Wonder if agents of players with knee surgeries are the ones responsible for planting stories about clubs' interest in their clients. If that's the case-I suspect United will be linked to Strootman for as long as LVG is United's manager.
Kevin Strootman
- Thread starter Someone
- Start date
- Status
and that is it i believe.
should look at other option now..
should look at other option now..
On the plus side if we want him his value has plummeted. 20m at most now had to be what he's worth. Still a gamble but a much safer one than north of 30 that was floating around.
Kevin Strootman’s knee surgery did not go perfectly, says ex-Roma doctor
• Former club medic speculates there may be ‘no way out’
• Louis van Gaal: Manchester United’s priority is creative midfielder
Kevin Strootman made his comeback for Roma in November but suffered a relapse of his knee injury in January. Photograph: Federico Proietti/AGF/Rex
Guardian sport
Monday 23 February 2015 13.05 GMT
A former Roma club doctor believes Kevin Strootman’s latest injury problems have come about because previous surgery on his injured knee ‘did not go perfectly’, speculating that there may be ‘no way out’ for the Dutch midfielder.
Strootman, a long time target of Manchester United’s manager, Louis van Gaal, picked up the initial injury in March and underwent subsequent surgery which ruled him out of Holland’s World Cup campaign.
The 25-year-old returned to action with Roma in November but suffered a relapse in January, was forced under the knife again and with no time frame set for his return, may not play again this season.
Van Gaal reportedly remains interested in signing Strootman, provided he makes a full comeback, but Mario Brozzi, previously part of Roma’s medical staff, fears prolonged complications for the midfielder.
“My impression is that the surgery on Strootman’s ligament did not go perfectly,” Brozzi has told La Partita Perfetta on Gold TV. “I don’t know what happened to his knee, but his Cyclops syndrome results from a problem in the ligament’s position.
“The cartilaginous damage is determined by the extensive deficit. Now, if this is the situation, I see no way out. But it’s not up to me to say whether further surgery is needed.”
• Former club medic speculates there may be ‘no way out’
• Louis van Gaal: Manchester United’s priority is creative midfielder
Kevin Strootman made his comeback for Roma in November but suffered a relapse of his knee injury in January. Photograph: Federico Proietti/AGF/Rex
Guardian sport
Monday 23 February 2015 13.05 GMT
A former Roma club doctor believes Kevin Strootman’s latest injury problems have come about because previous surgery on his injured knee ‘did not go perfectly’, speculating that there may be ‘no way out’ for the Dutch midfielder.
Strootman, a long time target of Manchester United’s manager, Louis van Gaal, picked up the initial injury in March and underwent subsequent surgery which ruled him out of Holland’s World Cup campaign.
The 25-year-old returned to action with Roma in November but suffered a relapse in January, was forced under the knife again and with no time frame set for his return, may not play again this season.
Van Gaal reportedly remains interested in signing Strootman, provided he makes a full comeback, but Mario Brozzi, previously part of Roma’s medical staff, fears prolonged complications for the midfielder.
“My impression is that the surgery on Strootman’s ligament did not go perfectly,” Brozzi has told La Partita Perfetta on Gold TV. “I don’t know what happened to his knee, but his Cyclops syndrome results from a problem in the ligament’s position.
“The cartilaginous damage is determined by the extensive deficit. Now, if this is the situation, I see no way out. But it’s not up to me to say whether further surgery is needed.”
£40 mil it is then? Screw it, give them £50mil.
Get someone else, then maybe in a few years after he's fully recovered he can be a squad option if we really want him
Surely that has to be that as far as our interest goes, it would be mind boggling stupid to even consider buying him until he gets another full season of good performances under his belt for Roma.
That should be an end to that.
I'd hope so
Has to be (if its true of course)I'd hope so
Of course I wouldn't put it past us to sign him anyway.
There's no way in hell we're buying him now. None.
Feel sorry for him and hope he gets back to full fitness. Moyes should have bought him in 2013.
Poor guy, can't help but feel bad for him.
