Billy Blaggs
Flacco of the Blaggs tribe
He obviously meant Udinese.Never played for Napoli. And yes he has stank up the place.
He obviously meant Udinese.Never played for Napoli. And yes he has stank up the place.
I would agree. Personally always thought both Martial and Rashford were strikers but over time I have changed my opinion on Rashford who is enjoyable to watch and talented but I just dont see as a striker anymore, actually more of an impact player.He has been tried on the right side against Spurs and Newcastle last season and didn't do well. It debrive him of his best weapons, cutting inside and shooting the R2 shot with his right leg. He becomes underwhelming without this.
Best solution is for him to be a sub for Lukaku in strker position while Rashford become a sub for Sanchez on the left.
But I half agree with this, Mourinho wont play him over Lukaku, or rest Lukaku. Still dont get everybodies idea about who to move over to the right, especially when people say Lukaku (laughable). I could see Sanchez there (sure he played on the right for Udinese)....but again I dont see Rashford as a started, or Martial on the left....so our best option at the moment surely is Lingard anyway? He was afte all our most improved player and actually one of our good players last year?Sell him. He is crap on the right, Sanchez won't be moved to the right. Mourinho will never prefer him as a striker, even as a sub(Lukaku won't be subbed anyway).
Get over itIts a podcast, hosted by a guy who wished United to lose games during LvG era and he doesnt see anything wrong in so called United fans wishing the same. You should go and check it out, maybe you will like it.
Rashford is terrible though, he doesn't deserve to start over Martial currently, whether it's on form or accomplishments (not that Martial has set the bar very high, mind you). Martial at least has had an impact from the left and he plays much better with Lukaku than Rashford. Hopefully Jose figures it out, or sell him in January and be done with it.I think it's a waste of time. Jose doesn't like him on the left so there's feck all chance he'll be happy with him on the right. I'd rather have Rashford there, or god forbid a right winger.
We are a very poor passing side, there is literally zero movement, we'd go nowhere with that formation.Ditch wingers. We don't have any.
DDGJust my humble opinion anyway
Valencia, Bailly, Lindelof, Young
Matic
Fred, Pogba,
Sanchez
Lukaku, Martial
![]()
I don't totally agree with that, our back four aren't natural passers that's for sure but Matic and pogba are both capable passers of the ball. Fred is supposed to be, only time will tell. Sanchez used to be dangerous and I hope he can be again.We are a very poor passing side, there is literally zero movement, we'd go nowhere with that formation.
If you are going to play through the middle, your passing and movement have to be top notch otherwise the opposition with set up a deep block and defend compactly. We aren't that good at passing or movement, we'd end up having fullbacks launch crosses inside with that formation.I don't totally agree with that, our back four aren't natural passers that's for sure but Matic and pogba are both capable passers of the ball. Fred is supposed to be, only time will tell. Sanchez used to be dangerous and I hope he can be again.
What would we lose by this formation? Two wingers that don't actually provide much. At least with this we would have more attacking intent without trying to create width without the right players.
Again, just my opinion obviously.
Best weapon - your right, problem is that’s about his only weapon. Perhaps playing on the right will force him to develop him game. Otherwise he is in serious danger of being a one trick pony.It debrive him of his best weapons, cutting inside and shooting the R2 shot with his right leg. He becomes underwhelming without this.
I think that it's more of a positioning and anticipation issue, when he is actually in a position to strike the ball, he is pretty good in the air.I remember making a note of Everton not playing with wingers because his aerial ability was limited, and to be fair what he's shown for us has been distinctly average.
For a guy his size, he should be absolutely dominant.
Great post, and agreed. I really believe Lukaku would shine even more if he played consistently with Martial.I don't think you can have both your wide players cutting inside if you don't have quality full backs able to deliver a good cross from the outside. Young crosses well, but he has to cut back inside to do it. The whole point of a winger cutting back in on his stronger foot, aside from giving him the option to shoot, is to create space for the overlap. So with that in mind, at least one of our nominal wide players, has to play with their strongest foot on the outside, keep width, and predominantly go past defenders on the outside. The natural option here is Sanchez on the right, and Martial or Rashford cutting in from the left. I think we all believed this was why he was signed. The way we have used him, as a Martial or Rashford replacement, is utterly bizarre for me. His signing, to date, hasn't improved our first eleven at all. But it doesn't need to be that way.
