You've made up your mind after one game? I'm not even going ask how you've come to those conclusions with the rest of your post.
I don't come up with that on the basis of the Norwich game. i come up with that on the basis of Giggs having 0 managerial experience and no proper training as a coach. At least Pep Guardiola had a proper training as a coach and he had a bit of experience coaching on the lower youth levels. With Ryan it is absolutley nothing, no experience, no training, just the fact he has been here at the club for a long time and he looks good in the suit.
I'd have said those things before he coached a single aswell. You want to know how I make my conclusions, because I use the grey mass in my head called a brain. It doesn't take a genius to know that somebody without any managerial experience or proper training will fail in one of the biggest managerial jobs in the world. According to your logic, we might aswell give the position to Fred the Red, he also knows what the club is about and we haven't seen his management skills yet, so we can't comment on them either. What a load of bullshit and flawed logic !
Before you get to be coach, you had better taken coaching lessons, were they school you about tactics, formations, playing systems, the strong points and weak points and finner details of all those matters. They teach you about the psychology of training, what you have to deal with, how you can deal with it. Than it takes years of experience to put those things into practice and you start at the begining, a lower league side, not a powerhouse like Manchester United. You learn on the job build up your set of knowledge, learn from your mistakes, form an own philosphy about football, putting it into practice, learn from the exerpience, adepting your philosphy until you find of working that works, than you specialise in that, you perfect it, you get results with it, you show the world your philosphy and your coaching methods and if a big club wants you than you do it at a big club. That it how it works. Ryan hasn't been through anyone of those steps, I make my assumption he won't be able to tactically outclass any kind of manager that hass, because I believe those things aren't complete bullshit. Because that is the only way Ryan would ever succeed in this job, if all those things, proper training, learning, building up experience, developing an own philosphy are complete bullshit. Ryan hasn't had the time to go through any of those steps, yet why he hasn't got a single chance of succeeding at the challenge of managing Manchester United. I thought this was one of the biggest clubs in the world and one of the most challenging managerial jobs in the world, yet it seems like most suited according to you (and the club) are the ones without any managerial experience at all, that is madness, there is no other word, it is madness !
On top of that, Giggs is biased, he has been a teammate to all of those players for years. Alot of them are his friends. The coach shouldn't be friends with his players, that is an unhealthy situation. Football is about competition, the one best suited to the posituion is the one that should play, and the one best suited depends, on quality, attitude and about the system in which you want to play. It doesn't depend on who you like more or less. he has already said, the hardest thing was deciding who would start and who wouldn't, not in the sense that he didn't know, in the sense that it was hard for him to look them in the eye and tell them they weren't going to play. He said the players didn't sulk or moan, so he was lucky, what about next season, if those decisions will be bread and butter business, how can he do a good job if that is the hardest part ? He'll have to make those decisons day in day out, what will he do if his mates start moaning, if they start sulking. Will he be able to tear them a new one, will he be able to bring up the hammer, the hair dryer. Will he be able to punish his mates if they are late for training because they went out partying into the late hours ? More important will he be able to transfer his mates if they aren't the right players for this club, will he be able to chose a new player that he doesn't know as a person over somebody that has been his teammate for over years ? I don't think those will be easy decisions to make in his position. If your day to day life becomes a series a decisions between your work or your mates than it is likely you'll make some biased decisions in the end.
