GuybrushThreepwood
Full Member
- Joined
- Mar 22, 2019
- Messages
- 1,167
- Supports
- Blackburn Rovers
It's interesting that quite a few people on the left don't particularly like John McDonnell any more.
I guess quite a few of them blame him for strongly pushing Labour to promise a 2nd EU referendum, which Corbyn was very reluctant to do, which attributed to the 2019 GE result (playing down the Corbyn factor). But I strongly disagree with that; if Labour's Brexit position had been just to pursue a new, 'soft' Brexit deal, and they went into that election promising neither another EU referendum to satisfy remainers, or leaving the EU by January 31st 2020 (so the Tories' 'Get Brexit Done' slogan still would have been devastatingly effective) to satisfy leavers, I just don't see how they would have done any better.
It was of course well known that Corbyn and McDonnell, while not bitterly feuding or becoming enemies or anything, became less close from 2018. I've seen some people on the left, such as those that work for Novara Media, criticise McDonnell for becoming 'obsessed with winning' after the 2017 GE result. That seems like a ridiculous criticism. He was the shadow chancellor and 2nd in command of a party that was pretty close to power in terms of parliamentary arithmetic after the 2017 GE, and knew that unless they entered government they couldn't enact any of the policies or 'radical agenda'' that they wanted. He was clearly frustrated that the momentum from the 2017 GE result was basically lost by early to mid 2018. He was also criticised for being interviewed by Alistair Campbell for GQ magazine. But again, a Labour shadow chancellor being interviewed by former and successful Labour strategist and also long-standing Labour party member (though he was kicked out after the 2019 European elections), should not be controversial. I didn't blame Corbyn for refusing to share a platform with Cameron during the 2016 EU referendum, but I did blame him for refusing to share a platform with Kinnock, Blair and Brown (i.e. in a rally involving all living people that had led the Labour party) during it.
While I'm far more sympathetic to the left than the right (i.e. I would find significantly more to agree with Corbyn on than Farage), there are similarities in terms of people who deviate even a bit from a set agenda / narrative / direction, being criticised as sellouts, turncoats, traitors etc. For example people who enthusiastically supported Trump during the 2020 presidential election campaign but then refused to buy the crackpot theories that the result was stolen, were criticised as 'lefties in disguise'. And people who grew up very much on the left of the Labour party, as 'Bennites' etc,. but realised that compromises had to make to gain power (i.e. promising a hugely radical agenda but remaining stuck in opposition is far worse than promising a still pretty radical agenda but more pragmatic one but winning elections and actually being able to implement it), also get heavily criticised.
I guess quite a few of them blame him for strongly pushing Labour to promise a 2nd EU referendum, which Corbyn was very reluctant to do, which attributed to the 2019 GE result (playing down the Corbyn factor). But I strongly disagree with that; if Labour's Brexit position had been just to pursue a new, 'soft' Brexit deal, and they went into that election promising neither another EU referendum to satisfy remainers, or leaving the EU by January 31st 2020 (so the Tories' 'Get Brexit Done' slogan still would have been devastatingly effective) to satisfy leavers, I just don't see how they would have done any better.
It was of course well known that Corbyn and McDonnell, while not bitterly feuding or becoming enemies or anything, became less close from 2018. I've seen some people on the left, such as those that work for Novara Media, criticise McDonnell for becoming 'obsessed with winning' after the 2017 GE result. That seems like a ridiculous criticism. He was the shadow chancellor and 2nd in command of a party that was pretty close to power in terms of parliamentary arithmetic after the 2017 GE, and knew that unless they entered government they couldn't enact any of the policies or 'radical agenda'' that they wanted. He was clearly frustrated that the momentum from the 2017 GE result was basically lost by early to mid 2018. He was also criticised for being interviewed by Alistair Campbell for GQ magazine. But again, a Labour shadow chancellor being interviewed by former and successful Labour strategist and also long-standing Labour party member (though he was kicked out after the 2019 European elections), should not be controversial. I didn't blame Corbyn for refusing to share a platform with Cameron during the 2016 EU referendum, but I did blame him for refusing to share a platform with Kinnock, Blair and Brown (i.e. in a rally involving all living people that had led the Labour party) during it.
While I'm far more sympathetic to the left than the right (i.e. I would find significantly more to agree with Corbyn on than Farage), there are similarities in terms of people who deviate even a bit from a set agenda / narrative / direction, being criticised as sellouts, turncoats, traitors etc. For example people who enthusiastically supported Trump during the 2020 presidential election campaign but then refused to buy the crackpot theories that the result was stolen, were criticised as 'lefties in disguise'. And people who grew up very much on the left of the Labour party, as 'Bennites' etc,. but realised that compromises had to make to gain power (i.e. promising a hugely radical agenda but remaining stuck in opposition is far worse than promising a still pretty radical agenda but more pragmatic one but winning elections and actually being able to implement it), also get heavily criticised.