I also always had a hankering to see Rashford have a good run of games on the right. He hasn't ever truly impressed there, but I think his combination of searing pace, and his ability to whip a ball in, are the natural attributes you need in a wide player. So much last season we suffered because our play was so narrow, and teams just stuffed up the middle making it impossible for us to breakthrough. Additionally, you really need at least one player like Martial or Rashford in the starting XI, because they are the two players we have that are truly able to beat a man. Beating players one on one is so important to disturbing the tactical equilibrium of the opposition as you can create overload situations. Pretty much all the top teams have those type of players. Even the pass masters of that great Barca team, had Messi who could take 2-3 players out of the game and destroy a team's defensive shape. Our top premier league rivals, City and Liverpool, both have multiple players who can do it consistently and effectively: De Bruyne, Silva, Sterling, Sane, Mane, Salah etc. I think the only reason Spurs aren't serious title challengers, is the absence of that maverick type talent. Because they have everything else.
For me, the best XI we can put out has to have Martial and Sanchez in it, and it has to give Pobga the license to break forwards and get goals from deep. I don't think Mata adds much of anything to our play coming in from the right. For a supposed counter-attacking team, you need someone explosive in that role. His lack of pace so often breaks down potential counter attacks as he can beat a man over 5 yards, but is hauled back in incredibly quickly. Not much good if you are sitting deep and need to exploit 60 yards of space ahead of you. For me, I'd be content seeing him in a deeper role, as that third central midfielder where his eye for a pass and reading of the game can be put to much better use.
If it was me, I would play the formation below. A unit that would be transformed as an attacking threat, with a high class left back. Drop a Marcelo or Sandro into that team and I think it looks as good as nearly any team in Europe. That's how important full backs are. Right now oppositions can easily funnel our "wingers" inside, because there's no serious overlap threat, and double up on them. Personally I think it's criminal this has gone unaddressed again. Instead spending the entire summer chasing a center back, when we already have 5 international class stoppers on the books. No one is saying that we couldn't upgrade in those areas, but priorities!
![]()
When I look at that lineup on paper, and assess the qualities of each player, it seems obvious to me that that front six is exceptional. IF played correctly. I don't think we've really seen us line up like that across the front 3 yet, for anything more than 25 mins at the end of a match. The obvious area of concern is the full back positions. If Dalot is as good as we hope, then I'm content with right back. But neither of our left back options are anywhere near good enough for a title challenging team.
Our squad is preposterously unbalanced again. We have, what? 8 central midfielders competing for 3 spots? Pogba, Fred, Matic, Andreas, Herrera, Fellaini, Lingard, and Mctominay. Lingard may be our back up option for the right, but again...far from ideal.
Meanwhile, our right wide options are Lingard - who isn't well suited there - Mata, who is the slowest player in the universe, and Sanchez, who the manager refuses to play there. TBH if we are lining up as we should (see above) then our striking options are thin too. Martial and Rashford competing for the left, and no real back up to Lukaku. If two of Rashford, Martial, lukaku and Sanchez are unavailable at the same time, then the attack looks feeble. Our priorities in terms of signings should have been (in order) LB - RW - CM - CF - RB - CB.
I don't think you can have both your wide players cutting inside if you don't have quality full backs able to deliver a good cross from the outside. Young crosses well, but he has to cut back inside to do it. The whole point of a winger cutting back in on his stronger foot, aside from giving him the option to shoot, is to create space for the overlap. So with that in mind, at least one of our nominal wide players, has to play with their strongest foot on the outside, keep width, and predominantly go past defenders on the outside. The natural option here is Sanchez on the right, and Martial or Rashford cutting in from the left. I think we all believed this was why he was signed. The way we have used him, as a Martial or Rashford replacement, is utterly bizarre for me. His signing, to date, hasn't improved our first eleven at all. But it doesn't need to be that way.
I also always had a hankering to see Rashford have a good run of games on the right. He hasn't ever truly impressed there, but I think his combination of searing pace, and his ability to whip a ball in, are the natural attributes you need in a wide player. So much last season we suffered because our play was so narrow, and teams just stuffed up the middle making it impossible for us to breakthrough. Additionally, you really need at least one player like Martial or Rashford in the starting XI, because they are the two players we have that are truly able to beat a man. Beating players one on one is so important to disturbing the tactical equilibrium of the opposition as you can create overload situations. Pretty much all the top teams have those type of players. Even the pass masters of that great Barca team, had Messi who could take 2-3 players out of the game and destroy a team's defensive shape. Our top premier league rivals, City and Liverpool, both have multiple players who can do it consistently and effectively: De Bruyne, Silva, Sterling, Sane, Mane, Salah etc. I think the only reason Spurs aren't serious title challengers, is the absence of that maverick type talent. Because they have everything else.
