Mikel Arteta | Lego Pep watch

The Red Thinker

Full Member
Joined
Jul 28, 2010
Messages
4,151
Location
Knowhere
Elite Coach? Maybe.

Elite Manager? You havin'alauuugh

He seems to enjoy going out to the public and dishing on every single decision made. Recipe for disaster. Imagine how motivated Saliba must feel right now to play for Arsenal. Especially at a time, when that defence NEEDS help. "wE HaVe MAdE a DeCIsiON!" is arrogant and poor man-management.

We had some DARK times at this club, when the midfield was unreliable with inconsistent Fred, run-around Mctominay and an injured Pogba. Matic badmouthing the manager. The attacking impetus was Rashford and Martial. That's it.

Arsenal have a similar problem. No creative assets in midfield, and their best DM, Partey, is injured. Leno has been inconstitent, just like De Gea was.

No squad depth, just like United. In this moment... When you have an Ozil just sitting around on a HUGE salary - just like Sanchez was - it would be criminal to openly put down the player. Bad for squad harmony. Sanchez was injured a lot and Ole never once put him down in the press when at the club. Arteta has chosen war without the clout of having any real long term success. The great managers would get Ozil onside. He's done for.
 

Bobcat

Full Member
Joined
Feb 2, 2014
Messages
6,388
Location
Behind the curtains, leering at the neighbors
Like every other manager today, Arteta has little or no say on the players brought into the club. Yet, at clubs which are struggling and been on a down curve for years, its always the managers who take the flack for years of sub standard player recruitment, but we never hear of the people responsible for crap signing after crap signing ever getting the sacked.
They're like the officers at the Charge of The Light Brigade pointing the finger at the next in line below them.
We dont really know how they do transfers, and i doubt Arteta has full autonomy, but it would be reasonable to expect he has some say in it. Also, their transfers have not been all bad imo. Auba and Partey are good players and Lacazette was as highly (if not higher) rated than Martial when he arrived, hes just not made the same impact.

The squad is pretty mediocre, but its not that bad and when i watch them i always get the feeling that almost none of these players are playing at full capacity. They look like a bunch or mercenaries who are happy to collect their paychecks, except that unlike the plastic clubs, these players are not that good. Arteta is clearly out of his depth, but honestly i think most managers would have been, because it would take something special to sort this mess out
 

sglowrider

Thinks the caf is 'wokeish'.
Joined
Dec 27, 2009
Messages
25,217
Location
Hell on Earth
Elite Coach? Maybe.

Elite Manager? You havin'alauuugh

He seems to enjoy going out to the public and dishing on every single decision made. Recipe for disaster. Imagine how motivated Saliba must feel right now to play for Arsenal. Especially at a time, when that defence NEEDS help. "wE HaVe MAdE a DeCIsiON!" is arrogant and poor man-management.

We had some DARK times at this club, when the midfield was unreliable with inconsistent Fred, run-around Mctominay and an injured Pogba. Matic badmouthing the manager. The attacking impetus was Rashford and Martial. That's it.

Arsenal have a similar problem. No creative assets in midfield, and their best DM, Partey, is injured. Leno has been inconstitent, just like De Gea was.

No squad depth, just like United. In this moment... When you have an Ozil just sitting around on a HUGE salary - just like Sanchez was - it would be criminal to openly put down the player. Bad for squad harmony. Sanchez was injured a lot and Ole never once put him down in the press when at the club. Arteta has chosen war without the clout of having any real long term success. The great managers would get Ozil onside. He's done for.
Nooo... we need Arteta to stay. I for one, want to see Arsenal play Millwall next season and possibly Grimsby in a couple of seasons after. The banter on AFTV with rival fans would be golden. Ty against Millwall fans....
 