It'll be an absolute joke if we still buy him after all this.
It'll be an absolute joke if we still buy him after all this.
Yep, I've heard LvG is a stubborn dutchman
But yeah, would be absolutely shocking if we bought him now, after pulling out of the Vidal deal for something similar.
Van Gaal seriously has to forget about Strootman now and instead go for Schneiderlin. Schneiderlin would be very getable, is not a crock and would be half the price of all our other central midfield targets with the potential to be as good
We need to finish in the top4 and hope Southampton don't to get Schneiderlin
So there's some talk in Italy that his career is over, which is terrible news for him, if true of course.
What is his condition, surely it's not career-ending?
Does he have a degenerative issue in his knee?
Owen Hargreaves all over again.
Poor bloke, was turning into a cracking midfielder that would have went onto have a very good career. Hope it isn't as bad as they fear.
Is he going to turn into another Brazilian Ronaldo, Saha, or Hargreaves with chronic injuries for years?
He is gone next summer. Not making the top 4 would only be dangerous, if United is really interested, if Arsenal go in for him and offer him similar wages, with the possible added incentive of European football
He was pissed about not being able to leave last summer. I think he's playing for a transfer at this point
Cartilage problems apparently, from what I've read about it. Cartilage protects the bones and the joints and stuff. Will never grow back. But he had another surgery where they made some holes in his ligament and the blood will form scarr tissue that replaces the missing cartilage - will never be as strong as the real stuff though.
But he can recover, only having a dodgy knee at 24 isn't ideal, especially for the longivity of his career and it's likely to be a permanent weak spot. No reason anymore to sign him now.
But he can recover, only having a dodgy knee at 24 isn't ideal, especially for the longivity of his career and it's likely to be a permanent weak spot. No reason anymore to sign him now.
Hopefully he can get the issue fixed but it sounds like it may take quite some time.
How trust worthy is the opinion of an ex Roma doctor, considering how much Roma want to hang on to Strootman?
Bit naughty from the ex Roma doctor? No? @Pogue Mahone ?
Either way I think that ship long sailed.
I also think Van Gaal's interest was overplayed. He was essential to his plans for the Dutch, no doubt about that but then that's down to the fact he could only choose from a pool of Dutch players. There's other options out there and I'd be we've already started the move for them.
I hope his career isn't over though, terrible at his age.
Either way I think that ship long sailed.
I also think Van Gaal's interest was overplayed. He was essential to his plans for the Dutch, no doubt about that but then that's down to the fact he could only choose from a pool of Dutch players. There's other options out there and I'd be we've already started the move for them.
I hope his career isn't over though, terrible at his age.
Think so too. He often changed his formation depending on the opposition, but it was essential either Du Guzman or Wijnaldum playing next to De Jong. Considering his lack of options, its no wonder he was relying so heavily on Strootman
His career is in doubt I hear. It's that bad..
SO is he going for more surgery then? As sad as his injury is we need to end all interest in him. We do not need another promising midfielder with a bad knee.
From what the surgeon says that could be difficult as there isn't much left to work with. You can't polish a turd as they say.
Knee blown to smithereens, former medical staff painting a pessimistic picture, comparisons to Ledley King's knees being made:
If his knee is as bad as rumoured, surely our medical staff would put the kibosh on any transfer. Wouldn't they?Yep, I've heard LvG is a stubborn dutchman
But yeah, would be absolutely shocking if we bought him now, after pulling out of the Vidal deal for something similar.
You dont need knees when you have the philosophy.
This should be printed on a tee-shirt.
I sent my CV to T Shirts United but I never heard back.
FFS AdebesiThat would be the logical move yeah....or we might just refuse to reinforce and wait another 12 months for Strootman
...who might never kick a ball again. Those who don't learn from history, they say, are doomed to repeat it. I see Hargreaves MkII heading our way.
That would be the logical move yeah....or we might just refuse to reinforce and wait another 12 months for Strootman
FFS! Let's hope not
Happy for him. Hope he can come back. Be a shame if this did end his career.
- Status