I’n in team ”Give Ten Hag a chance under new management and not appoint an underwhelming candidate”. We know for a fact Ten Hag is not a shite manager, he did a fantastic job at Ajax. Everyone was drooling watching his Ajax team push deep into the Champions League. Sure, he never replicated that in Europe but he did lose key players the following season. With talent and decent lads at his disposal I believe he can do good things.
If someone succeeds as a coach at Manchester United now it’s because of the new ownership, not because of their incredible management skills. We’ve sacked 6 managers in 11 years. Sacking and appointing has not worked for 11 years. If sacking and appointing works now it’s because of the new ownership. Might as well give Ten Hag a shot at it because the candidates on the market are not better than him. They are either on the same level or SLIGHTLY better (Tuchel, Potter, Nagelsmann) or slightly below or the same (Southgate, Flick, Mourinho) or not a good fit for United (Inzaghi). If we were to go for a new manager I’d rather go for a complete wild card, like McKenna, who has potential and a lot to prove. Might as well.
Other than that the only ones I would appoint are those who are clearly better managers than Ten Hag. Those are Pep Guardiola and Jurgen Klopp. These two are the definite top 2 managers, the rest are moving up and down in the list, overtaking each other in periods of good form, then dropping down the list again in difficult times. Perhaps Zidane is worth a shout, but even he is doubtful even though his legendary aura would be enough to spur motivation. Pep and Klopp however are the only managers who would not only survive the Glazers, but thrive, because they are just on that level. Obviously that will never happen but the point is there is no manager available at that level. Might as well try to keep building on the foundation we already have. Might as well try to give the managers the tools to succeed. Let’s see how he does in a functional system.