Brexited | the worst threads live the longest

Do you think there will be a Deal or No Deal?


  • Total voters
    194
  • Poll closed .

Adebesi

Full Member
Joined
Dec 6, 2006
Messages
19,159
Location
Sanctity, like a cat, abhors filth.
This is like the matchday thread. What is the concern her deal will pass based on? I'm in Thailand on hols and am coming into today's fresh hell cold.
For me its the fact that the likes of Johnson and JRM have folded. But to be fair I dont see anything to suggest Labour will do the same.

I thought the last vote would be close too and I was completely wrong. I am probably just bracing myself for it, rather than really expecting it for logical reasons.
 

mancan92

Full Member
Joined
Jan 9, 2011
Messages
10,225
Location
Loughborough university
This is like the matchday thread. What is the concern her deal will pass based on? I'm in Thailand on hols and am coming into today's fresh hell cold.
Rumours of Labour MPs rebelling and voting for the deal. Also now seems the ERG will mostly be voting for the deal. There will be very little in it. But if she can get a decent portion of labour rebels on board then it could get through.
 

Fully Fledged

Full Member
Joined
May 23, 2013
Messages
16,303
Location
Midlands UK
Just seen on social media, people planning to drive stupidly slow along the M60 from Heaton Park at 7:30/8:00 this morning. For those that know the M60 that's all they'll be doing anyway, it's gridlocked at that time no matter what.

I'd really love to speak to some of the idiots that have gone out of their way to sit in rush hour traffic for no reason :lol:
They are going to say look how slow the traffic is going. That is how much people care about Brexit. It's like saying I'm gonna sit in my car for 20 minutes not moving between 8 and 9 on the M25. You now it's gonna happen anyway.
 

Fully Fledged

Full Member
Joined
May 23, 2013
Messages
16,303
Location
Midlands UK
Rumours of Labour MPs rebelling and voting for the deal. Also now seems the ERG will mostly be voting for the deal. There will be very little in it. But if she can get a decent portion of labour rebels on board then it could get through.
The rebels will vote for it that's a given They did last time.
 

Jippy

Sleeps with tramps, bangs jacuzzis, dirty shoes
Staff
Joined
Nov 19, 2009
Messages
57,630
Location
Jet fuel doesn't melt steel beams
For me its the fact that the likes of Johnson and JRM have folded. But to be fair I dont see anything to suggest Labour will do the same.

I thought the last vote would be close too and I was completely wrong. I am probably just bracing myself for it, rather than really expecting it for logical reasons.
Rumours of Labour MPs rebelling and voting for the deal. Also now seems the ERG will mostly be voting for the deal. There will be very little in it. But if she can get a decent portion of labour rebels on board then it could get through.
Thanks, appreciate the update- it's weird being on holiday but also fretting about Brexit.

Johnson is only folding cos of his naked opportunism about the PM job. The Guardian seemed confident it would not go through earlier, just hope they're right. I fully understand why one would mentally prepare for the worst. Thought Labour wouldn't vote for a 'blindfold Brexit' though and this still has the hated back-stop in there.
 

Jacko21

Full Member
Joined
Mar 27, 2016
Messages
4,587
Location
Manchester
It's important to keep in mind, however, that even if the number of Eurosceptics grows, they are still a minority. Appeasing the minority out of fear is rarely a wise course of action.

The UK never really bought into the European project. Their vision of the EU is fundamentally different from, well, the actual aims and goals of it as stated in its constitutional documents. I do not believe the entire EU should start moving in a completely different direction simply for the sake of UK exceptionalism.

The assertion that the EU ignores criticism is essentially a meaningless one. What criticism does it ignore? What should it do? Who ignores the criticism? Those critical of it have voices: in the European Parliament, in the Council of the European Union, in the European Council. Its the ministers of national governments that appoint the members of the Commission.

The EU is not some monolithic dictatorial entity, it's just usually how it's depicted in Britain, for some reason. It's made up of its member states. Its governing bodies are made up of the member states' representatives. If those who believe that it should just be a free trade bloc or something similar gain a majority in these institutions, the EU will move toward devolvement. Until then it won't.
When I speak about the EU, I speak about the member states too - it is about collective responsibility. I don't dispute that in plenty of cases, anger that should be directed at the respective governments, is in fact hurled at Brussels. But the threat nonetheless remains - and so it'd seem sensible to me to look to collectively address that threat rather than to ignore it and hope that it remains a minority. Nor does it seem sensible to double-down on the very thing that people have long expressed concerns about - greater centralisation. The UK can't be treated as a 'problem child' and the referendum result dismissed as a freak. As of last year, only 28% of people believed the EU was headed in the 'right direction', hardly a ringing endorsement.
 

