Thomas Tuchel | Gone to & from Bayern (In Summer)

crossy1686

career ending
Joined
Jun 5, 2010
Messages
31,721
Location
Manchester/Stockholm
Supposedly Bayern are a club Hag would very much like to manage.

Also, with our ownership up in the air , coupled with a potential small budget to play with in the summer, he might be tempted.
We’ll sell in the summer and the budget will be adequate regardless who the owners are. Ten Hag took the job knowing who the owners were so if they’re still here it won’t make a difference to him.

If he wanted the Bayern job then all he had to do was wait for it, I’m pretty sure they considered him previously though and decided against it. At the end of the day, they’d rather weaken a direct BL rival and take their manager than go for someone like Ten Hag unless he’s available like Tuchel was.
 

do.ob

Full Member
Joined
Jun 19, 2010
Messages
15,626
Location
Germany
Supports
Borussia Dortmund
We’ll sell in the summer and the budget will be adequate regardless who the owners are. Ten Hag took the job knowing who the owners were so if they’re still here it won’t make a difference to him.

If he wanted the Bayern job then all he had to do was wait for it, I’m pretty sure they considered him previously though and decided against it. At the end of the day, they’d rather weaken a direct BL rival and take their manager than go for someone like Ten Hag unless he’s available like Tuchel was.
Yeah, they are obviously already tapping up Edin Terzic. :thinking:
 

11101

Full Member
Joined
Aug 26, 2014
Messages
21,322
I haven’t really been impressed with him since his PSG days, don’t really get him to be honest. He obviously did well to win the CL but I think it was more luck that anything, the ultimate new manager bounce.
If you look at his Chelsea days, he had a month or two after joining where they improved but after that he reverted to a similar win rate to Lampard. I think people rate him because he acts like Klopp.
 

crossy1686

career ending
Joined
Jun 5, 2010
Messages
31,721
Location
Manchester/Stockholm
If you look at his Chelsea days, he had a month or two after joining where they improved but after that he reverted to a similar win rate to Lampard. I think people rate him because he acts like Klopp.
I kid you not, I remember a poster saying they rated Tuchel because he was ‘active on the touchline’ and Ole wasn’t.
 

11101

Full Member
Joined
Aug 26, 2014
Messages
21,322
I kid you not, I remember a poster saying they rated Tuchel because he was ‘active on the touchline’ and Ole wasn’t.
I posted this a couple of years ago. Tuchel vs Lampard at Chelsea. Take out Tuchel's new manager bounce and he was actually worse than Lampard for much of their respective tenures. Yet one is a laughing stock and the other is a world class coach?

Lampard overall - 1.53 ppg
Lampard pre Everton implosion - 2 ppg
Lampard post implosion - 0.88 ppg

Tuchel overall - 2 ppg
Tuchel first 5 games - 2.6 ppg
Tuchel remaining games - 1.79 ppg
He is extremely fortunate to have joined late in the season and won that CL. His entire reputation is built on it.
 

do.ob

Full Member
Joined
Jun 19, 2010
Messages
15,626
Location
Germany
Supports
Borussia Dortmund
I posted this a couple of years ago. Tuchel vs Lampard at Chelsea. Take out Tuchel's new manager bounce and he was actually worse than Lampard for much of their respective tenures. Yet one is a laughing stock and the other is a world class coach?



He is extremely fortunate to have joined late in the season and won that CL. His entire reputation is built on it.
So you cut out Tuchel's best period and you cut out Lampard's worst period and then you think that's a suitable basis for a comparison?

Not to mention "his entire reputation is built on it"? When Tuchel got the Chelsea job based on his performance at previous clubs, wheras Lampard got it for being a Chelsea legend?
 

Zehner

Football Statistics Dork
Joined
Mar 29, 2018
Messages
8,135
Location
Germany
Supports
Bayer 04 Leverkusen
So you cut out Tuchel's best period and you cut out Lampard's worst period and then you think that's a suitable basis for a comparison?

