Martial agent looking for a new club for him

Glorio

Full Member
Joined
Jun 16, 2020
Messages
4,602
Does seem heavier than normal, then again he's been out for 5 months. I do hope with all the support our strikers should be getting with Bruno, Pogba, Sancho all around them, plus having expectant fans in the stands, that he'll up his game. Martial is not known for killer off-the-ball movement a la Cavani, but last season in particular he was incredibly flat footed. He seemed to only recognise he needed to move when the chance had gone. He's definitely better than that.

Here's to hoping he picks up because having an in-form Martial in addition to all the other players we have now will cause all kinds of problems for defences. And thankfully, when Cavani's in full flow we won't be totally dependent on him.
 

roonster09

Hercule Poirot of the scouting world
Scout
Joined
May 10, 2009
Messages
36,758
It's actually not 100% clear who Ole sees as first choice because there hasn't been a long spell when both him and Cavani have been fully fit at the same time.
Yeah, first half Cavani was not fit and second half Martial was injured. I think both will be rotated.
 

Nikelesh Reddy

Full Member
Joined
Sep 10, 2017
Messages
1,912
Won’t happen this summer,certainly not with Marcus being out until October.But if Martial doesn’t really establish himself as an integral part of the team next season,then I can see him being offloaded next summer...
 

Widow

Full Member
Joined
Oct 13, 2020
Messages
7,137
Location
Can't spell Mkhitaryan
:lol: At least should properly check how many mins he played and for how many games he was available.

He played 2422 mins and he was injured for months

CL - He was available for 5 games and he played all 5 games, only game he missed was due to injury (played 95% of the mins he was available for)

Europa league - He stared 2/3 games he was available, other game he came on as a sub. Then missed all other games because of knee injury.

PL - He started 17/23 games he was available. 5 games he came on as a sub. Rest he missed due to suspension and injuries. (He played 71% of the PL mins he was available for)
So you're saying he had plenty of game time and was still unimpressive?

Thanks for clearing that up
 

roonster09

Hercule Poirot of the scouting world
Scout
Joined
May 10, 2009
Messages
36,758
So you're saying he had plenty of game time and was still unimpressive?

Thanks for clearing that up
I doubt you will find anyone who said Martial had a decent season. Everyone knows and said he was poor last season.

So there is nothing to clear up here.
 

VanDeBank

Ma’am
Joined
May 13, 2021
Messages
4,862
I'd say that is a symptom of 6 years of watching Martial and waiting, hoping he would eventually come good. Most posters have realised that will not happen now and we need to move him on.
:nono: You can't use logic to justify selling a flop for 50m. If you want to sell him, you must "hate" him.

Yeah, first half Cavani was not fit and second half Martial was injured. I think both will be rotated.
Cavani deserves being first choice. Martial should earn serious rotation. If he's caught strolling about like he cba when Cavani's rested, make Greenwood 2nd choice CF and play one of our dozen wingers instead.

If Anto has another poor season, no one will take his 13m/y salary next year. Haaland will be our only signing and the crying about DM/GK/RB commences.
 

Hackman2210

New Member
Joined
Jul 16, 2013
Messages
527
Is it all mind games - Martial definately staying does sort of translate into give us more than £50m if you want him. Man Utd have certainly started playing hardball with their assets and so they should, 5 years ago - Linguard would have been shipped out for peanuts Tuanzebe as well. Now we seem to be run properly in terms of outgoings.
 

roonster09

Hercule Poirot of the scouting world
Scout
Joined
May 10, 2009
Messages
36,758
:nono: You can't use logic to justify selling a flop for 50m. If you want to sell him, you must "hate" him.



Cavani deserves being first choice. Martial should earn serious rotation. If he's caught strolling about like he cba when Cavani's rested, make Greenwood 2nd choice CF and play one of our dozen wingers instead.

If Anto has another poor season, no one will take his 13m/y salary next year. Haaland will be our only signing and the crying about DM/GK/RB commences.
Both will get chances and whoever plays well will play regularly.

Martial played most games whenever he was available, think it will be same this season too.
 

VanDeBank

Ma’am
Joined
May 13, 2021
Messages
4,862
Both will get chances and whoever plays well will play regularly.

