Surprised majority on here saying no rebuild needed just a good manager. The manager is just a part of the rebuild. Lets not talk f the last seven years just the current squad.
We have a squad of about 35 players, its too large, four players over 35, several reaching the end of there contracts, sevreal injury plagued players, we still have a first eleven that looks very weak in at least three positions, beyond DeGea not really a single consistent performer this season, several players that have under performed in there time here.....etc etc etc
Does anybody genuinely think any manager would take over this group of players and with just a couple of signings transform them into title winners or champions league winners?
In terms of consistency of performance individually and as a team, entertainment, desire, quality we are a long way behind City and Liverpool. Of course a rebuild is needed, but we need to do it right, for me:
1) A good manager - Of course this is important, our timing of hiring managers has been unforunate and poor. Think we definately missed a trick timing wise for both Klopp and Nagelsmann and this summer I really cant see anybody beyond Pochettino that fits
2) A clear out of players - For me this is one of the things we have got the most wrong season after season over the last decade pretty much and this summer with so mnay players out of contract and wanting to leave AND considerign our squad is so big, the excuse of struggling to offload players due to the salareis they are on....sinply isnt there. From the likes of Grant and Pereira who simply havent played to the talented failures like Pogba and Martial, our departures should be into double figures in my opinion, comfortably
3) Signing the RIGHT players in the RIGHT positions. Since Ferguson retiring, we have signed 40players and lets face it, barely any have been a huge success and for me personally so many looked the wrong signings at the time:
Moyes spent £70m on Mata and Fellaini, both were totally the wrogn players I thought at the time
LVG bought Blind, Rojo, injured Schweinsteiger, Schneiderlin and Depay for £100m...none looked right to me
Mourinho spent £150m on Lukaku, Fred and Lindelof after a good first summer of deals....awful business, didnt think much of any of them when saw them before comign here
Ole spent close £120m on Maguire, James and VDB when for me there were far better options around
Thats approacing half a billion on players that were never right between them for me before they signed.
The list of players I genuinely thought were the right signings in the last few years is really small.....Shaw, Falcao, Romero, Pogba, Ibrahimovic, Bailly and Bissaka (Varane and SAncho this season not really including as early days)....not even a player a season addign them up and only the older experienced ones have had some amount of success consistently over there time here if you forget Shaw last season, som ehav ebeen very dissapointing.
So for me THIS summer we really need a good manager 10-15 players out a centre back, right back, two central midfielers and one or two attacking options also in......get the right ones out and in and a good manager, a nucleus of 20 players with a few youngsters around them.....we could be transformed....simply a manager and 5 or so out and a couple in, no chance whoever the manager is