The Red Thinker

Full Member
Joined
Jul 28, 2010
Messages
4,151
Location
Knowhere
Nooo... we need Arteta to stay. I for one, want to see Arsenal play Millwall next season and possibly Grimsby in a couple of seasons after. The banter on AFTV with rival fans would be golden. Ty against Millwall fans....
Good lord...you know that his life won't matter to them lot.
 

thatsme

New Member
Newbie
Joined
Dec 5, 2020
Messages
185
We dont really know how they do transfers, and i doubt Arteta has full autonomy, but it would be reasonable to expect he has some say in it. Also, their transfers have not been all bad imo. Auba and Partey are good players and Lacazette was as highly (if not higher) rated than Martial when he arrived, hes just not made the same impact.

The squad is pretty mediocre, but its not that bad and when i watch them i always get the feeling that almost none of these players are playing at full capacity. They look like a bunch or mercenaries who are happy to collect their paychecks, except that unlike the plastic clubs, these players are not that good. Arteta is clearly out of his depth, but honestly i think most managers would have been, because it would take something special to sort this mess out
I agree with most of what you said.
At best i think the squad is a 6th place outfit, which simply isn't good enough for a club the size of Arsenal. So, no matter who the manager is, it's going to take quite a while before you challenge for the title again.
However, I think its a bit unfair to call the players a bunch of mercenairies. When a team is in a big slump a lot of fans say the players dont care and aren't playing for the manager etc. I just think its simply a case of confidence falling through the floor. Players become timid on the ball and become afraid of making mistakes and trying things and that leads to their minds and bodies working a fraction slower which makes it look like they're not trying as hard as they should be.
If I was an Arsenal fan, I'd give Arteta until at least the end of this season and probably until this time next year to see if he can get the team moving forward.
Too many clubs and their fans dont give managers enough time these days and clubs end up on a merrygoround of managers hoping something will click.
 

Bobcat

Full Member
Joined
Feb 2, 2014
Messages
6,388
Location
Behind the curtains, leering at the neighbors
I agree with most of what you said.
At best i think the squad is a 6th place outfit, which simply isn't good enough for a club the size of Arsenal. So, no matter who the manager is, it's going to take quite a while before you challenge for the title again.
However, I think its a bit unfair to call the players a bunch of mercenairies. When a team is in a big slump a lot of fans say the players dont care and aren't playing for the manager etc. I just think its simply a case of confidence falling through the floor. Players become timid on the ball and become afraid of making mistakes and trying things and that leads to their minds and bodies working a fraction slower which makes it look like they're not trying as hard as they should be.
If I was an Arsenal fan, I'd give Arteta until at least the end of this season and probably until this time next year to see if he can get the team moving forward.
Too many clubs and their fans dont give managers enough time these days and clubs end up on a merrygoround of managers hoping something will click.
Thats reasoable, but this Arsenal side looks like it lacks leaders on the pitch and they have a few to many idiots like Xhaka and Luiz

Quality had also dropped. Its not that long ago they could field Ramsey, Carzola, Sanchez and Ozil in the same XI and besides Auba who have been shite this year there are no one near that quality

They need a complete overhaul
 

OleBoiii

New Member
Joined
Oct 4, 2019
Messages
6,021
Is his team really that bad? It's obviously not as good as the general top 5(Pool Spurs, City, Chelsea and us), but is it that much worse than the likes of Leicester, Southampton and Everton?
 

sglowrider

Thinks the caf is 'wokeish'.
Joined
Dec 27, 2009
Messages
25,217
Location
Hell on Earth
Is his team really that bad? It's obviously not as good as the general top 5(Pool Spurs, City, Chelsea and us), but is it that much worse than the likes of Leicester, Southampton and Everton?
The most expensive front 3 in the league who can't score goals.
 

WeePat

Full Member
Joined
Apr 13, 2015
Messages
17,410
Supports
Chelsea
I can't wait for them to gain promotion back to the top flight in 2027 thanks in large to a couple of Chelsea and Spurs academy players they've had on loan.
 

Haddock

Full Member
Joined
May 25, 2013
Messages
729
Is his team really that bad? It's obviously not as good as the general top 5(Pool Spurs, City, Chelsea and us), but is it that much worse than the likes of Leicester, Southampton and Everton?
Yes, they are that bad.

