Pre Premier League Draft

Indnyc

Full Member
Joined
Aug 3, 2017
Messages
4,537
I've got no idea how to settle that to be honest.

Seems unfair on one or the other no matter which way you go.
I agree it is unfair but we had to make a choice and which is why taking the neutral vote was the lesser of the two evils
 

Indnyc

Full Member
Joined
Aug 3, 2017
Messages
4,537
Yeah I fully understand that I didn't see that you had come to a conclusion by the time I replied.
I tagged 5 of the neutrals to come to a conclusion.. Three of them came back saying divide by 6.. So we went ahead :)
 

Edgar Allan Pillow

Ero-Sennin
Joined
Dec 7, 2010
Messages
41,425
Location
┴┬┴┤( ͡° ͜ʖ├┬┴┬
1. oneniltothearsenal - 1) K. Dalglish (10) 2) K. Sansom (7) 3) J. Robertson (16) 4) J. Molby (3) 5) G. Stevens (2) 6) C. Allen (1) 7) M. Wright (1) 8) S. McMahon (1) 9) L. Lloyd (1) 10) J. Rimmer (10) 11) A. Limpar (10) 12) M. Thomas (14)

8. youngrell - 1) P. Gascoigne (28) 2) M. Le Tissier (287) 3) P. Ince (2) 4) A. McLeish (11) 5) A. Kennedy (34) 6) A. McCoist (34) 7) R. Clemence (32) 8) G. Speed (205) 9) S. Bould (28) 10) P. Merson (5) 11) M. Duxbury (40) 12) R. Giggs (34)

9. Cal? - 1) G. Best (10) 2) T. Adams (460) 3) S. Pearce (298) 4) G. Strachan (10) 5) G. McAllister (1) 6) E. Cantona (302) 7) D. Batty (28) 8) R. Nilsson (15) 9) M. Keown (1) 10) G. Hurst (10) 11) H. van Breukelen (47) 12) A.
Kanchelskis (60)

11. Skizzo/Pat Mustard - 1) J. Barnes (137) 2) D. McGrain (116) 3) N. Whiteside (15) 4) M. Buchan (10) 5) J. Wark (4) 6) L. Cunningham (155) 7) M. Chivers (5) 8) R. Whelan (66) 9) B. McNeill (26) 10) C. Woods (40) 11) C. Knowles (60) 12) G. Cowans (10)

13. Oaencha - 1) R. Keane (19) 2) I. Wright (147) 3) S. Bruce (162) 4) G. Pallister (335) 5) S. Staunton (96) 6) D. Seaman (33) 7) T. Sheringham (24) 8) R. Houghton (285) 9) D. Wallace (175) 10) A. Shearer (58) 11) R. Jones (58) 12) R. Lee (15)

14. Indnyc - 1) E. Gray (34) 2) P. Thompson (145) 3) J. McGovern (36) 4) T. Brooking (5) 5) P. Shilton (6) 6) R. McFarland (10) 7) G.Sharpe (90) 8) B. Latchford (14) 9) K. Swain (8) 10) M. Mills (24) 11) M. O'Neill (2) 12) I. Bowyer (2)

15. KM/Invictus/Šjor Bepo - 1) M. Hughes (90) 2) E. Hughes (16) 3) T. Butcher (111) 4) D. Platt (32) 5) L. Dixon (30) 6) M. Peters (183) 7) G. Banks (19) 8) I. Callaghan (1) 9) A. Gemill (76) 10) D. Hirst (175) 11) R. Osman (28) 12. A. Ferguson (295)

16. Chesterlestreet -1) L. Brady 2) P. Lorimer (260) 3) W. Miller 4) J. Olsen (40) 5) A. Mullery 6) J. Aldridge (374) 7) A. Albiston 8) P. Reaney (42) 9) G. McQueen 10) R. Moses (121) 11) P. Cooper 12) J. Jordan (14)

...