For me, the best XI we can put out has to have Martial and Sanchez in it, and it has to give Pobga the license to break forwards and get goals from deep. I don't think Mata adds much of anything to our play coming in from the right. For a supposed counter-attacking team, you need someone explosive in that role. His lack of pace so often breaks down potential counter attacks as he can beat a man over 5 yards, but is hauled back in incredibly quickly. Not much good if you are sitting deep and need to exploit 60 yards of space ahead of you. For me, I'd be content seeing him in a deeper role, as that third central midfielder where his eye for a pass and reading of the game can be put to much better use.
If it was me, I would play the formation below. A unit that would be transformed as an attacking threat, with a high class left back. Drop a Marcelo or Sandro into that team and I think it looks as good as nearly any team in Europe. That's how important full backs are. Right now oppositions can easily funnel our "wingers" inside, because there's no serious overlap threat, and double up on them. Personally I think it's criminal this has gone unaddressed again. Instead spending the entire summer chasing a center back, when we already have 5 international class stoppers on the books. No one is saying that we couldn't upgrade in those areas, but priorities!
![]()
When I look at that lineup on paper, and assess the qualities of each player, it seems obvious to me that that front six is exceptional. IF played correctly. I don't think we've really seen us line up like that across the front 3 yet, for anything more than 25 mins at the end of a match. The obvious area of concern is the full back positions. If Dalot is as good as we hope, then I'm content with right back. But neither of our left back options are anywhere near good enough for a title challenging team.
Our squad is preposterously unbalanced again. We have, what? 8 central midfielders competing for 3 spots? Pogba, Fred, Matic, Andreas, Herrera, Fellaini, Lingard, and Mctominay. Lingard may be our back up option for the right, but again...far from ideal.
Meanwhile, our right wide options are Lingard - who isn't well suited there - Mata, who is the slowest player in the universe, and Sanchez, who the manager refuses to play there. TBH if we are lining up as we should (see above) then our striking options are thin too. Martial and Rashford competing for the left, and no real back up to Lukaku. If two of Rashford, Martial, lukaku and Sanchez are unavailable at the same time, then the attack looks feeble. Our priorities in terms of signings should have been (in order) LB - RW - CM - CF - RB - CB.
You musn’t have watched him at “Napoli”(Udinese) because he in tandem with Di Natale were frightening and for most of that was operating off the right where he was up there as one of the best right sided players there was at the time.Look at where Sanchez spent his time playing on the right wing: at Barcelona (underwhelming) and Napoli (not world class).
His best performances at Arsenal (where he became world class) were from the left or centre
Also what's all this about him stinking up the place? He's one of two risk takers on our team. People cry about our team being boring, this guy is the complete opposite.
Pretty muchI'm fine with him being tried on the right. He's been totally invisible/ineffective from the left plenty of times, so I don't know why people are using two games as a reason not to.
Our entire team is predictable, Sanchez looked pretty amazing at Arsenal and he has looked predictable in his time here. Since our passing and transition is slow, we can never have a player playing off the last man like Salah does at Liverpool, by the time the ball is moved from defence to attack, the opposition are already deep and compact.I think he needs to bstop being so predictable which is why he is not as effective as he was when he was an unknown quantity.
If he could run into the space or onto the ball rather than wanting ball to feet then turn and try and take someone on around the halfway one which has been shit down more often than not by opposition players.
If he could vary it up a bit he might get more joy. I would be very interested to see if he could play off the lastman:shoulder and break the lines. It could be the making of him
thought we were going to do this after playing 3 at the back in pre-seasonPlay 2 up front. Play martial as a striker.
Problem solved.
Yes. Sanchez has played on the right for Barcelona and Udinese. And he is capable of cutting both ways, and actually has a decent left foot. And does have a good cross in him. Why we are playing Mata at RW (or playing him at all), is beyond me.So where to play him? In my view the answer is from the left, in a supporting role for Lukaku with Sanchez playing from the right, form allowing. In this rile his defensive duties are reduced and he's well placed for a counter attack, which may well be the style Mourinho goes for this season. In respect to Sanchez, he's the seasoned "world class" player so he should be far more capable than Martial playing from the right. This however is rarely mentioned despite it being obvious...