Russian invasion of Ukraine | Fewer tweets, more discussion

dove

New Member
Joined
May 15, 2013
Messages
7,899
Some russian tg channel claims that situation is very very difficult for them in the direction of Bersilav, Kherson region.
To give a feeling where it’s on the map:
This can only mean (if confirmed) a total collapse of Russian defense lines north of Kherson. Although it is very doubtful at this stage that such progress could have been possible this quickly.
That last tweet is a bit too optimistic IMO (or lost in translation somewhere) but it definitely seems like it's not a very good day for Russia with tons of reports of Kherson front collapsing from that direction.
 

The United

Full Member
Joined
Sep 14, 2015
Messages
5,804
That last tweet is a bit too optimistic IMO (or lost in translation somewhere) but it definitely seems like it's not a very good day for Russia with tons of reports of Kherson front collapsing from that direction.
The reports usually lag the events. I think the Ukrainians have gained massive amount of ground in the south already based on many reports. If the Russians will counterattack and the Ukrainians can hold what they gained for the next few hours would be interesting.

Or the whole Russians line will collapse within a few days which is the usual thing with their northern front lines.
 

The Firestarter

Full Member
Joined
Apr 8, 2010
Messages
28,309
Several times these weeks I had to pause and just think about the big picture and how absolutely ridiculous it would have been about 7 months ago to suggest that Ukraime would be capable of executing not one but two large scale geographically separated maneuvering offensives , simultaneously, and that against the Russian army which was build for the sole purpose of ground warfare. These last 5 years have felt like decades in terms of global events.
 

Frosty

Logical and sensible but turns women gay
Joined
Jan 11, 2007
Messages
17,293
Location
Yes I can hear you Clem Fandango!
Several times these weeks I had to pause and just think about the big picture and how absolutely ridiculous it would have been about 7 months ago to suggest that Ukraime would be capable of executing not one but two large scale geographically separated maneuvering offensives , simultaneously, and that against the Russian army which was build for the sole purpose of ground warfare. These last 5 years have felt like decades in terms of global events.
Agreed. And if there is one positive thing about a Tory PM in crisis, it is that plenty of money and military hardware should soon be heading to Kyiv.
 

nimic

something nice
Scout
Joined
Aug 2, 2006
Messages
31,619
Location
And I'm all out of bubblegum.
Several times these weeks I had to pause and just think about the big picture and how absolutely ridiculous it would have been about 7 months ago to suggest that Ukraime would be capable of executing not one but two large scale geographically separated maneuvering offensives , simultaneously, and that against the Russian army which was build for the sole purpose of ground warfare. These last 5 years have felt like decades in terms of global events.
I was 100% buying into the narrative that the Russian army was actually very strong. Now it's clear that it was a very, very small slice of competence.
 

Raoul

Admin
Staff
Joined
Aug 14, 1999
Messages
130,407
Location
Hollywood CA
Good interview with Khodorkovsky. Mentions that Putin knows failure to win in Ukraine would result in his own death, which is why some degree of tactical nukes may be on the table in the coming months.

 

Beans

Full Member
Joined
Aug 9, 2019
Messages
3,519
Location
Midwest, USA
Supports
Neutral
What's he waiting for, then?

If he was actually training these conscripts I'd say he's waiting till they're trained, but it seems he's just throwing them into the fight. Or maybe some are training and some are fodder?
 

Raoul

Admin
Staff
Joined
Aug 14, 1999
Messages
130,407
Location
Hollywood CA
What's he waiting for, then?

If he was actually training these conscripts I'd say he's waiting till they're trained, but it seems he's just throwing them into the fight. Or maybe some are training and some are fodder?
Using nukes would almost certainly trigger NATO getting involved and cause Putin to lose any trace of support from the likes of China and others. It could basically expedite his own demise. He’s basically fecked.
 

dove

New Member
Joined
May 15, 2013
Messages
7,899
Looks like yesterday's reports of Russians retreating all the way to Dudchany and then the fighting going in that area were correct. It would mean Ukraine advanced around 30km by the riverside in a few days or so, the first major breakthrough in Kherson region.

 

Adisa

likes to take afvanadva wothowi doubt
Joined
Nov 28, 2014
Messages
50,421
Location
Birmingham
We all laughed at him for being a fantasist when he said Ukraine will defeat Russia back in February.
 

RedRover

Full Member
Joined
Mar 19, 2007
Messages
8,966
Don't remember any of them having nukes though.
How does that change or affect what happens internally in Russia?

Putin is a 70 year old man. Even without the mess he's created, at some stage there has to be a transition of power. Either he will try to find a successor, or he'll be deposed. This isn't like the Soviet Union with a political mechanism in place to replace him.

He continues to march Russia towards economic and political isolation and even if he doesn't care, plenty of those around him will because this is the future they'll have to live. These are not ideologues, they're just gangsters and kleptocrats who look out for number one. Whilst he may well rule by fear now, that isn't guaranteed forever and when it starts to fall apart, and he loses his grip people will act in their own self-interest, not his. There's a simple solution coming for all those around Putin to have a brighter future.
 

sglowrider

Thinks the caf is 'wokeish'.
Joined
Dec 27, 2009
Messages
25,223
Location
Hell on Earth
Surprised the Russians have not drawn up a defensive line. Are they allowing the UKR forces to go deeper and therefore stretch their lines thin before counter-attacking?
 