Not to mention "his entire reputation is built on it"? When Tuchel got the Chelsea job based on his performance at previous clubs, wheras Lampard got it for being a Chelsea legend?
:lol:
 

weetee

Full Member
Joined
Jan 29, 2021
Messages
3,760
Supports
no-one in particular
Regardless of how one rates Tuchel, I think it's pretty obvious that the squad/club was already imploding behind the scenes. Hence the curious sacking of Nagelsman with the hope of a positive reaction with a new manager which didn't happen. Club is in total shambles for a long time.

"total shambles" obviously regarding Bayern's standards. Kahn/Salihmidzic have a long way ahead of them if they truly want to rebuild the club structures to the positive - if they aren't replaced by then.
 

do.ob

Full Member
Joined
Jun 19, 2010
Messages
15,626
Location
Germany
Supports
Borussia Dortmund
If Bayern should take their next manager from another BL club, I would bet on Xabi Alonso.
He surely seems like the most likely candidate - in this unlikely scenario - but even with redcafe IQ it must be a bit too much of a stretch, to call a team that probably hasn't finished within 15 points of Bayern in 10 years a direct rival.
 

stefan92

Full Member
Joined
Feb 9, 2021
Messages
6,514
Supports
Hannover 96
He surely seems like the most likely candidate - in this unlikely scenario - but even with redcafe IQ it must be a bit too much of a stretch, to call a team that probably hasn't finished within 15 points of Bayern in 10 years a direct rival.
Looking at some discussions on here I am quite sure that some posters would not even realize that Bayer and Bayern are not the same club, so I have to respectfully disagree here.
 

11101

Full Member
Joined
Aug 26, 2014
Messages
21,322
So you cut out Tuchel's best period and you cut out Lampard's worst period and then you think that's a suitable basis for a comparison?

Not to mention "his entire reputation is built on it"? When Tuchel got the Chelsea job based on his performance at previous clubs, wheras Lampard got it for being a Chelsea legend?
Or you could look at it as cutting out the 10 games or so around the manager change. For three quarters of the season they were on the same points per game.

Anyway, Tuchel is on his way to finishing second in a one horse race so when he is sacked it will be interesting to see where he can go next.
 

Zehner

Football Statistics Dork
Joined
Mar 29, 2018
Messages
8,135
Location
Germany
Supports
Bayer 04 Leverkusen
He surely seems like the most likely candidate - in this unlikely scenario - but even with redcafe IQ it must be a bit too much of a stretch, to call a team that probably hasn't finished within 15 points of Bayern in 10 years a direct rival.
Focus on your job and next season, we'll make sure it'll be two seasons in a row without a league title for Bayern!
 

Neil_Buchanan

Cock'd
Joined
Nov 18, 2006
Messages
3,541
Location
Bolton
Heaven forbid that Bayern aren’t sat at the top of the table for every single week of the season or that they don’t win every single trophy. Jeez, have a day off you boring twat of a club. I know it’s a clubs mission to be as successful as possible but at what point does it become greed? The game of capitalism is to earn more money, so should I only be satisfied once I have all the money? Every single bloody penny?
 

hasanejaz88

Full Member
Joined
Dec 3, 2017
Messages
5,937
Location
Munich
Supports
Germany
Or you could look at it as cutting out the 10 games or so around the manager change. For three quarters of the season they were on the same points per game.

Anyway, Tuchel is on his way to finishing second in a one horse race so when he is sacked it will be interesting to see where he can go next.
He's not going to get sacked this season no matter what happens. He wasn't signed to save this season, which was going fine, but to prevent him from going anywhere else.

I think the board realize they messed up the squad by replacing Lewandowski with Mane, who hasn't worked out at all, and that they need a striker for next season.
 

Zehner

Football Statistics Dork
Joined
Mar 29, 2018
Messages
8,135
Location
Germany
Supports
Bayer 04 Leverkusen
He's not going to get sacked this season no matter what happens. He wasn't signed to save this season, which was going fine, but to prevent him from going anywhere else.

