horrifying thought!
I don't think there's much between Hughes, Bruce and Moyes.
But the "stay" voters, are they United fans? Im thinking some of them support other teams.
You couldn't get 96% of people to agree the earth is round. Unbelievable.
My opinion since the start has been that he should go if we fail to qualify for the Champions League. I just don't see how someone who has prevailed over this disasterous season can suddenly come back next year and inspire our players to a decent season. It's not just a matter of getting rid of certain players and replacing them. He needed to show this season that he was capable of managing at the highest level and he has failed. I don't think he is the right manager for us. Whatever difficult circumstances he has faced this season donot justify our poor season. 4th place should be the bare minimum for us.
In 26 minutes 103 votes to go.
Even the Gods wants him out..
Been a life long United fan, only 25 years old too.
Some of them are apparently.
Delusion has set in if people think giving Moyes £150m will just solve our problems.
We need to give the 5 'Stay' voters the psychiatric help they so sorely need.
I'm interested in why they want him to stay. @FortBoyard , why do you want Moyes to stay?
Stay ,give him another season.
Sounds good. But do enlighten us; Why should he stay?
Close one so far.
I think he'll be a millstone around the neck of the club unfortunately. I don't think investment in the summer will be enough; ultimately even if we bring together a good squad of players, we will be competing with a manager who is inarguably less-capable than those at all our main rivals in the league.
Hiring a second-rate manager got us into this mess... let's not repeat that.
Go. Not end of season, NOW.
Giggs might get us through against Olmypiakos and grab a point against City.
Giggs might get us through against Olmypiakos and grab a point against City.
Because I do not think he has had enough time to judge whether he'll be a complete flop or not yet.
120-5
fecking hell. How did he get 5 votes?
fecking hell. How did he get 5 votes?
True, but even having somebody like Giggs as caretaker manager would be an improvement at the moment. We should go for a top manager, but keep Giggs or somebody like that as caretaker boss until somebody does become available. Van gaal for example is probably going to spurs in the summer but no chance would he pick them ahead of United if the job became available.
The two blokes haven't aged a day. Lying in a cryogenic freeze all this time waiting for their moment of vindication.
Do you think that he'll be a complete flop or not if he doesn't get sacked?
Go.Out of his depth and not learning from his mistakes.
We're actually going to finish below Everton.
What?
Really? I'm amazed how you can't see it now. No change in how we play since he started. He hasn't even attempted to create a new philosophy.
I commend your optimism, but you're more deluded than I thought.
I'm out, we're all disappointed with the result today, no need to start taking it out on people just believing in what they think is right.
I remember way back in June/July time, when a few suggested that we may fall out of the top 4 under Moyes, and all it invoked was laughing green smileys, like the author of that opinion was completely unhinged from sanity.
It's weird how the ridiculous has come to fruition. I didn't think it would happen either.
He has to go. And I hope he's replaced by some lunatic tactical virtuoso, like Bielsa or Klopp. None of this longevity shite. If anything, what we really need is a stop gap, to bridge the monumental change between Sir Alex and the Post-Sir Alex eras.
It's not going to get easier any time soon either. I predict we'll win on Wednesday, but not enough to take us through, so that'll be Champions League football gone for a while. And City are going to kick the feck out of us, good and proper.
It's weird how the ridiculous has come to fruition. I didn't think it would happen either.
He has to go. And I hope he's replaced by some lunatic tactical virtuoso, like Bielsa or Klopp. None of this longevity shite. If anything, what we really need is a stop gap, to bridge the monumental change between Sir Alex and the Post-Sir Alex eras.
It's not going to get easier any time soon either. I predict we'll win on Wednesday, but not enough to take us through, so that'll be Champions League football gone for a while. And City are going to kick the feck out of us, good and proper.
If he doesn't get sacked, do you think that he'll be a success here? Or are you simply keeping an agnostic thinking that we still don't know how good/bad he will be?
Or let me reprase the question, if Moyes gets another 2 years and 200m for transfers, do you think that it is more likely for us to be one of the top clubs in the world again, or a club that fights for the fourth place?
You're so fragile.
He's going to crack eventually, his odds are great.
I still don't get that first question, if he doesn't get sacked that means what?
For your rephrase, I'd like to think we'd be up there challenging.
I voted go, what if big name players won't sign for us in the summer, not because of CL but because of the manager? We could end up signing panic buys again.