We need an rvn

Full Member
Joined
Aug 13, 2015
Messages
3,873
Location
Down south...somewhere
Surprised the Russians have not drawn up a defensive line. Are they allowing the UKR forces to go deeper and therefore stretch their lines thin before counter-attacking?
I agree it seems Ukraine is taking land back very quickly which does make you think it could be a trap to thin their lines and counter attack

but flip side, the German collapse in wwii also went fairly quickly and it’s hard to draw a defensive line when so much of Your army is retreating without much order
 

cyberman

Full Member
Joined
May 26, 2010
Messages
37,331
Surprised the Russians have not drawn up a defensive line. Are they allowing the UKR forces to go deeper and therefore stretch their lines thin before counter-attacking?
Ukraine aren’t giving them time to establish a foothold for a counter attack. Speed is a tactic for Ukraine, not for Russia
 

Maagge

enjoys sex, doesn't enjoy women not into ONS
Joined
Oct 9, 2011
Messages
11,960
Location
Denmark
I agree it seems Ukraine is taking land back very quickly which does make you think it could be a trap to thin their lines and counter attack

but flip side, the German collapse in wwii also went fairly quickly and it’s hard to draw a defensive line when so much of Your army is retreating without much order
Yeah if you're retreating without your equipment you're not likely to be planning a counter attack.
 

The Firestarter

Full Member
Joined
Apr 8, 2010
Messages
28,309
How does that change or affect what happens internally in Russia?

Putin is a 70 year old man. Even without the mess he's created, at some stage there has to be a transition of power. Either he will try to find a successor, or he'll be deposed. This isn't like the Soviet Union with a political mechanism in place to replace him.

He continues to march Russia towards economic and political isolation and even if he doesn't care, plenty of those around him will because this is the future they'll have to live. These are not ideologues, they're just gangsters and kleptocrats who look out for number one. Whilst he may well rule by fear now, that isn't guaranteed forever and when it starts to fall apart, and he loses his grip people will act in their own self-interest, not his. There's a simple solution coming for all those around Putin to have a brighter future.
The cases you mentioned were externally triggered. So far I see the chance of F-35s bombing Moscow still as slim. Also, they had an already established resistance/ opposition that could be helped. No such entity exists in Russia. It may develop , but it will take a lot of time.
 

RedRover

Full Member
Joined
Mar 19, 2007
Messages
8,966
The cases you mentioned were externally triggered. So far I see the chance of F-35s bombing Moscow still as slim. Also, they had an already established resistance/ opposition that could be helped. No such entity exists in Russia. It may develop , but it will take a lot of time.
The concern over use of nuclear weapons is based on the idea that Putin is a madman who will ultimately be willing to risk it all and take the world down in flames if he has to. He might be, because if he loses this war, he's finished anyway. That risk doesn't apply to the people around him and it shows that he's not as all powerful as he might be assumed to be.

The narrative shifted last week with Zelensky and others making the point that Putin, not Russia, is the problem. It's targeted at people around him and the general population. There has been numerous articles the last few weeks about how mobilization has broken the social contract with the Russian people who willingly kept out of politics in return for an easy life. He's now asking them to go to war. Russia is a massive country, and there's a risk that as the war drags on and less young men come home public opinion will turn.

My opinion, there doesn't necessarily need to be an organised "resistance" because the elite are all self-serving and will ultimately do what they need to do to survive and remain rich and powerful. There will always be people moving in the shadows looking to take the throne and if they find backing of powerful people in high office, then just as with Putin, they could rise.

He is obviously a survivor, and maybe he does see this out and live to a grand old age, but he won't do so by continuing on this track.
 

The Firestarter

Full Member
Joined
Apr 8, 2010
Messages
28,309
The concern over use of nuclear weapons is based on the idea that Putin is a madman who will ultimately be willing to risk it all and take the world down in flames if he has to. He might be, because if he loses this war, he's finished anyway. That risk doesn't apply to the people around him and it shows that he's not as all powerful as he might be assumed to be.

The narrative shifted last week with Zelensky and others making the point that Putin, not Russia, is the problem. It's targeted at people around him and the general population. There has been numerous articles the last few weeks about how mobilization has broken the social contract with the Russian people who willingly kept out of politics in return for an easy life. He's now asking them to go to war. Russia is a massive country, and there's a risk that as the war drags on and less young men come home public opinion will turn.

My opinion, there doesn't necessarily need to be an organised "resistance" because the elite are all self-serving and will ultimately do what they need to do to survive and remain rich and powerful. There will always be people moving in the shadows looking to take the throne and if they find backing of powerful people in high office, then just as with Putin, they could rise.

He is obviously a survivor, and maybe he does see this out and live to a grand old age, but he won't do so by continuing on this track.
I'd obviously hope for the same outcome however all that I have read and also what Russians acquaintances have shared, is that it's not very realistic to expect a palace coup because he has spent decades shielding himself from such a possibility.