2. green_smiley - 1) I. Rush (4) 2) D. Rocastle (31) 3) S. Jardine (7) 4) R. Kennedy (27) 5) D. Cooper (26) 6) S. Perryman (32) 7) P. Jennings (9) 8) B. Bonds (5) 9) T. Smith (2) 10) S. Bowles (11) 11) G. Mabbutt (60) 12) A. Lindsay (23)

3. BeforeKeanetherewasRobson - 1) B. Robson (51) 2) T. McDermott (146) 3) D. Irwin (14) 4) D. O'Leary (10) 5) B. McClair (3) 6) C. Todd (1) 7) F. Stapleton (3) 8) B. Grobbelaar (1) 9) T. Steven (3) 10) P. Van den Hauwe (10) 11) G. Hill (4) 12) M. Channon (41)

4. Edgar Allan Pillow - 1) P. McGrath (63) 2) A. Muhren (14) 3) P. Neal (2) 4) A. Smith (2) 5) P. Reid (3) 6) M. Lawrenson (10) 7) N. Southall (20) 8) C. Blackmore (48) 9) P. Nevin (2) 10) C. Johnston (10) 11) A. Gray (8) 12) T.Currie (180)

5. Frank Grimes - 1) K. Keegan (480) 2) J. Giles (142) 3) B. Bremner (12) 4) S. Coppell (25) 5) S. Heighway (11) 6) J. Toshack (195) 7) P. Schmeichel (480) 8) P. Parker (9) 9) M. Malpas (20) 10) D. Watson (19) 11) D. Narey (61) 12) C. Regis (220)

6. Enigma_87/TRV - 1) G. Lineker (3) 2) O. Ardiles (4) 3) D. Walker (1) 4) T. Francis (17) 5) N. Hunter (15) 6) F. Thijssen (21) 7) N. Winterburn (4) 8) K. Sheedy (9) 9) P. Rice (33) 10) F. Worthington (8) 11) J. Leighton (2) 12) R. Villa (2)

7. MJJ - 1) G. Souness (180) 2) C. Bell (191) 3) R. Wilkins (7) 4) M. MacDonald (97) 5) K. Burns 6) S. Nicol (25) 7) K. Beattie (2) 8) D. Statham (480) 9) G. Armstrong (445) 10) Allan Clarke (480) 11) J. Corrigan (5) 12) Milne (80)

10. Gio - 1) G. Hoddle (35) 2) C. Waddle (48) 3) V. Anderson (76) 4) R. Gough (70) 5) J. Greig (24) 6) B. Lennox (11) 7) K. Ratcliffe (243) 8) P. McStay (130) 9) K. Dixon (21) 10) A. Goram (60) 11. T. Dorigo (8) 12) A. Hartford (94)

12. Tuppet - 1) A. Hansen (46) 2) P. Beardsley (91) 3) A. Ball (38) 4) J. Johnstone (10) 5) T. Cooper (97) 6) B. Murdoch (73) 7) M. England (291) 8) F. Lee (160) 9) P. Madeley (38) 10) L. Sharpe (68) 11) P. Bonner (178) 12) B. Moore (133)
 
Last edited:

P-Nut

fan of well-known French footballer Fabinho
Joined
Oct 16, 2015
Messages
21,644
Location
Oldham, Greater Manchester

oneniltothearsenal

Caf's Milton Friedman and Arse Aficionado
Scout
Joined
Dec 17, 2013
Messages
11,164
Supports
Brazil, Arsenal,LA Aztecs
I just want to add one negative to picking 1st or 16th with the double pick is that I made the mistake of rushing a pick to keep my timing down and forgot about a player I really wanted when I first started this draft - Big Willie Young. Probably wouldn't have changed my first round loss but I certainly would have more fun posting the "We've got the Biggest Willie in the land" chants and claiming that Young would simply scare John Toshack into submission.
Much better character than Mark Wright
 

Gio

★★★★★★★★
Joined
Jan 25, 2001
Messages
20,334
Location
Bonnie Scotland
Supports
Rangers
Just glanced at the list of players that are going to be available after the first round..... wow.

Then you look at a possible XI (even before last couple of games done) and it'd have been scarily good.
It's a deep pool IMO - could potentially have gotten away with just a single decade in terms of depth, although I like the fact that the late 70s / early 80s stars don't need an asterix to get their dues.
 

Edgar Allan Pillow

Ero-Sennin
Joined
Dec 7, 2010
Messages
41,425
Location
┴┬┴┤( ͡° ͜ʖ├┬┴┬
Reinforcement Pool:

1. oneniltothearsenal - 1) K. Dalglish (10) 2) K. Sansom (7) 3) J. Robertson (16) 4) J. Molby (3) 5) G. Stevens (2) 6) C. Allen (1) 7) M. Wright (1) 8) S. McMahon (1) 9) L. Lloyd (1) 10) J. Rimmer (10) 11) A. Limpar (10) 12) M. Thomas (14)

