On loan with no obligation to buy.
Which would you prefer?
Which would you prefer?
Sarr or Dembele?
- Thread starter jderbyshire
- Start date
-
Nik (@Rood) and Imran (@Annihilate Now!) discuss United's fantastic win away against Athletic Club in the semi-final of the Europa League.
They also pick out the positives of United's 4-3 loss away at Brentford, and Nik reviews a day out at Old Trafford watching Manchester United Women qualify for the Champions League.
Might as well go for Dembele and see what happens.
Top ceiling is far far higher.
Top ceiling is far far higher.
The cheaper one because I'd rather save up and have one more shot at Sancho next year. Maybe.
Why not both? Sarr permanent, Dembele loan. We need motivated attacking talent real bad.
If Dembele stays fit he can be as good as Sancho.
Sarr not even sure if he can slightly upgrade starting eleven, but I can be wrong about that.
Sarr not even sure if he can slightly upgrade starting eleven, but I can be wrong about that.
Dembele, no contest
Not sure what Sarr's injury record is like but it couldn't be worse than Dembele's and that alone is reason enough to choose him of the two
Definitely Dembele. If we had an option to buy and got him looking like a player again it’d be a hell of a deal. Add Sancho next year too and we’d have one of the best set of attacking options around.
Dembele in a first round knockout within 1 second
Dembele. Not a fan of him at all, but at least there's a chance that he'll do something special every now and then. Not sure Sarr offers anything.
Neither.
Gun to head if I had to choose. Sarr and the only 2 reasons for it is, he'll stay fit for longer and he's cheaper.
Dembele talent wise pisses all over sarr but he's so Injury prone. No good sitting next to Jones all season
Gun to head if I had to choose. Sarr and the only 2 reasons for it is, he'll stay fit for longer and he's cheaper.
Dembele talent wise pisses all over sarr but he's so Injury prone. No good sitting next to Jones all season
Dembele. He is a potential superstar if you can depend on that hamstring not snapping... hopefully he can remain fit for a good 40-45 games for us this season, should he join.
Dembele, chances are he'll be injured but if he's not, it's a hell of a lot more interesting and potentially exciting than a loan of Sarr.
Dembele 100%. Dembele is better and uses his left foot. Sarr would be yet another BAD SIGNING.
So I'm expecting us to sign Sarr.
So I'm expecting us to sign Sarr.
Yeah definitely Dembele but still think we are only looking for loan with option to buy, rather than obligation or a permanent deal either but maybe I am completely wrong
Pellistri
Dembele by a landslide.
Buy Sarr and Loan Dembele.... Sarr offers us depth.... Sell James and Lingard
Hasn't Sarr just been confirmed by Bayern Munich?
Different one
Neither.
Gun to my head? Dembele.
Gun to my head? Dembele.
Oh. God damn it. So confusing, all these Sarrs, Traore's and Dembeles are making my head spin.
Obviously Dembele
Amad Traore has huge potential. I think he'll surprise us.
I'm happy the majority in this thread want Dembele. Hope Ole or Ed read this thread!!! 
Dembele.
Dembele...the only option I'd take a punt on from the Championship would have been Buendia £20m or Benrahma £25m.
On pure skill Dembele by a long way.
Dembele, at least when he's fit he's very talented, Sarr isn't good enough and never will be.
Not sure if that was serious or not but a fit Ousmane is a level or two above Sancho.
Dembele with no option to buy is just plain dumb.
He has NEVER been as prolific as Sancho. EVER.
Dembele probably can't do a star jump without tearing his hamstring, so I'd say Sarr
Who cares?
He has destroyed teams on any and every stage, Sancho has not.
Also watch Sancho's numbers drop off a cliff once he leaves Dortmund and faces proper competition.
Dembele is far more talented so that's who I'd go for.
You guys have Top Red, we have Top French in @Clermontois
Im not even a Red
. Dembele is one of those players who's hype always seems to out do his actual game. When fit he is good but he has never met what he has been touted to be.Dembele. I just hope we try to put in a purchase option. If he stays fit his price will catapult.
Dembele. Not even close.
But I would want Traore though.
But I would want Traore though.
This is essential, it would make no sense rejecting Reguilion due to a buy back clause but accept Dembele without an option.