You’re not what you were, but the PL outside the top 2 is pretty damn poor to average, to the point Leicester have a hope of getting in this season. We are in disarray, Chelsea are a bunch of kids but still up there, and Arsenal are .. Arsenal, with United in a mess too.
You would have enough quality about you to comfortably get third, I think. Wouldn’t be near the top two but the rest are even more inconsistent than you think you are. None of the other top 4 contenders in the PL, even on their most perfect days, could do what you did to us.