2009 final, we didn't play our best team like we did in 2008, instead we elected to play Park which was a mistake. Also scholesey on the bench against a team you need to keep the ball against.. ditto Tevez. Feel like SAF got that one wrong.. If we played the team that started in the 08 final, or if we played Scholes, Tevez and possibly Nani instead of Park / Giggs / Ando, I feel like we would have won.
2008 FA cup semi second I guess, but I don't mind much given how succesfull a year it was regardless of that.