YouOnlyLiveTwice
Full Member
- Joined
- Apr 27, 2014
- Messages
- 5,468
I don't think Barcelona will be letting Pedro go this year due to transfer ban but I imagine once Turan and Vidal join them in January he will be sold. He's going to be a great buy for whoever decides to sign him.
The issue is who to replace him with if we get an astronomical fee. Players of his ability who are established aren't easy to find. And we don't need the money.
Exactly.It would need to be a swap deal (which is highly unlikely) for me to see sense - i.e. Goetze or someone else from Munich. Cash is not what we need - we need quality and despite his form last season, he has quality in abundance. Therefore, unless we are bringing in someone of equal ability, it makes no sense to let him go.
I suppose you could also say 'One good season in Spain and all of a sudden he is a world class player'One bad season in a new country and everybody just forgot how crazy good the guy is.
While I think it would be mental to give up on AdM at this stage from United's persepctive (especially given some of his early season form) if he doesn't want to be here and is agitating for a move away then selling him is absolutely the right decision.Am I alone in seeing sense in selling Di Maria? Whenever a story links him with a move away people seem aghast but it seems reasonable enough to me.
The problem with you and I, is that we know very little, LVG knows if he can do something with Di Maria or not, and he doesn't need more than a few months. I would say that coaches like Van gaal, Mourinho or Guardiola are typically the type of coaches who assess players quickly because they have a very clear game plan.I don't think coach like LVG would make decisions based on just one season with our weakness held elsewhere.
It should the media crap that thrown everywhere.
On the wing he has been World Class for Argentina though.I suppose you could also say 'One good season in Spain and all of a sudden he is a world class player'
I am not actually doubting his talent, but on the wing for Real Madrid he was a good player, but would never have been classed as world class. As a few have said, as a winger, he isn't worth what we paid for him.
Through the middle he doesn't really suit our system very well. Quick player who had a great season playing counter attack football and Real, but struggling to play tika taka at United.
If we could get a good price for him, I'd sell him. One bad season doesn't really hurt his market value much, but if he struggles again next season, then we would be looking at a big loss for him
No he hasn't, 'World Class' should recognize some sort of consistency, Di Maria has always been a cracking winger capable of creating things from nothing but he has never been consistent and therefore never been 'world class'.On the wing he has been World Class for Argentina though.
From a french tweet aggregator who calls himself Jon LeGossip...Where's all of this Di Maria being sold talk coming from? anywhere solid?
Seems legitFrom a french tweet aggregator who calls himself Jon LeGossip...
Not too sure about that. He has been excellent pretty much every game for Argentina in the last 2 years. He was arguably the best player for them at the WC, One of the better ones in the recent Copa America and tears teams to shreds in quite a lot of friendlies they have played also.No he hasn't, 'World Class' should recognize some sort of consistency, Di Maria has always been a cracking winger capable of creating things from nothing but he has never been consistent and therefore never been 'world class'.
PS: World Class is a nasty expression.
He was shit at the world cup, don't want to be rude but you clearly haven't seen a minute of him at the WC.Not too sure about that. He has been excellent pretty much every game for Argentina in the last 2 years. He was arguably the best player for them at the WC, One of the better ones in the recent Copa America and tears teams to shreds in quite a lot of friendlies they have played also.
Shit? Everyone has their opinions - but yours is obviously wrong. Argentina/Messi missed him when he got injured.He was shit at the world cup, don't want to be rude but you clearly haven't seen a minute of him at the WC.
He wasn't good, Mascherano, Garay, Messi and Sergio Romero were the best players.Shit? Everyone has their opinions - but yours is obviously wrong. Argentina/Messi missed him when he got injured.
That's not gonna happen. People can't seriously think we just sell players without having a good idea of who is coming in.If we get rid of Di Maria and Van Persie in one window, without any quality replacements coming in, i wonder what LVG and Woody have been smoking.
I watched every one of their games unfortunately, and every last one of them was boring. Didn't disguise the fact he was probably their best player. I dread to think what your standards must be then.He was shit at the world cup, don't want to be rude but you clearly haven't seen a minute of him at the WC.
Schweinsteiger and Muller and we can talk.The only way I'd sell di Maria is if we sign Bale. Why would Schweinsteiger be part of a deal though, doesn't make sense.
I'd agree with you that he wasn't the best player - Mascherano was by far - but I defintely wouldnt call him shit - thought he played well and allowed Messi to play much better before he got injured.He wasn't good, Mascherano, Garay, Messi and Sergio Romero were the best players.
By Di Maria's standards it wasn't good.I watched every one of their games unfortunately, and every last one of them was boring. Didn't disguise the fact he was probably their best player. I dread to think what your standards must be then.
Yeah I will admit, shit is over the top but pretending that it was even close from his best or from a world class tournament is also over the top.I'd agree with you that he wasn't the best player - Mascherano was by far - but I defintely wouldnt call him shit - thought he played well and allowed Messi to play much better before he got injured.
Jon LeGossip
Is this guy reliable? It just doesn't make sense to sell someone who is seemingly determined to stay and who we have spent so much on, especially if we get a past-it Schweinsteiger instead of a Goetze or Muller, in return.Tweet
— Twitter API (@user) date
We are definitely not missing a #10 in our team. If anything, we have too many of those.A great player but not my favorite .The price seems excessive , but it is inevitable that United will have that problem in the future. All clubs are aware of the new deal with Adidas and the financial power. In any case , I see it difficult , I think he is very identified with Bavaria and Bayern. The relationship with Pep should be very bad to consider an exit. I would try Gotze before, certainly cheaper and with the talent that the midfield is missing