I think a lot of people felt this way, but we've all been made to look foolish; because in hindsight, it seems so obvious that Schneiderlin never had the passing range or competency, and game intelligence of a player like Michael Carrick. Carrick is just a very classy, hugely under rated footballer. An elegant midfielder who facilitates others through his calm reading of the game, excellent positioning, and passing repertoire. Schneiderlin is, what I would describe as, industrious. I think he much more suited to a role as a number 8 than as a number 6, and for a club of United's ambitions, he just isn't complete enough for that role.When Schniederlin was signed i thought he could potentially be the natural successor to Carrick, but he hasn't really grasped the chances he's been given, i would like him to stay and prove his worth, but can understand him if he wants to move on.
Depay on the other hand has essentially been useless. The glimpses of promise that he has displayed has quickly been followed up by several dreadful performances, I have wondered if he is better suited to playing centrally rather then on the wing, but i certainly won't be losing any sleep about him moving on.
Yeah I agree. In hindsight, he is the player that we bring on to protect a lead at Everton for example instead of Fellaini who i really do want gone ASAP.I think a lot of people felt this way, but we've all been made to look foolish; because in hindsight, it seems so obvious that Schneiderlin never had the passing range or competency, and game intelligence of a player like Michael Carrick. Carrick is just a very classy, hugely under rated footballer. An elegant midfielder who facilitates others through his calm reading of the game, excellent positioning, and passing repertoire. Schneiderlin is, what I would describe as, industrious. I think he much more suited to a role as a number 8 than as a number 6, and for a club of United's ambitions, he just isn't complete enough for that role.
I still think he could have been a good squad player, all things considered, and is a step up in midfield depth over what we've seen in recent years; but not all players can cope with not playing regularly. Time for him to move on.
Completely. The Fellaini issue is just crazy. Whether he deserves all the stick he gets is very debatable, because he has had some good games. But, overall he's just been a terrible fit for the club since he arrived and the sooner he is gone the better. He brings next to nothing I value to a football field.Yeah I agree. In hindsight, he is the player that we bring on to protect a lead at Everton for example instead of Fellaini who i really do want gone ASAP.
It isn't a hate campaign, it's just he offers very little to the side. Even when he is doing a job he is usually moments away from being sent off or committing a silly foul in a needless position. We need to ship him out and use the funds to replace him with a more suitable player.Its not debatable that Fellaini does not deserve the hate campaign directed against him.
Good one.I just hope we get decent money for them for a change.
Not in the slightest@Red Indian Chief Torn Rubber Do you think Fellaini deserves the hate campaign against him?
Its is nothing but a hate campaign. Championed by the same fallacious lie that he offers nothing and is the worst player to ever play for United. In LVGs first season, during our best run in years, he was one of our top performers in a side playing excellent football as it despatched Tottenham, Pool and City amongst other games. Even last season, he was amongst the key reasons we finally won the Fa cup again. He was ace in the semi vs West Ham for example. So much so that when we missed him against the same opponents in the league later, it cost as a champions league place. Fellaini has his limitations. But its pure fantasy land to claim he is useless, contributes absolutely nothing of value and is the worst player to ever play for us/ "nothing but a championship level player'. One doesn't have to like him to know this for a fact. All this blaming him for other players failing to live up to their hype is all an example of the hate campaign I'm referring to. Fellaini keeps getting picked because like his coaches keep stating he does what he is asked. Due to his natural limitations it at times doesn't come off, but its effective. I don't see value in hating on him yet more talented players than him simply fail repeatedly to do the bare minimum of implementing instructions given. Its why even a Lingard has been putting the likes of Depay on the bench. He is simply a squad player and its high time folks stop pretending that he is being treated like a key one, just because other more talented lads are not pulling their weight.It isn't a hate campaign, it's just he offers very little to the side. .....
Good one.
Memphis £5,5m
Schneiderlin £4m
That would be decent to me.
similar to Ando I guessNot in the slightest
That three-game run is going to echo through the ages.Its is nothing but a hate campaigned. Championed by the same fallacious lie that he offers nothing and is the worst player to ever play for United. In LVGs first season, during our best run in years, he was one of our top performers in a side playing excellent football as it despatched Tottenham, Pool and City. Even last season, he was amongst the key reasons we finally won the Fa cup again. He was ace in rthe semi vs West Ham for example. So much so that when we missed him against the same opponents in the league later, it cost as a champions league place. Fellaini has his limitations. But its pure fantasy land to claim he is useless, contributes absolutely nothing of value and is the worst player to ever play for us/ "nothing but a championship level player'. One doesn't have to like him to know this for a fact. All this blaming him for other players failing to live up to their hype is all an example of the hate campaign I'm referring to. Fellaini keeps getting picked because like his coaches keep stating he does what he is asked. Due to his natural limitations it at times doesn't come off, but its effective. I don't see value in hating on him yet more talented players than him simply fail repeatedly to do the bare minimum of implementing instructions given. Its why even a Lingard has been putting the likes of Depay on the bench. He is simply a squad player and its high time folks stop pretending that he is being treated like a key one, just because other more talented lads are not pulling their weight.
It really will.That three-game run is going to echo through the ages.
I'm looking forward to gathering my grandchildren around, 50 years from now, and telling them all where I was when Rooney silently dominated.It really will.