1. Hector Bellerin - laughable
2. Dani Ceballos - When Andy Gray made that joke about 'wet, windy nights in Stoke' he was playing on the imagined stereotype of the weak, snide, diving, sideways passing, continental fair-weather foreigner. Ceballos somehow managed to embody all those things.
3. Pepe - got some quality but he's basically a left footed Gervinho
4. Willian - still got quality but he's on the wane
5. Xhaka - give him the keys
6. Mohammed El backwards
7. Mustafi - nuff said
8. Kolasinac - see above
9. Cedric Soares - pretty average and on a 4 year deal if I'm not wrong.
10. David Luiz - if he's your best centre half, good luck.

Arsenal fans rave about Tierney but I've seldom seen him make intelligent choices on the pitch. Lacazette has talent but is simply not worth what Arsenal paid for him. He seems to get no criticism in the media comapred to say Martial despite being half the player and cost nearly as much. His goal return has fallen year on year and he's never touched 20 goals a season. They'd kill to have someone as good as Calvert-Lewin ( some caf posters turn their noses up at him) who is going to become a 25 goal a season centre forward.

They spent £27M on this Saliba kid but he hasn't kicked a ball yet so can't be judged. Maitland Niles is alright and Smith-Rowe is supposed to be good too but I've seen little of him. Apart from that Saka and Martinelli have quality but they are kids, they aren't going to put up the numbers like seasoned players. If you pop around to Arsenal forums/subs they cheered Martinelli's return as though it was Fat Ronaldo returning to action which says it all.

Basically the spine of this side - the senior pros are all garbage. Their only top level players are Özil and Auba. One of whom they won't play and the other is not in any way a leader.

Someone brought up West Ham earlier in this thread. You have mentioned Leicester and Southampton. Many of their players are better man for man better and/or better coached.

1. I'd like to ask any Hammers on this forum if they'd swap Soucek, Bowen or Rice for their opposite at Arsenal. They offer goals and composure neither of which can be found in Arsenal's midfield.

2. Watching Southampton play Arsenal recently I was struck by the intelligence and composure shown by Walker-Peters, Ward - Prowse, Vestegaard and Armstrong. These players have clearly improved through coaching. Something Arsenal's haven't done in years and the best example is Walcott who is making sensible decisions and taking up intelligent positions for the first time in 14 years.

3. The Leicester the midfield has Ndidi, Maddison and especially Tielemans who is a glorious player. Justin and Jonny Evans have shown more quality than all the clowns in Arsenal's back four over the last seven years put together. Then there's Schmeichel Jr is, Harvey Barnes and Vardy.


Why is it that Arsenal's board cannot detect shit unless they are knee deep in it? Or maybe they have and don't care.
 
Last edited:

RashyForPM

New Member
Joined
Jun 25, 2020
Messages
3,183
Yes they are that bad.

1. Hector Bellerin - laughable
2. Dani Ceballos - When Andy Gray made that joke about 'wet, windy nights in Stoke' he was playing on the imagined stereotype of the weak, snide, diving, sideways passing, continental fair-weather foreigner. Ceballos somehow managed to embody all those things.
3. Pepe - got some quality but he's basically a left footed Gervinho
4. Willian - still got quality but he's on the wane
5. Xhaka - give him the keys
6. Mohammed El backwards
7. Mustafi - nuff said
8. Kolasinac - see above
9. Cedric Soares - pretty average and on a 4 year deal if I'm not wrong.
10. David Luiz - if he's your best centre half, good luck.

Arsenal fans rave about Tierney but I've seldom seen him make intelligent choices on the pitch. Lacazette has talent but is simply not worth what Arsenal paid for him. He seems to get no criticism in the media comapred to say Martial despite being half the player and cost nearly as much. His goal return has fallen year on year and he's never touched 20 goals a season. They'd kill to have someone as good as Calvert-Lewin ( some caf posters turn their noses up at him) who is going to become a 25 goal a season centre forward.