I think the board realize they messed up the squad by replacing Lewandowski with Mane, who hasn't worked out at all, and that they need a striker for next season.
I wouldn't rule anything out to be honest. I absolutely love it but what's happening at Bayern is total madness and I imagine some of those responsible for that would do everything to distract from themselves. Hoeneß is still pulling the strings and he seems to have lost the plot completely at this point if there was any truth to the rumours about his son as Kahn's successor.

There appears to be so much club politics right now that it wouldn't surprise me if Tuchel indeed became another pawn, even if it makes no sense for the club at all.

Beautiful to see, really :D Brazzo might be my favourite person in the world right now!
 

PepG

Full Member
Joined
Jun 23, 2016
Messages
1,191
Supports
Ajax
When you win so much as Bayern you get comfortable and lazy so this is actually good thing for the bavarians. This shakeup is very much needed and it could be used as a wakeup call for the club.
 

WeePat

Full Member
Joined
Apr 13, 2015
Messages
17,421
Supports
Chelsea
So you cut out Tuchel's best period and you cut out Lampard's worst period and then you think that's a suitable basis for a comparison?

Not to mention "his entire reputation is built on it"? When Tuchel got the Chelsea job based on his performance at previous clubs, wheras Lampard got it for being a Chelsea legend?
:lol:
 

do.ob

Full Member
Joined
Jun 19, 2010
Messages
15,626
Location
Germany
Supports
Borussia Dortmund
I wouldn't rule anything out to be honest. I absolutely love it but what's happening at Bayern is total madness and I imagine some of those responsible for that would do everything to distract from themselves. Hoeneß is still pulling the strings and he seems to have lost the plot completely at this point if there was any truth to the rumours about his son as Kahn's successor.

There appears to be so much club politics right now that it wouldn't surprise me if Tuchel indeed became another pawn, even if it makes no sense for the club at all.

Beautiful to see, really :D Brazzo might be my favourite person in the world right now!
No one currently in charge at the club could afford to sack Tuchel, it would basically finalize the Nagelsmann sacking as one of the worst management decisions in the history of the club. They will stick with him and hope he turns it around, so they can ride out the pressure.
 

B. Munich

Full Member
Joined
Mar 26, 2014
Messages
1,442
Location
Philippines
Supports
Bayern Munich
I think mid season WC is the root cause of the collapse.
No other team had thang many long-term injuries and mentally shot players returning from Qatar.

Nagelsmann thought it's a good idea to give the team 4 and half week off to clear their heads. In comparison English teams just continued with the season.

Obviously this didn't work out as planned. On top he couldn't rebuild necessary fitness levels in pre season.

This the players weren't not only mentally weak but also physically not at their best. This explains the 16 points dropped after leads and the many poor second half performances.

I even don't blame Nagelsmann much because this mid season WC was unchartered territory for all clubs.

Once the damage was done, there is no way to fix it in a fixture packed season. Similar to United and Rangnick last year.
 

do.ob

Full Member
Joined
Jun 19, 2010
Messages
15,626
Location
Germany
Supports
Borussia Dortmund
I think mid season WC is the root cause of the collapse.
No other team had thang many long-term injuries and mentally shot players returning from Qatar.

Nagelsmann thought it's a good idea to give the team 4 and half week off to clear their heads. In comparison English teams just continued with the season.

Obviously this didn't work out as planned. On top he couldn't rebuild necessary fitness levels in pre season.

This the players weren't not only mentally weak but also physically not at their best. This explains the 16 points dropped after leads and the many poor second half performances.

I even don't blame Nagelsmann much because this mid season WC was unchartered territory for all clubs.

Once the damage was done, there is no way to fix it in a fixture packed season. Similar to United and Rangnick last year.
I'm sure the world cup didn't help, but the problems, e.g. Mane not working out and Bayern lacking a Lewandowski replacement as a consequence, were already visible before. And the bad impact was not inevitable, Brandt, Süle and Schlotterbeck were part of the same WC outfit, Schlotterbeck even had a highly visible mistake and they became the backbone of Dortmund's 2023 success.
 

