Giggs, Beckham or Keane. Hard to choose.
Your one past United player as a summer transfer
- Thread starter Murder on Zidanes Floor
- Start date
Vidic would be nice.
Has to be Gabriel Obertan.
Man Utd's Ronaldo. I strongly believe the current iteration would struggle here.
Roy Keane. He'd give some of our under performers a good kick up their arse
Beckham would be perfect. Imagine him pinging crosses to Lukaku.
Nah, imagine him pinging crosses to Fellaini!
Keane is my favorite United player ever and the best of that era.
But the answer is Ronaldo.
But the answer is Ronaldo.
Best and no mourinho for me. If we have to stick with mourinho then probably keane or charlton.
How can you all forgot Eric Cantona. He is a complete forward and a complete mid-fielder. He changed the fortune of the club in 90s. We desperately need a player like him.
If only we have one more season of Bebe.
My heart says Duncan Edwards. My head says King Eric.
Its always the obvious answer isn't it? Seems like someone from the Class of '92 could be a dream situation for manager for several reasons. The team obviously lacks the backbone of a Keane, Giggs or Scholes.
Ryan Giggs, Ryan Giggs running down the wing...
Vidic circa 09
Our defence is shite & we have no leaders. Two birds one stone & that.
Our defence is shite & we have no leaders. Two birds one stone & that.
Scholes
My thoughts exactly, plus I dont think modern day football could handle a prime Roy Keane.
Keane.
But Beckham considering our squad composition would be an actual fit to the side too.
But Beckham considering our squad composition would be an actual fit to the side too.
Roy Keane all day every day.
He would instantly elevate every player around him and players would start playing to their potential.
He would instantly elevate every player around him and players would start playing to their potential.
Chill Hamlet. We came second in the league.
For me it’d be Best or Ronaldo - not only the two best players ability wise to play for United but both also address the weakest area of our team on the right wing.
Pushing them very close though would be Keane. We need a leader and someone to add some control to our midfield.
Roy Keane.
No half assed performances from other players when he’s on the pitch.
We are missing that leader that grabs the whole team by the scruff of the neck and leads by example.
No half assed performances from other players when he’s on the pitch.
We are missing that leader that grabs the whole team by the scruff of the neck and leads by example.
Ok, tad dramatic alright maybe. But if not rotten then at least soft or lacking in in the required mentality.Ronaldo
Evra
Ferdinand
Those are the three areas I'd like to see improved this summer. RW, LB, CB but Keane also makes a whole lot of sense too.
Ronaldo would probably be #1 though.
Evra
Ferdinand
Those are the three areas I'd like to see improved this summer. RW, LB, CB but Keane also makes a whole lot of sense too.
Ronaldo would probably be #1 though.
Has to be Keane.
Roy Motherfecking Keane
Keane.
he wouldn’t stand for the trash we have.
he wouldn’t stand for the trash we have.
Keano for me. Better players available for sure, more flair players like CR7 or Giggsy. But Keano brings a lot more than just raw football ability to the table. He won games in the tunnel before a ball was kicked. A leader on the pitch that has not been replaced since he left in my opinion. Added to that he had everything in his locker to a consistently high standard week in week out.
Feck it, just sign Keane as assistant manager, he would'nt have stood for any of this nonsense from Martial. Gets along great with José as well.
Lee Sharpe would make a great attacking LB these days.
But Ronaldo or Best on the right side wouldn't go amiss.
But Ronaldo or Best on the right side wouldn't go amiss.
This is, almost impossible to answer for me.
If you were allowed managers, of course SAF would be top of the list.
Players wise how do you approach this?
Vidic to give us a solid brick wall defence?
Cristiano to send us on our way to the title with a 40 goal season?
Scholesy in his peak to bag us a load of goals and added creativity to the middle?
Keano to add some steele and no nonsense back in the squad?
Saying that, Roy Keane and Pogba in the same team... don't think I can quite picture it!
Good question OP, I cannot decide!
If you were allowed managers, of course SAF would be top of the list.
Players wise how do you approach this?
Vidic to give us a solid brick wall defence?
Cristiano to send us on our way to the title with a 40 goal season?
Scholesy in his peak to bag us a load of goals and added creativity to the middle?
Keano to add some steele and no nonsense back in the squad?
Saying that, Roy Keane and Pogba in the same team... don't think I can quite picture it!
Good question OP, I cannot decide!
Cantona! 
Any of the below five seven
Scholes/Keane- need more creativity and bite from midfield
Rio - need the cbs to get the ball into attack faster, they're part the reason we're often slow
Beckham/GNeville - Huge gap in right wing, having a fullback who can actually deliver a ball too would make a difference
Ronnie/Cantona - Why wouldn't you?
Scholes/Keane- need more creativity and bite from midfield
Rio - need the cbs to get the ball into attack faster, they're part the reason we're often slow
Beckham/GNeville - Huge gap in right wing, having a fullback who can actually deliver a ball too would make a difference
Ronnie/Cantona - Why wouldn't you?
Ronaldo then Scholes then Evra then Rio.
My words to have them back...
My words to have them back...
Evra
We're crying out for a right winger, so it would have to be Ronaldo for me.
Gary Neville kthxbye
Im also inclined to belive that a Modern day version of, Roy Kean is needed!