8. youngrell - 1) P. Gascoigne (28) 2) M. Le Tissier (287) 3) P. Ince (2) 4) A. McLeish (11) 5) A. Kennedy (34) 6) A. McCoist (34) 7) R. Clemence (32) 8) G. Speed (205) 9) S. Bould (28) 10) P. Merson (5) 11) M. Duxbury (40) 12) R. Giggs (34)

9. Cal? - 1) G. Best (10) 2) T. Adams (460) 3) S. Pearce (298) 4) G. Strachan (10) 5) G. McAllister (1) 6) E. Cantona (302) 7) D. Batty (28) 8) R. Nilsson (15) 9) M. Keown (1) 10) G. Hurst (10) 11) H. van Breukelen (47) 12) A.
Kanchelskis (60)

11. Skizzo/Pat Mustard - 1) J. Barnes (137) 2) D. McGrain (116) 3) N. Whiteside (15) 4) M. Buchan (10) 5) J. Wark (4) 6) L. Cunningham (155) 7) M. Chivers (5) 8) R. Whelan (66) 9) B. McNeill (26) 10) C. Woods (40) 11) C. Knowles (60) 12) G. Cowans (10)

13. Oaencha - 1) R. Keane (19) 2) I. Wright (147) 3) S. Bruce (162) 4) G. Pallister (335) 5) S. Staunton (96) 6) D. Seaman (33) 7) T. Sheringham (24) 8) R. Houghton (285) 9) D. Wallace (175) 10) A. Shearer (58) 11) R. Jones (58) 12) R. Lee (15)

14. Indnyc - 1) E. Gray (34) 2) P. Thompson (145) 3) J. McGovern (36) 4) T. Brooking (5) 5) P. Shilton (6) 6) R. McFarland (10) 7) G.Sharpe (90) 8) B. Latchford (14) 9) K. Swain (8) 10) M. Mills (24) 11) M. O'Neill (2) 12) I. Bowyer (2)

15. KM/Invictus/Šjor Bepo - 1) M. Hughes (90) 2) E. Hughes (16) 3) T. Butcher (111) 4) D. Platt (32) 5) L. Dixon (30) 6) M. Peters (183) 7) G. Banks (19) 8) I. Callaghan (1) 9) A. Gemill (76) 10) D. Hirst (175) 11) R. Osman (28) 12. A. Ferguson (295)

16. Chesterlestreet -1) L. Brady 2) P. Lorimer (260) 3) W. Miller 4) J. Olsen (40) 5) A. Mullery 6) J. Aldridge (374) 7) A. Albiston 8) P. Reaney (42) 9) G. McQueen 10) R. Moses (121) 11) P. Cooper 12) J. Jordan (14)

QF Managers:

1. Tuppet - 1) A. Hansen (46) 2) P. Beardsley (91) 3) A. Ball (38) 4) J. Johnstone (10) 5) T. Cooper (97) 6) B. Murdoch (73) 7) M. England (291) 8) F. Lee (160) 9) P. Madeley (38) 10) L. Sharpe (68) 11) P. Bonner (178) 12) B. Moore (133)

2. Gio - 1) G. Hoddle (35) 2) C. Waddle (48) 3) V. Anderson (76) 4) R. Gough (70) 5) J. Greig (24) 6) B. Lennox (11) 7) K. Ratcliffe (243) 8) P. McStay (130) 9) K. Dixon (21) 10) A. Goram (60) 11. T. Dorigo (8) 12) A. Hartford (94)

3. MJJ - 1) G. Souness (180) 2) C. Bell (191) 3) R. Wilkins (7) 4) M. MacDonald (97) 5) K. Burns 6) S. Nicol (25) 7) K. Beattie (2) 8) D. Statham (480) 9) G. Armstrong (445) 10) Allan Clarke (480) 11) J. Corrigan (5) 12) Milne (80)

4. Enigma_87/TRV - 1) G. Lineker (3) 2) O. Ardiles (4) 3) D. Walker (1) 4) T. Francis (17) 5) N. Hunter (15) 6) F. Thijssen (21) 7) N. Winterburn (4) 8) K. Sheedy (9) 9) P. Rice (33) 10) F. Worthington (8) 11) J. Leighton (2) 12) R. Villa (2)

5. Frank Grimes - 1) K. Keegan (480) 2) J. Giles (142) 3) B. Bremner (12) 4) S. Coppell (25) 5) S. Heighway (11) 6) J. Toshack (195) 7) P. Schmeichel (480) 8) P. Parker (9) 9) M. Malpas (20) 10) D. Watson (19) 11) D. Narey (61) 12) C. Regis (220)