B. Munich

Full Member
Joined
Mar 26, 2014
Messages
1,442
Location
Philippines
Supports
Bayern Munich
I'm sure the world cup didn't help, but the problems, e.g. Mane not working out and Bayern lacking a Lewandowski replacement as a consequence, were already visible before. And the bad impact was not inevitable, Brandt, Süle and Schlotterbeck were part of the same WC outfit, Schlotterbeck even had a highly visible mistake and they became the backbone of Dortmund's 2023 success.
Bayern has two major groups, the German and the French players. All were mentally down after the WC. The only player with a positive experience was Mazraoui and he was out for months.

Thus Nagelsmann thought it's great to give the team over 4 weeks off. This was, at least for me, the key mistake. The players lost match fitness and Nagelsmann failed to get necessary fitness levels back in pre season.

Examples are Leipzig, Frankfurt, Hohenheim, Mainz but also in matches Bayern won like Stuttgart, Wolfsburg or even Dortmund. Bayern always dominated the first half, took the lead and were in control only the loose points in the second half or let the teams back in the game. This is absolutely not Bayern like and can only be explained with poor fitness levels.
 

Sylar

Full Member
Joined
May 15, 2007
Messages
40,508
Just realized they are second in the league and that's cos they lost 3-1.
This has been a disaster so far right?
 

stefan92

Full Member
Joined
Feb 9, 2021
Messages
6,514
Supports
Hannover 96
Just realized they are second in the league and that's cos they lost 3-1.
This has been a disaster so far right?
The results definitely. Exited the cup (lost at home against Freiburg), exited the CL against City and lost the lead in the league.

But as argued above this likely is a case of he came too late to stop the downward spiral, because it isn't just a mental problem, but Bayern lack physical fitness as well.

Part of the reason why Bayern won ten titles in a row is that they always were able to turn around games, if necessary in extra time. This season it consistently feels the opposite, even if they lead in a match you ask if they will get through. And far too often like yesterday against Mainz they won't.
 

Maluco

Last Man Standing 3 champion 2019/20
Joined
Jan 4, 2014
Messages
5,938
There always seems to be a ready made excuse for Tuchel. Dortmund aren’t ambitious enough, PSG is a circus, Chelsea had off field issues and now he has arrived at the wrong time at Bayern.

He seems to be a decent tactician who can set sides up well in one off games, but his league form has never been great and I think he is extremely overrated as a coach.
 

stefan92

Full Member
Joined
Feb 9, 2021
Messages
6,514
Supports
Hannover 96
There always seems to be a ready made excuse for Tuchel. Dortmund aren’t ambitious enough, PSG is a circus, Chelsea had off field issues and now he has arrived at the wrong time at Bayern.

He seems to be a decent tactician who can set sides up well in one off games, but his league form has never been great and I think he is extremely overrated as a coach.
He has managed Mainz' best ever BL season and Dortmund's second best ever, and in general his Dortmund side was the last time Dortmund really challenged Bayern head to head (since then they only won a cup in a season Bayern embarassed themselves in the second round and nothing else).

Saying his league form has never been great is just false.
 

Maluco

Last Man Standing 3 champion 2019/20
Joined
Jan 4, 2014
Messages
5,938
He has managed Mainz' best ever BL season and Dortmund's second best ever, and in general his Dortmund side was the last time Dortmund really challenged Bayern head to head (since then they only won a cup in a season Bayern embarassed themselves in the second round and nothing else).

Saying his league form has never been great is just false.
“Never” might be an exaggeration, but it’s interesting that the two examples you have given were both after Klopp and were both at smaller clubs where players might be more inclined to accept an authoritarian approach. (No offense to Dortmund fans, but they are run like a smaller club with no real ambition to win big trophies)

I don’t think he has the personality to manage at big clubs, and I don’t think he has managed a big team that have ever played particularly great football consistently.

