Don't forget Fred the Red and the washing machine lady.
Jose Mourinho v Ryan Giggs... who do you want? [POLL]
- Thread starter Raees
- Start date
-
In the latest episode of the United Hour Podcast, Nik @Rood and Imran @Annihilate Now! start with the good news by celebrating Manchester United Women's emphatic FA Cup win over Spurs at Wembley and the future of manager Marc Skinner.
Then it's the bad news and the ever worsening form of our Men with losses to Arsenal and Palace.
Finally the main debate - ETH Out now or keep him until the end of the season - if not longer. Are you Team Nik or Team Imran?
- Status
Lets just pretend this never happened.
I get this feeling too which is what makes me uneasy about the whole thing.
Dang, first Walrus, and now you too. I'm getting good at this sarcasm lark aren't I.
I have the same impression.
I'm hoping someone with common sense on the board sees reason, otherwise only God knows where we're headed.
Giggs has better hair.
No worries pal I went through a similar phase where even the likes of Eyepopper lost their shit with me.Dang, first Walrus, and now you too. I'm getting good at this sarcasm lark aren't I.
That is exactly what happened.
There's no logical reason as to why Giggs should get the job. Knowing the club inside out means feck all if you can't manage a team properly and nobody knows whether he can. For a club of our supposed size and ambitions it would be insane to hire him. Too much of a risk to take when Mourinho is available.
There are actually 24 supposed United fans who want Giggs ahead of Jose?
Oppo fans would love to see Giggs be appointed.
is this statistically sound
I feel the same way too, if he doesn't get the Utd job I bet he won't bother trying anywhere else and if he does get it and screws it up I can see him just saying ah well I tried but don't think being a manager is for me, really cant see him buckling down and trying to be successful somewhere else, if he thought like that he'd already be doing it.
OK, so that's 95% approval rating from a cross section of fans. So … what are we waiting for then 
Ed? Ed, are you there? Ed? Ed?
Ed? Ed, are you there? Ed? Ed?
Admin should find out who they are and give them lifetime bans! WUMs
I voted for Giggs, but would also welcome Mourinho. He couldn't do worse than Van Gaal.
This poll is a landslide
Just click on the number of votes and you can see who it is
@Invictus you voted for Giggs? Wum surely??
I wouldn't say i'd ''love'' to see Giggs take over from van Gaal, but i'd be very intrigued to see how the man Bryan Robson labelled the Pep Guardiola of United fares were he to take charge.
Probably some just don't like Mourinho. Invictus is voting Giggs for the lols.
Just click on the number
Add me to the Giggs camp.
The only reservation I have about Giggs, is that he might be too nice of a guy to succeed in the cut throat world of the premiership elite. That's why I'd like to see how he would handle being thrown into the lions den right now, even if it was just till the end of the season.
I prefer a 3rd option
No I think he might have a ruthless side to him considering the stories about his brother
I'm sure Giggs has plenty of ruthlessness in him, seen as no skirt is off the table.
LVG has United sitting in 5th with about 11 first team injuries and was tasked with rebuilding United. Giggs could absolutely do worse--much worse.
'Supposed fan'?
Yep... that's me. My season ticket and the fact I spend a fortune watching my team play home and away is just a lavish front and I do it purely for espionage!
Opposition fans votes shouldn't be counted here - it's not their club's future on the line
Do please elaborate on why it is you think Giggs is qualified to be the next United manager then.'Supposed fan'?
Yep... that's me. My season ticket and the fact I spend a fortune watching my team play home and away is just a lavish front and I do it purely for espionage!
Being around Sir Alex for a long long time is not exactly a great reason, a quick look at Neville's record at Valencia tells the story.
Well, no one voting really decides anything about the club, be it opposition or United fans.
Tbf the Sunday Supplement hacks this morning acknowledged (somewhat in shock) that Giggs does not have the fans' support for the job in general, certainly not in the face of someone like Mourinho, so at least some of them know the situation as we perceive it.
It really comes to something when fans like me prefer José Bloody Mourinho to a modern-day legend of the club; but that's how seriously I (and no doubt many others) view our situation. Something has to change, dramatically so.
Because he is the second coming of Pep, ghez don't you know anything?
My mistake, we're so desperate not to run the club the way Perez does we should be appointing a recently retired legend with very very little management experience.
Isn't that exactly what Perez did?
I see some Bayern fans voting for Giggs. What have we ever done to them?
- Status