6. Edgar Allan Pillow - 1) P. McGrath (63) 2) A. Muhren (14) 3) P. Neal (2) 4) A. Smith (2) 5) P. Reid (3) 6) M. Lawrenson (10) 7) N. Southall (20) 8) C. Blackmore (48) 9) P. Nevin (2) 10) C. Johnston (10) 11) A. Gray (8) 12) T.Currie (180)

7. BeforeKeanetherewasRobson - 1) B. Robson (51) 2) T. McDermott (146) 3) D. Irwin (14) 4) D. O'Leary (10) 5) B. McClair (3) 6) C. Todd (1) 7) F. Stapleton (3) 8) B. Grobbelaar (1) 9) T. Steven (3) 10) P. Van den Hauwe (10) 11) G. Hill (4) 12) M. Channon (41)

8. green_smiley - 1) I. Rush (4) 2) D. Rocastle (31) 3) S. Jardine (7) 4) R. Kennedy (27) 5) D. Cooper (26) 6) S. Perryman (32) 7) P. Jennings (9) 8) B. Bonds (5) 9) T. Smith (2) 10) S. Bowles (11) 11) G. Mabbutt (60) 12) A. Lindsay (23)
 

Indnyc

Full Member
Joined
Aug 3, 2017
Messages
4,537
Standard 8 hour. In case of ties, we'll use the timing from the first round.

So @Tuppet goes first and whenever he picks, 8 hours starts for the next one from there
 
QF Reinforcement Pool

Indnyc

Full Member
Joined
Aug 3, 2017
Messages
4,537
Reinforcement Pool:

1. oneniltothearsenal - 1) K. Dalglish (10) 2) K. Sansom (7) 3) J. Robertson (16) 4) J. Molby (3) 5) G. Stevens (2) 6) C. Allen (1) 7) M. Wright (1) 8) S. McMahon (1) 9) L. Lloyd (1) 10) J. Rimmer (10) 11) A. Limpar (10) 12) M. Thomas (14)

8. youngrell - 1) P. Gascoigne (28) 2) M. Le Tissier (287) 3) P. Ince (2) 4) A. McLeish (11) 5) A. Kennedy (34) 6) A. McCoist (34) 7) R. Clemence (32) 8) G. Speed (205) 9) S. Bould (28) 10) P. Merson (5) 11) M. Duxbury (40) 12) R. Giggs (34)

9. Cal? - 1) G. Best (10) 2) T. Adams (460) 3) S. Pearce (298) 4) G. Strachan (10) 5) G. McAllister (1) 6) E. Cantona (302) 7) D. Batty (28) 8) R. Nilsson (15) 9) M. Keown (1) 10) G. Hurst (10) 11) H. van Breukelen (47) 12) A.
Kanchelskis (60)

11. Skizzo/Pat Mustard - 1) J. Barnes (137) 2) D. McGrain (116) 3) N. Whiteside (15) 4) M. Buchan (10) 5) J. Wark (4) 6) L. Cunningham (155) 7) M. Chivers (5) 8) R. Whelan (66) 9) B. McNeill (26) 10) C. Woods (40) 11) C. Knowles (60) 12) G. Cowans (10)

13. Oaencha - 1) R. Keane (19) 2) I. Wright (147) 3) S. Bruce (162) 4) G. Pallister (335) 5) S. Staunton (96) 6) D. Seaman (33) 7) T. Sheringham (24) 8) R. Houghton (285) 9) D. Wallace (175) 10) A. Shearer (58) 11) R. Jones (58) 12) R. Lee (15)

14. Indnyc - 1) E. Gray (34) 2) P. Thompson (145) 3) J. McGovern (36) 4) T. Brooking (5) 5) P. Shilton (6) 6) R. McFarland (10) 7) G.Sharpe (90) 8) B. Latchford (14) 9) K. Swain (8) 10) M. Mills (24) 11) M. O'Neill (2) 12) I. Bowyer (2)

15. KM/Invictus/Šjor Bepo - 1) M. Hughes (90) 2) E. Hughes (16) 3) T. Butcher (111) 4) D. Platt (32) 5) L. Dixon (30) 6) M. Peters (183) 7) G. Banks (19) 8) I. Callaghan (1) 9) A. Gemill (76) 10) D. Hirst (175) 11) R. Osman (28) 12. A. Ferguson (295)

