As others have already said. That’s bullshit. Users will downvote just because a show has replaced a white character with a black actor and call it too woke, it happens so much. Or simply because it doesn’t follow the book like they thought it would. User reviews are the most unreliable medium of them all.
critics reviews are generally a good gauge when it comes to tv shows at least these days. They can get them wrong but I’ve found 90% of shows that have a good approval to be at least a semi good watch, which hopefully this will be.
That's not always the case. The more high-profile something is, the less true it is sometimes. Watchmen has a 56% audience score on Rotten Tomatoes, but I guess that's because the protagonist is a black woman and (some of) the antagonists are white supremacists. But wasn't there already some drama about black people being cast as elves and dwarves? LotR might be too big for that to matter, but there's no accounting for internet racists.
I understand what you infer there but tbh in the last couple of years I've been more distrusting of negative reviews than of positive ones esp. when it comes to the users. There's always this agenda attached to those negative ones. I was seeing that with the movie "Prey" negative user reviews/youtube reviews (anyone can guess the agenda there). Same thing I'm seeing with TROP, most of the negative reviews I've seen on youtube are from ones who've had already decided to hate the show for a while due to reasons like "too woke", "trashing Tolkien-ian legacy", "different Galadriel" etc etc. The neutral non-Tolkien-ian reviewers and Tolkien-ian youtubers have been positive citing a couple of things they're unsure about just from the first couple of episodes. Though with everything, I'll need to watch it first to make my mind about it and I've been cautiously positive about it for a while.
The reason I'll always favour the people - and when I say people, I'm referring to the everyday working man who gives zero shits for which side is elected president of the US, including the majority of US citizens - is that we have no agenda one way or another. We merely want to see a good movie/TV show, play a good video game or listen to good music we enjoy, and our feelings will absolutely reflect that when it comes to rating them on the likes of IMDB, Metacritic, Rotten Tomatoes, etc. I truly believe that.
You have to look past the bullshitters, though, because, as you correctly point out, the haters will do everything in their power to compromise the rating to further their agenda, but if you dive into those user reviews, actually
read what people have to say about the product, you can separate the genuine reviews from the false ones with little difficulty. The self-professed "experts of the entertainment industry" are far less trustworthy, in my honest-to-God opinion, as they've given us fake reviews for decades because they've been paid to do so. We all know they do it, lads/lasses. Let's not pretend otherwise.
User reviews all the way. You, me, the silent majority. We are the shit