He isn’t among the elite manager bracket for me and that will be exemplified if he somehow contrives to fail at Bayern Munich, of all clubs. No matter what the excuses are.
 

do.ob

Full Member
Joined
Jun 19, 2010
Messages
15,626
Location
Germany
Supports
Borussia Dortmund
“Never” might be an exaggeration, but it’s interesting that the two examples you have given were both after Klopp and were both at smaller clubs where players might be more inclined to accept an authoritarian approach. (No offense to Dortmund fans, but they are run like a smaller club with no real ambition to win big trophies)

I don’t think he has the personality to manage at big clubs, and I don’t think he has managed a big team that have ever played particularly great football consistently.

He isn’t among the elite manager bracket for me and that will be exemplified if he somehow contrives to fail at Bayern Munich, of all clubs. No matter what the excuses are.
"both after Klopp", as in Klopp finished 4th (in the 2nd division) with Mainz, then another guy coached the entire next season and following pre-season and only then Tuchel took over and had success until the 6th year since Klopp's departure. I take it you were a big Mainz enjoyer at the time?
 

stefan92

Full Member
Joined
Feb 9, 2021
Messages
6,514
Supports
Hannover 96
“Never” might be an exaggeration, but it’s interesting that the two examples you have given were both after Klopp and were both at smaller clubs where players might be more inclined to accept an authoritarian approach. (No offense to Dortmund fans, but they are run like a smaller club with no real ambition to win big trophies)
I would disagree on Dortmund as a club. In the late Klopp and following Tuchel years they absolutely saw themselves as the true and ambitious challenger and wanted to win titles. Settling for being second best happened more recently, during Tuchel's time they were still willing and able to challenge Pep's Bayern, but after the bomb attack and the following dispute between Tuchel and the board this got lost.

I don’t think he has the personality to manage at big clubs, and I don’t think he has managed a big team that have ever played particularly great football consistently.
That's a fair point I think, he just tends to use a pragmatic approach, not an aesthetically pleasing. I don't think that his personality is a problem however, at least not for the success of his teams.

He isn’t among the elite manager bracket for me and that will be exemplified if he somehow contrives to fail at Bayern Munich, of all clubs. No matter what the excuses are.
If he fails at Bayern I will agree. But I won't judge him on this season, as I am convinced that the board messed up by not sacking Nagelsmann far earlier (in fact I think they messed up by signing Nagelsmann at all).
 

Castia

Full Member
Joined
Jun 18, 2011
Messages
18,414
The results definitely. Exited the cup (lost at home against Freiburg), exited the CL against City and lost the lead in the league.

But as argued above this likely is a case of he came too late to stop the downward spiral, because it isn't just a mental problem, but Bayern lack physical fitness as well.

Part of the reason why Bayern won ten titles in a row is that they always were able to turn around games, if necessary in extra time. This season it consistently feels the opposite, even if they lead in a match you ask if they will get through. And far too often like yesterday against Mainz they won't.

There was no downward spiral under Nagelsmann he was competing for a treble with a 74% win rate when he was fired, it will go down as one of the most ridiculous sackings in football they’ve completely blown their season
 

Maluco

Last Man Standing 3 champion 2019/20
Joined
Jan 4, 2014
Messages
5,938
"both after Klopp", as in Klopp finished 4th (in the 2nd division) with Mainz, then another guy coached the entire next season and following pre-season and only then Tuchel took over and had success until the 6th year since Klopp's departure. I take it you were a big Mainz enjoyer at the time?
He had two decent finishes prior to that, so it’s not like like they weren’t accustomed to competing before that blip. He did well.

A lot of managers have done well at smaller clubs and failed to translate that to consistent top level management.
 

stefan92

Full Member
Joined
Feb 9, 2021
Messages
6,514
Supports
Hannover 96
There was no downward spiral under Nagelsmann he was competing for a treble with a 74% win rate when he was fired, it will go down as one of the most ridiculous sackings in football they’ve completely blown their season
Did you watch Bayern play this season? I can't remember another season where they looked consistenly that vulnerable. In the league they had the worst ppg average since ten years and the only reason it didn't blow up earlier in the season is that Barca and Dortmund usually shit themselves when they have to play against Bayern.
 