They spent £27M on this Saliba kid but he hasn't kicked a ball yet so can't be judged. Maitland Niles is alright and Smith-Rowe is supposed to be good too but I've seen little of him. Apart from that Saka and Martinelli have quality but they are kids, they aren't going to put up the numbers like seasoned players. If you pop around to Arsenal forums/subs they cheered Martinelli's return as though it was Fat Ronaldo returning to action which says it all.

Basically the spine of this side - the senior pros are all garbage. Their only top level players are Özil and Auba. One of whom they won't play and the other is not in any way a leader.

Someone brought up West Ham earlier in this thread. You have mentioned Leicester and Southampton. Many of their players are better man for man better and/or better coached.

1. I'd like to ask any Hammers on this forum if they'd swap Soucek, Bowen or Rice for their opposite at Arsenal. They offer goals and composure neither of which can be found in Arsenal's midfield.

2. Watching Southampton play Arsenal recently I was struck by the intelligence and composure shown by Walker-Peters, Ward - Prowse, Vestegaard and Armstrong. These players have clearly improved through coaching. Something Arsenal's haven't done in years and the best example is Walcott who is making sensible decisions and taking up intelligent positions for the first time in 14 years.

3. The Leicester the midfield has Ndidi, Maddison and especially Tielemans who is a glorious player. Justin and Jonny Evans have shown more quality than all the clowns in Arsenal's back four over the last seven years put together. Then there's Schmeichel Jr is, Harvey Barnes and Vardy.


Why is it that Arsenal's board cannot detect shit unless they are knee deep in it? Or maybe they have and don't care.
Great post. Disagree on one bit though; I don’t think Ozil is top class anymore.
 

UNITED ACADEMY

New Member
Joined
Aug 14, 2018
Messages
13,127
Supports
Erik ten Hag
Yes they are that bad.

1. Hector Bellerin - laughable
2. Dani Ceballos - When Andy Gray made that joke about 'wet, windy nights in Stoke' he was playing on the imagined stereotype of the weak, snide, diving, sideways passing, continental fair-weather foreigner. Ceballos somehow managed to embody all those things.
3. Pepe - got some quality but he's basically a left footed Gervinho
4. Willian - still got quality but he's on the wane
5. Xhaka - give him the keys
6. Mohammed El backwards
7. Mustafi - nuff said
8. Kolasinac - see above
9. Cedric Soares - pretty average and on a 4 year deal if I'm not wrong.
10. David Luiz - if he's your best centre half, good luck.

Arsenal fans rave about Tierney but I've seldom seen him make intelligent choices on the pitch. Lacazette has talent but is simply not worth what Arsenal paid for him. He seems to get no criticism in the media comapred to say Martial despite being half the player and cost nearly as much. His goal return has fallen year on year and he's never touched 20 goals a season. They'd kill to have someone as good as Calvert-Lewin ( some caf posters turn their noses up at him) who is going to become a 25 goal a season centre forward.

They spent £27M on this Saliba kid but he hasn't kicked a ball yet so can't be judged. Maitland Niles is alright and Smith-Rowe is supposed to be good too but I've seen little of him. Apart from that Saka and Martinelli have quality but they are kids, they aren't going to put up the numbers like seasoned players. If you pop around to Arsenal forums/subs they cheered Martinelli's return as though it was Fat Ronaldo returning to action which says it all.

Basically the spine of this side - the senior pros are all garbage. Their only top level players are Özil and Auba. One of whom they won't play and the other is not in any way a leader.

Someone brought up West Ham earlier in this thread. You have mentioned Leicester and Southampton. Many of their players are better man for man better and/or better coached.

1. I'd like to ask any Hammers on this forum if they'd swap Soucek, Bowen or Rice for their opposite at Arsenal. They offer goals and composure neither of which can be found in Arsenal's midfield.

