Because you chose to believe your gut feeling rather than what players and Jose's mouth piece Duncan Castles reported.
That they spoke with the manager doesn't mean they were his first choice. When the first choices can't be gotten, Ed moves in for the substandard/cheap choice.
In the history of Jose's career, he's never relied on unproven rookies in his defence to win titles.
Porto(03/04) - Jorge Costa(33), Carvalho(26)
Chelsea(04/05) - Carvalho(27), Gallas(27), *Terry(24). *Terry was an early developer. He won club's player of the year as far back as 2002.
Inter Milan(09/10) - Lucio(31), Walter Samuel(31), Materrazi(36)
Real Madrid(11/12) - Carvalho(34), Pepe(29).
Chelsea2.0(14/15) - Ivanovic(31), Gary Cahill(29), John Terry(34)
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
Man Utd(17/18) - Bailly(23), Lindelof(23)