Castia

Full Member
Joined
Jun 18, 2011
Messages
18,414
Did you watch Bayern play this season? I can't remember another season where they looked consistenly that vulnerable. In the league they had the worst ppg average since ten years and the only reason it didn't blow up earlier in the season is that Barca and Dortmund usually shit themselves when they have to play against Bayern.
They was still digging out the results though at the minute they’d struggle against Wrexham theres a massive drop off
 

Maluco

Last Man Standing 3 champion 2019/20
Joined
Jan 4, 2014
Messages
5,938
I would disagree on Dortmund as a club. In the late Klopp and following Tuchel years they absolutely saw themselves as the true and ambitious challenger and wanted to win titles. Settling for being second best happened more recently, during Tuchel's time they were still willing and able to challenge Pep's Bayern, but after the bomb attack and the following dispute between Tuchel and the board this got lost.


That's a fair point I think, he just tends to use a pragmatic approach, not an aesthetically pleasing. I don't think that his personality is a problem however, at least not for the success of his teams.


If he fails at Bayern I will agree. But I won't judge him on this season, as I am convinced that the board messed up by not sacking Nagelsmann far earlier (in fact I think they messed up by signing Nagelsmann at all).
Surely your first point would indicate that the start of Dortmund’s decline was Tuchel? The politics and fractured relationship with the board was a problem that he left, after one cup win and a third place finish.

He has now left Dortmund after rumored clashes with the board, PSG after clashes with Leonardo, Chelsea after rumored issues and there are already murmurings of discontent about him after only a few games at Bayern.

Surely there can’t be this much smoke without fire when it comes to his personality? It’s an issue when it contributes to tension behind the scenes and contributes to eventual sackings.

That side of the game is part of being a top coach nowadays and he consistently plays his hand very badly.
 

stefan92

Full Member
Joined
Feb 9, 2021
Messages
6,514
Supports
Hannover 96
Surely your first point would indicate that the start of Dortmund’s decline was Tuchel? The politics and fractured relationship with the board was a problem that he left, after one cup win and a third place finish.

He has now left Dortmund after rumored clashes with the board,
No I think he was the last one preventing that mental decline from being a true challenger to a distant follower and the clashes with the board partially happened because of that.

But I agree that he definitely isn't acting very diplomatically when dealing with his bosses and that doesn't help him.
 

do.ob

Full Member
Joined
Jun 19, 2010
Messages
15,626
Location
Germany
Supports
Borussia Dortmund
He had two decent finishes prior to that, so it’s not like like they weren’t accustomed to competing before that blip. He did well.

A lot of managers have done well at smaller clubs and failed to translate that to consistent top level management.
I don't even like the guy, but the way you try dismiss the meaning of everything bar his work for Chelsea, where he still won the CL, is ridiculous.

He didn't just do well at Mainz, he performed miracles and he's a big reason for why they now have a fairly safe spot in the first division, instead of being a random team in the second.

At Dortmund his first season was a low key miracle as well, considering how things had ended under Klopp and the following year he did great in the CL, until the bus attack, and eventually won the cup.

At PSG he had a season north of 90 points and got them to the CL final.

And you summarize that as "failed to translate that to consistent top level management", what the heck?

I mean we all know that he has a toxic personality and that talking himself out of his job seems inevitable, but before that happens he clearly does good coaching work - unfortunately.
 

Pintu

Full Member
Joined
Apr 12, 2015
Messages
4,196
Location
Sweden
They was still digging out the results though at the minute they’d struggle against Wrexham theres a massive drop off
No they weren’t getting results… Dortmund had just gained something like 10 points on them in about 2 months.
 

Dancfc

Full Member
Joined
Oct 28, 2016
Messages
7,411
Supports
Chelsea
I haven’t really been impressed with him since his PSG days, don’t really get him to be honest. He obviously did well to win the CL but I think it was more luck that anything, the ultimate new manager bounce.
The only "luck" involved in that UCL win was for the opposition that we didn't beat them by more.