2. Watching Southampton play Arsenal recently I was struck by the intelligence and composure shown by Walker-Peters, Ward - Prowse, Vestegaard and Armstrong. These players have clearly improved through coaching. Something Arsenal's haven't done in years and the best example is Walcott who is making sensible decisions and taking up intelligent positions for the first time in 14 years.

3. The Leicester the midfield has Ndidi, Maddison and especially Tielemans who is a glorious player. Justin and Jonny Evans have shown more quality than all the clowns in Arsenal's back four over the last seven years put together. Then there's Schmeichel Jr is, Harvey Barnes and Vardy.


Why is it that Arsenal's board cannot detect shit unless they are knee deep in it? Or maybe they have and don't care.
Or they are just bad because Arteta? Emery finished 5th with the same players exclude Partey, Gabriel, Willian & player he hasn’t play yet Saliba. I’ll put Leicester squad above them but definitely not Southampton. Their squad should be better or on the same level as Everton.
 

SilentWitness

ShoelessWitness
Staff
Joined
Jan 14, 2010
Messages
30,608
Supports
Everton
Or they are just bad because Arteta? Emery finished 5th with the same players exclude Partey, Gabriel, Willian & player he hasn’t play yet Saliba. I’ll put Leicester squad above them but definitely not Southampton. Their squad should be better or on the same level as Everton.
I don’t know if their squad is better than ours right now. Our strongest first XI is much better than their one too.
 

SinNombre

Full Member
Joined
Jan 26, 2019
Messages
2,626
Most of their fans and pundits thought they were a shoo-in for top 6 and with a good chance to finish ahead of United and Spurs in the top 4 at the start of the season.

Now their squad is suddenly worse than Everton to protect elite manager Arteta.
 

UNITED ACADEMY

New Member
Joined
Aug 14, 2018
Messages
13,127
Supports
Erik ten Hag
I don’t know if their squad is better than ours right now. Our strongest first XI is much better than their one too.
But before the start of season everyone would say arsenal have better squad and at least about the same XI. It’s different view now because Arteta fails to get the best out of his players.

If any Everton including you & arsenal fans have discussion before the first game week. This is what both fans would come up with the combined XI:

Leno
Coleman Luiz Gabriel/Holgate Tierney/Digne
Partey Allan
Pepe James Aubameyang
DCL
 

SilentWitness

ShoelessWitness
Staff
Joined
Jan 14, 2010
Messages
30,608
Supports
Everton
But before the start of season everyone would say arsenal have better squad and at least about the same XI. It’s different view now because Arteta fails to get the best out of his players.

If any Everton including you & arsenal fans have discussion before the first game week. This is what both fans would come up with the combined XI:

Leno
Coleman Luiz Gabriel/Holgate Tierney/Digne
Partey Allan
Pepe James Aubameyang
DCL
Digne is far better than Tierney. Keane is far more reliable than Luiz. Richarlison is better than Pepe.

There aren’t many Arsenal players I’d actually want right now which shows how far behind they are quality wise.
 

UNITED ACADEMY

New Member
Joined
Aug 14, 2018
Messages
13,127
Supports
Erik ten Hag
Digne is far better than Tierney. Keane is far more reliable than Luiz. Richarlison is better than Pepe.

There aren’t many Arsenal players I’d actually want right now which shows how far behind they are quality wise.
''Right now''. But I'm talking about before the season started.

Both of you would have say Pepe is better on the right than Richarlison since he's more LW. Luiz would have nail the centre back after his contribution last season against Liverpool & the FA Cup, Keane was far being reliable too last season.
 

SilentWitness

ShoelessWitness
Staff
Joined
Jan 14, 2010
Messages
30,608
Supports
Everton
''Right now''. But I'm talking about before the season started.

Both of you would have say Pepe is better on the right than Richarlison since he's more LW. Luiz would have nail the centre back after his contribution last season against Liverpool & the FA Cup, Keane was far being reliable too last season.
I’d have had each of those three above the Arsenal lot before this season too.
 