16. Chesterlestreet -1) L. Brady 2) P. Lorimer (260) 3) W. Miller 4) J. Olsen (40) 5) A. Mullery 6) J. Aldridge (374) 7) A. Albiston 8) P. Reaney (42) 9) G. McQueen 10) R. Moses (121) 11) P. Cooper 12) J. Jordan (14)
 

Tuppet

New Member
Joined
Feb 9, 2014
Messages
3,622
Location
West Coast


1. Tuppet - 1) A. Hansen (46) 2) P. Beardsley (91) 3) A. Ball (38) 4) J. Johnstone (10) 5) T. Cooper (97) 6) B. Murdoch (73) 7) M. England (291) 8) F. Lee (160) 9) P. Madeley (38) 10) L. Sharpe (68) 11) P. Bonner (178) 12) B. Moore (133) 13) J. Barnes

2. Gio - 1) G. Hoddle (35) 2) C. Waddle (48) 3) V. Anderson (76) 4) R. Gough (70) 5) J. Greig (24) 6) B. Lennox (11) 7) K. Ratcliffe (243) 8) P. McStay (130) 9) K. Dixon (21) 10) A. Goram (60) 11. T. Dorigo (8) 12) A. Hartford (94)

3. MJJ - 1) G. Souness (180) 2) C. Bell (191) 3) R. Wilkins (7) 4) M. MacDonald (97) 5) K. Burns 6) S. Nicol (25) 7) K. Beattie (2) 8) D. Statham (480) 9) G. Armstrong (445) 10) Allan Clarke (480) 11) J. Corrigan (5) 12) Milne (80)

4. Enigma_87/TRV - 1) G. Lineker (3) 2) O. Ardiles (4) 3) D. Walker (1) 4) T. Francis (17) 5) N. Hunter (15) 6) F. Thijssen (21) 7) N. Winterburn (4) 8) K. Sheedy (9) 9) P. Rice (33) 10) F. Worthington (8) 11) J. Leighton (2) 12) R. Villa (2)

5. Frank Grimes - 1) K. Keegan (480) 2) J. Giles (142) 3) B. Bremner (12) 4) S. Coppell (25) 5) S. Heighway (11) 6) J. Toshack (195) 7) P. Schmeichel (480) 8) P. Parker (9) 9) M. Malpas (20) 10) D. Watson (19) 11) D. Narey (61) 12) C. Regis (220)

6. Edgar Allan Pillow - 1) P. McGrath (63) 2) A. Muhren (14) 3) P. Neal (2) 4) A. Smith (2) 5) P. Reid (3) 6) M. Lawrenson (10) 7) N. Southall (20) 8) C. Blackmore (48) 9) P. Nevin (2) 10) C. Johnston (10) 11) A. Gray (8) 12) T.Currie (180)

7. BeforeKeanetherewasRobson - 1) B. Robson (51) 2) T. McDermott (146) 3) D. Irwin (14) 4) D. O'Leary (10) 5) B. McClair (3) 6) C. Todd (1) 7) F. Stapleton (3) 8) B. Grobbelaar (1) 9) T. Steven (3) 10) P. Van den Hauwe (10) 11) G. Hill (4) 12) M. Channon (41)

8. green_smiley - 1) I. Rush (4) 2) D. Rocastle (31) 3) S. Jardine (7) 4) R. Kennedy (27) 5) D. Cooper (26) 6) S. Perryman (32) 7) P. Jennings (9) 8) B. Bonds (5) 9) T. Smith (2) 10) S. Bowles (11) 11) G. Mabbutt (60) 12) A. Lindsay (23)

@Gio
 

Indnyc

Full Member
Joined
Aug 3, 2017
Messages
4,537
Just glanced at the list of players that are going to be available after the first round..... wow.

Then you look at a possible XI (even before last couple of games done) and it'd have been scarily good.
The player pool is pretty deep and there were some really good players in the UK who don't get the recognition that they deserve.. Someone like Sansom for example wouldn't be a bad pick even in an all time draft at least for the first couple of rounds.
 
Joined
Jun 26, 2014
Messages
22,078
Location
Behind the right goal post as "Whiteside shoots!"
The player pool is pretty deep and there were some really good players in the UK who don't get the recognition that they deserve.. Someone like Sansom for example wouldn't be a bad pick even in an all time draft at least for the first couple of rounds.
That's all I was after really. I know how good some of the 70s/80s players were because I watched them but the lack of TV coverage compared to the last 20 years was chalk and cheese, which maybe led to a perception that the time pre PL was all about hoofing the ball, terrible tackles and fans in flat caps with a pie.