Adebesi

Full Member
Joined
Dec 6, 2006
Messages
19,159
Location
Sanctity, like a cat, abhors filth.
Thanks, appreciate the update- it's weird being on holiday but also fretting about Brexit.

Johnson is only folding cos of his naked opportunism about the PM job. The Guardian seemed confident it would not go through earlier, just hope they're right. I fully understand why one would mentally prepare for the worst. Thought Labour wouldn't vote for a 'blindfold Brexit' though and this still has the hated back-stop in there.
If I was Johnson I would have played it a bit differently though, yes he wants to be PM and so wants May to go and so yes, getting the deal through helps facilitate that, but do people really think the only way May goes is if she passes her deal? She is Dead PM Walking either way, all he has done is opened himself up to accusations of self interest and flip flopping, and angered his die hard Brexiter fans. He should (IMO) have played a slightly longer game, (for once) stuck to his "principles" (pretending he has any) and waited, the job is going to open up one way or the other in the next few months. This just makes him look even more of an arsehole than usual, if that was even possible.

So the fact that he is swinging behind the deal makes me think that is where he feels the wind is blowing. I read it as, Johnson always wants to back the winning horse, so him getting behind the deal is evidence that he thinks a critical mass of MPs are doing the same. He is a follower, not a leader.

But as I said, I have no real conviction in my ability to accurately read these situations. It doesnt seem like this is how other people understand his actions, so I am probably reading it all wrong.
 

Jippy

Sleeps with tramps, bangs jacuzzis, dirty shoes
Staff
Joined
Nov 19, 2009
Messages
57,630
Location
Jet fuel doesn't melt steel beams
If I was Johnson I would have played it a bit differently though, yes he wants to be PM and so wants May to go and so yes, getting the deal through helps facilitate that, but do people really think the only way May goes is if she passes her deal? She is Dead PM Walking either way, all he has done is opened himself up to accusations of self interest and flip flopping, and angered his die hard Brexiter fans. He should (IMO) have played a slightly longer game, (for once) stuck to his "principles" (pretending he has any) and waited, the job is going to open up one way or the other in the next few months. This just makes him look even more of an arsehole than usual, if that was even possible.

So the fact that he is swinging behind the deal makes me think that is where he feels the wind is blowing. I read it as, Johnson always wants to back the winning horse, so him getting behind the deal is evidence that he thinks a critical mass of MPs are doing the same. He is a follower, not a leader.

But as I said, I have no real conviction in my ability to accurately read these situations. It doesnt seem like this is how other people understand his actions, so I am probably reading it all wrong.
That sounds a very credible and plausible reading of the situation, but the situation is so unpredictable and irrational that trying to call it is anyone's guess.

I just don't get Labour MPs voting with her- appreciate a lot of them have leave constituencies but literally no-one thinks the deal is in the best interests of the country.
 

Buster15

Go on Didier
Joined
Aug 28, 2018
Messages
13,715
Location
Bristol
Supports
Bristol Rovers
A better idea would have been to have a plan, firstly before the referendum was held and secondly before A50 was triggered. Three years further on no-one has the slightest idea what they want or how they could possibly get what they want.
If 50 years was given to the UK they still wouldn't know.

Two years is too long.
In an ideal world perhaps with you leading the team 2 years would be adequate.
But we all know that the world is not an ideal place.
 

Buster15

Go on Didier
Joined
Aug 28, 2018
Messages
13,715
Location
Bristol
Supports
Bristol Rovers
Two years is a reasonable timeframe for a withdrawal agreements when the leaving member state has a clear idea about where he wants to go. That's why after the referendum I said that the UK should only trigger art.50 when they are ready, it was going to upset some people in the UK and other EU countries but it was the sensible move to prepare a foolproof plan and then trigger art.50 which would have made the transition period simple and boring.
Instead they decided to improvise and gamble on the idea that EU officials/governments would lose their collective minds and either turn against each others or make ridiculous mistakes, that idea is probably the fruit of decades of belief that EU bureaucrats are mugs.
That is fair. Regrettably our politicians have demonstrated that they are not fit for purpose and while many are professional politicians, in reality they are absolute rank amateurs.
 