UNITED ACADEMY

New Member
Joined
Aug 14, 2018
Messages
13,127
Supports
Erik ten Hag
I’d have had each of those three above the Arsenal lot before this season too.
I can understand Digne but other than him, it's biased opinion. You finished 12th last season below Arsenal and your defense were terrible last season and worse than Arsenal. No chance Keane should be above Arsenal defense before this season.
 

C'mon FC

New Member
Newbie
Joined
Nov 7, 2018
Messages
274
Supports
1. FC Köln
But before the start of season everyone would say arsenal have better squad and at least about the same XI. It’s different view now because Arteta fails to get the best out of his players.

If any Everton including you & arsenal fans have discussion before the first game week. This is what both fans would come up with the combined XI:

Leno
Coleman Luiz Gabriel/Holgate Tierney/Digne
Partey Allan
Pepe James Aubameyang
DCL
Leno
Bellerin, Gabriel, Holgate, Digne
Partey, Allan, Doucoure
James
Richarlison
Aubameyang
 

Alemar

Full Member
Joined
Jul 11, 2017
Messages
7,617
Arteta should be doing alot better with the players he has. Their spending last 3 seasons is not far always from Uniteds tbf
absolutely. They have many good players: Aubameyang, Lacazette, Ozil, Willian, Leno, Partey, Ceballos, Saka, Gabriel, Thierney are all good players. Even Pepe as well is not Lingard level... it’s the manager that is out of his depth.
 
Last edited:

Maluco

Last Man Standing 3 champion 2019/20
Joined
Jan 4, 2014
Messages
5,925
I think Gabriel, Tierney, Saliba, Saka, Partey, Cabellos, Willian, Aubaemyang, Lacazette, Martinelli is more than enough to be doing far better.

Arteta is doing a horrendous job. I think any manager who fancies himself would be happy enough with their squad and a couple of additions in January.

Maybe we will see Tuchel come in.
 

C'mon FC

New Member
Newbie
Joined
Nov 7, 2018
Messages
274
Supports
1. FC Köln
Messi went to barca when he was 13
So basically he cost 0?

I'm guessing were going on costs rather than estimated value btw
Currently Messi's salary is around 35Mio per year. I believe in former years it wasn't that less.
Costs are not only signing fee...
 

SilentWitness

ShoelessWitness
Staff
Joined
Jan 14, 2010
Messages
30,608
Supports
Everton
I can understand Digne but other than him, it's biased opinion. You finished 12th last season below Arsenal and your defense were terrible last season and worse than Arsenal. No chance Keane should be above Arsenal defense before this season.
I am pretty sure that since Ancelotti and Arteta took over we have taken more points in the league overall. That’s from when I’m considering choosing Keane or Luiz from as that’s where each club was currently at before the season began, with those managers in charge. Luiz is fecking awful nowadays, he was once a cracking CB and CDM but now he’s a mistake waiting to happen. Keane is limited but solid at what he does.

The Pepe and Richarlison choice is a no brainer too. One is a tireless worker who is as important to the defence as he is to attack (the forward with the most tackles in the league last season) as well as putting up impressive forward numbers, and the other is someone who lumbers about the pitch with no urgency at all.

Yes, they have a few young talented players and good enough senior players throughout the side that should be doing better but I don’t see a top 4 side at all. I see a side that will be battling for the EL spots with a strong set of teams around them - Everton, Wolves, Southampton, Leicester etc. who are currently a lot better quality wise and form wise.
 

Sylar

Full Member
Joined
May 15, 2007
Messages
40,502
Currently Messi's salary is around 35Mio per year. I believe in former years it wasn't that less.
Costs are not only signing fee...
Right. But generally on here when people talk about price of a strike force it's only talking about value of signing, not wages, years spent etc

Of course happy to be corrected by @cyberman
 

Oldyella

Full Member
Joined
Jan 8, 2014
Messages
5,856
Is his team really that bad? It's obviously not as good as the general top 5(Pool Spurs, City, Chelsea and us), but is it that much worse than the likes of Leicester, Southampton and Everton?
Better than Southampton but not Leicester or Everton imo.