If we can get 40 in total would be amazing. Everton has the money now with their new owner being a billionaire.Think we will get around £10m for each.
Yup. Like Ando 'dominating' Fabregas and Gerrard or that spell where Welbeck actually scored in 5/6 (something like that) consecutive games. It's mad what people around here cling to.That three-game run is going to echo through the ages.
Ando was faultless in the big games in his first 2 years. Honestly, he was always starting and perfoming in our biggest games.Yup. Like Ando 'dominating' Fabregas and Gerrard or that spell where Welbeck actually scored in 5/6 (something like that) consecutive games. It's mad what people around here cling to.
He could be a very good 6 or 8 with the right player beside him. If he was paired with Carrick he could be instructed to press like crazy and offload the ball to the 10 (Mata) or the 6 (Carrick). That was pretty much the Vidal role at Juve. Or he could play as Pogba's workhorse, ie like Vidal. Coquelin is doing a similar role alongside Cazorla or Xhaka and the combination of high energy pressing and technique works well.I think a lot of people felt this way, but we've all been made to look foolish; because in hindsight, it seems so obvious that Schneiderlin never had the passing range or competency, and game intelligence of a player like Michael Carrick. Carrick is just a very classy, hugely under rated footballer. An elegant midfielder who facilitates others through his calm reading of the game, excellent positioning, and passing repertoire. Schneiderlin is, what I would describe as, industrious. I think he much more suited to a role as a number 8 than as a number 6, and for a club of United's ambitions, he just isn't complete enough for that role.
I still think he could have been a good squad player, all things considered, and is a step up in midfield depth over what we've seen in recent years; but not all players can cope with not playing regularly. Time for him to move on.
He started promising alright. I wasn't as impressed as some but he looked like a player with bags of potential.Ando was faultless in the big games in his first 2 years. Honestly, he was always starting and perfoming in our biggest games.
Sad how it ended.
Thats the thing, it was more than one time. I dont think we lost a single game to Arsenal/Liverpool in that period.He started promising alright. I wasn't as impressed as some but he looked like a player with bags of potential.
But when it became abundantly clear that he wasn't going to make it here, people kept bringing up how he dominated Fabregas that one time.
And Anderson had a hate campaign against him when?similar to Ando I guess
Of course he had. There were people like myself who wanted him out and I still believe its scandalous that a player who produced so little for us would stay with us for so many years.And Anderson had a hate campaign against him when?
Me what I hate is the ungratefulness fans have towards certain players. Just last season Fellaini and Lingard for example were absolutely key to us finally ending our FA cup droubt and most importantly bagging our first trophy post Fergie. But folks piss and moan about them on here like they have been key to us being in a relagation dog fight. I can't get not rating players but I don't get over the top hate nor ungratefulness. I always believe if talented players work hard enough the likes of Fellaini will never play ahead of them. So to hate on a limited player for winning his spot the hard way I find utterly revolting.Of course he had. There were people like myself who wanted him out and I still believe its scandalous that a player who produced so little for us would stay with us for so many years.
There again, I concede it was much less than to what Fellaini currently faces. The reasons are many
a- Ando had the potential to become a world class player, Fellaini does not. People tend to be more patient to the former then to the latter
b- Ando was funny. I know its ridiculous because a footballer should be judged on what he does on the pitch and not on the pranks he makes. However its undeniable that there are people who likes that
c- Ando played at a time when United were winning trophies on a yearly basis. So we could afford a freeloader or two on the way after all we could always rely on Scholes, Giggs, Ronaldo and co to bail us out. We can't do that now
d- United is all about good football. Don't take me wrong, we acknowledge the need of having bad people around (some like myself do more then others) but we (myself included) see it as a necessary evil. Hence why the trinity monument has Law, Charlton and Best rather then Nobby Stiles, Roy Keane and Paul Ince
I feel sorry for Fellaini. He's a relic of a game that is dying out. The only way we can take some juice out of this transfer is to play him out of position and that's far from ideal for a player especially at his age and at the standards United expect him to play in. There again much better players were offloaded when the game moved on without them. The likes of Bergkamp, Zola and Baggio struggled in a Serie A that was swiftly moving to a 1 men striker system. Some moved to the EPL who was still, at the time, far behind the Serie A. Others just had to adapt and play in minor teams. Baggio was a much better player then Rooney ever even dreamt of being. Yet he spent a big chunk of his career with teams like Brescia and Bologna. Its life
I doubt Welbeck has scored in 5/6 consecutive games ever in his career TBH.Yup. Like Ando 'dominating' Fabregas and Gerrard or that spell where Welbeck actually scored in 5/6 (something like that) consecutive games. It's mad what people around here cling to.
Yup I would be of the same thinking but he did something like that or else scored 5/6 in a run of games and people never shut up about it on here as some sort of vindication of his supposed 'excellence'.I doubt Welbeck has scored in 5/6 consecutive games ever in his career TBH.
most likely. wouldn't be surprising.Anybody else think Schneiderlin will go to Everton (or somewhere of similar stature) and be absolutely brilliant?
I think he'll be a £30m player when he's playing regularly for a team
Wouldn't say it was a hate campaign. More a fat shaming campaign.And Anderson had a hate campaign against him when?