Infra-red

Full Member
Joined
May 4, 2010
Messages
13,555
Location
left wing
So do we think the offer to step down will actually be enough to bring her own party on board with deal? Another thing is that I thought the Speaker of the House already said there can't be a thrid vote on the same deal if no significant changes are introduced?
I don't think it will be enough, no. The offer to step down has in fact likely proved counter-productive in terms of securing Labour votes, because they're concerned that voting her deal through guarantees a hard Brexit under a new Brexiteer PM.

The speaker has allowed the vote because this is substantially different to the two previous meaningful votes - the political declaration regarding the future relationship, has been removed.
 

Adebesi

Full Member
Joined
Dec 6, 2006
Messages
19,159
Location
Sanctity, like a cat, abhors filth.
That sounds a very credible and plausible reading of the situation, but the situation is so unpredictable and irrational that trying to call it is anyone's guess.

I just don't get Labour MPs voting with her- appreciate a lot of them have leave constituencies but literally no-one thinks the deal is in the best interests of the country.
Maybe some people think the only acceptable solution will be one that is nobody's worst case scenario, even if it is also nobody's best case? An option that pisses everyone off, but without anybody being absolutely terminally outraged? Isnt that one way to proceed when you have the country split down the middle with completely contradictory views? This ticks that box.

Also, some people might be willing to vote for almost anything at this point to just be done with it. I think it is more this one that I can see motivating people, really. The sheer exhaustion and frustration of it, the loss of the will to live, let alone do a job as an MP. Vote for it so we can move on. (Even if we just go onto a new stage of Brexit.)

I think a lot of people in the country might feel like that. Be relieved if May's deal passes, even if it is shit, just so we dont have to hear any more about this damn withdrawal agreement.
 

Penna

Kind Moderator (with a bit of a mean streak)
Staff
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
49,729
Location
Ubi caritas et amor, Deus ibi est.
I don't think it will be enough, no. The offer to step down has in fact likely proved counter-productive in terms of securing Labour votes, because they're concerned that voting her deal through guarantees a hard Brexit under a new Brexiteer PM.

The speaker has allowed the vote because this is substantially different to the two previous meaningful votes - the political declaration regarding the future relationship, has been removed.
I agree with you. It would be a very risky thing to do, and a betrayal.
 

Buster15

Go on Didier
Joined
Aug 28, 2018
Messages
13,715
Location
Bristol
Supports
Bristol Rovers
That's bullshit. Corbyn could hand May a deal on a piece of paper, then May put's it to parliament and Labour would vote against it. Party politics nothing less. Labour have no cohesive stand on Brexit and neither is it their No. 1 one priority.
Have to agree.
I listened to K Starmer this morning and was disappointed with his argument.
He accepted that Labour agreed with the WA but would not vote for the WA because TM had separated it from the Political Declaration.

I would have hoped that they would compromise and support the WA and work with the government to make the PD acceptable given that it is open to negotiation.
Wishful thinking on my part.
 

JPRouve

can't stop thinking about balls - NOT deflategate
Scout
Joined
Jan 31, 2014
Messages
66,678
Location
France
That is fair. Regrettably our politicians have demonstrated that they are not fit for purpose and while many are professional politicians, in reality they are absolute rank amateurs.
I used to be involved in local politics and amateurs is the correct term, a large amount of politicians that get to the top do it through networking, they aren't even the ones selling their ideas to the population, that's done by anonymous supporters who actually talk to the common man/woman. The other thing is that if you get involved in politics you will quickly witness treachery, none of these people got there by being honest or loyal that's not how the system work.
 

Steven Seagull

Full Member
Joined
Aug 31, 2010
Messages
9,207
Location
The Clockwork Orange tulip technician.
If I have no say in what powers are created and how they are used what difference does it make whether they are made in London or Brussels?

I'm a complete Europhile. I buy into the idea that I can go anywhere in Europe at a split seconds notice. Can work anywhere in Europe or can study anywhere in Europe(even though my years of study are behind me).
Because the same issues in Scunthorpe aren’t the same as in Brescia. Farage and his mates have tainted the whole taking back control angle but the premise is very sound and simple to me. I am not an advocate of leaving the EU
 

That'sHernandez

Ominously close to getting banned
Joined
Oct 30, 2010
Messages
24,594
Because the same issues in Scunthorpe aren’t the same as in Brescia. Farage and his mates have tainted the whole taking back control angle but the premise is very sound and simple to me. I am not an advocate of leaving the EU
Yep I agree with this and this is largely what the non-sound bite quoting leave voters say to me. And it’s a position I do understand and respect, however it’s not something you can change from outside.
 

Klopper76

"Did you see Fabinho against Red Star & Cardiff?"
Joined
Dec 15, 2015
Messages
19,965
Location
Victoria, BC
Supports
Liverpool
Anyone know what the numbers are like for the pro-Brexit protest in Parliament Square?
 

Jippy

Sleeps with tramps, bangs jacuzzis, dirty shoes
Staff
Joined
Nov 19, 2009
Messages
57,630
Location
Jet fuel doesn't melt steel beams
Maybe some people think the only acceptable solution will be one that is nobody's worst case scenario, even if it is also nobody's best case? An option that pisses everyone off, but without anybody being absolutely terminally outraged? Isnt that one way to proceed when you have the country split down the middle with completely contradictory views? This ticks that box.

Also, some people might be willing to vote for almost anything at this point to just be done with it. I think it is more this one that I can see motivating people, really. The sheer exhaustion and frustration of it, the loss of the will to live, let alone do a job as an MP. Vote for it so we can move on. (Even if we just go onto a new stage of Brexit.)

I think a lot of people in the country might feel like that. Be relieved if May's deal passes, even if it is shit, just so we dont have to hear any more about this damn withdrawal agreement.
I guess, but feck, second referendum keeps feeling like it's in touching distance, but never quite close enough. That has to be the best outcome.
 

Adebesi

Full Member
Joined
Dec 6, 2006
Messages
19,159
Location
Sanctity, like a cat, abhors filth.
I guess, but feck, second referendum keeps feeling like it's in touching distance, but never quite close enough. That has to be the best outcome.
Its the best outcome for me and you and probably a majority at this point.

But I can also see the other side of the argument. When Ireland rejected the EU constitution and they were just told to vote again I remember shaking my head and thinking what a travesty of democracy that was. Keep asking till you get the answer you want, it is such an EU approach to politics. I can see that in this case there is a real justification for it, and I hope it happens, but if I was for Brexit I would feel the system was rigged against me if that happened.

Also, if a second referendum happens and we vote to remain, politics is going to be very, very ugly for a very, very long time. It is not a solution in that sense, it swaps one problem for another, and the problem we end up with will not be a walk in the park. I imagine there will be massive civil unrest.

Probably we get that whatever happens though.
 

Fully Fledged

Full Member
Joined
May 23, 2013
Messages
16,303
Location
Midlands UK
Because the same issues in Scunthorpe aren’t the same as in Brescia. Farage and his mates have tainted the whole taking back control angle but the premise is very sound and simple to me. I am not an advocate of leaving the EU
I think there is a bigger difference between someone who went to a Comp in the West Midlands and someone who went to Eton than there are between me and someone who went to a state school in Italy. I know this because I work with people who went to a state school in Italy and I know people who went to a public school in the UK.
 

Massive Spanner

The Football Grinch
Joined
Jul 2, 2014
Messages
28,536
Location
Tool shed
Conservative MP Rebecca Powell says she has not spoken in many of the Brexit debates, but it was now her moment as "time and time again we hear from the same people, but not often from the voices of reason".

To shouts of "the men", she says: "I am exasperated of the bickering and it cannot be beyond the men and women of this place to put the good of the nation first."

She adds that today's vote is "one small step for Parliament and one giant leap for the UK".
This woman actually used the moon landing quote in reference to today's Brexit vote.
 

Silva

Full Member
Joined
Apr 2, 2010
Messages
30,756
Location
Smoke crack like Isaac Asimov
"it's time for reason" has never been followed by the person saying a reasonable thing, it's like "I'm not a racist but", you don't know where it'll go but you know it won't be good
 

GDaly95

Says he's one of the best posters
Joined
May 1, 2013
Messages
6,356
Location
Wicklow, Ireland
Is this WA as bad for the British economy as many MPs have said? Does anyone on here know the nuances of it?

I too find it strange that the general consensus is that it'll get trounced. Seems to me that it could well pass.