Martial played most games whenever he was available, think it will be same this season too.
Cavani joined late and became our main man in the 2nd half of the season after Martial failed to deliver. I'd be very disappointed in Ole if they'll start as equals. If by both you mean Martial and Greenwood, that's fair.
 

roonster09

Hercule Poirot of the scouting world
Scout
Joined
May 10, 2009
Messages
36,758
Cavani joined late and became our main man in the 2nd half of the season after Martial failed to deliver. I'd be very disappointed in Ole if they'll start as equals. If by both you mean Martial and Greenwood, that's fair.
Martial played almost all the time when he was available. Both will play enough games anyways, we will play many games and we have good squad to rotate attackers.
 

Redcy

Full Member
Joined
Nov 9, 2014
Messages
2,614
I doubt you will find anyone who said Martial had a decent season. Everyone knows and said he was poor last season.

So there is nothing to clear up here.
So last year in the league he had 1487 minutes as I said, and he scored every 372 minutes. Previously the poster claimed the reason that he was poor was because the managers misplayed him.. and in the one season he has been excellent it was because the manager believed him and played him. What you showed in better stats was that the manager fully trusted and believed in him last year. So from two example years where apparently the manager was good for Martial we have one good year and one crap. Believe in him all you want this year, but the issue isn't the manager believing him in, or making him feel good. Prior to that 2019/20 season his scoring record was closer to last years than his standout season.

It seems to be largely irrelevant anyway, as noone is paying Martial 180k plus 70k bonuses the way he played last year. Will probably be here until the end of his contract, as noone is spending that kind of money on him anyway, so we better hope he has seasons like 19/20
 

roonster09

Hercule Poirot of the scouting world
Scout
Joined
May 10, 2009
Messages
36,758
So last year in the league he had 1487 minutes as I said, and he scored every 372 minutes. Previously the poster claimed the reason that he was poor was because the managers misplayed him.. and in the one season he has been excellent it was because the manager believed him and played him. What you showed in better stats was that the manager fully trusted and believed in him last year. So from two example years where apparently the manager was good for Martial we have one good year and one crap. Believe in him all you want this year, but the issue isn't the manager believing him in, or making him feel good. Prior to that 2019/20 season his scoring record was closer to last years than his standout season.

It seems to be largely irrelevant anyway, as noone is paying Martial 180k plus 70k bonuses the way he played last year. Will probably be here until the end of his contract, as noone is spending that kind of money on him anyway, so we better hope he has seasons like 19/20
I don't know which poster said he played poorly because manager misplayed him or whatever that means, you can quote them and reply to them.
 
Joined
May 4, 2021
Messages
439
Location
Tangier
I don't know which poster said he played poorly because manager misplayed him or whatever that means, you can quote them and reply to them.
It's fascinating isn't it? It's like there are loads of people here who seem determined to deny he has ever played well for us.
So last year in the league he had 1487 minutes as I said, and he scored every 372 minutes. Previously the poster claimed the reason that he was poor was because the managers misplayed him.. and in the one season he has been excellent it was because the manager believed him and played him. What you showed in better stats was that the manager fully trusted and believed in him last year. So from two example years where apparently the manager was good for Martial we have one good year and one crap. Believe in him all you want this year, but the issue isn't the manager believing him in, or making him feel good. Prior to that 2019/20 season his scoring record was closer to last years than his standout season.

It seems to be largely irrelevant anyway, as noone is paying Martial 180k plus 70k bonuses the way he played last year. Will probably be here until the end of his contract, as noone is spending that kind of money on him anyway, so we better hope he has seasons like 19/20
If he has a season like 19/20 we wouldn't have a problem getting rid of him. The question would be 'do we want to sell a 20 goal a season striker?' 'can we replace a 20 goal a season striker?'

It's a really bad idea to sell an asset when it's just performed at its worst for 6 years. If we were trying to sell Lingard at the end of last season we would be optimistic to ask for £5m. Now we're asking for £30m.

It's like you guys who are determined to sell Martial now don't understand what form is, or the basic logistics of selling players.
 
Last edited:

roonster09

Hercule Poirot of the scouting world
Scout
Joined
May 10, 2009
Messages
36,758
It's fascinating isn't it? It's like there are loads of people here who seem determined to deny he has ever played well for us, and who
Yeah I don't get this "we have been waiting for 6 years". Did they not watch 2019-20, 2015-16, 2017-18, 2018-19 seasons?
 

Ayoba

Poster of Noncense.
Joined
Feb 2, 2021
Messages
8,532
He literally had his best season in 19/20. It was a really good season from him, he was Players' Player of the Year.
Sure, and I'm not taking that away from him but do you really think Martial is the forward to propel us to the next level? I'm just sick and tired of waiting for him to be consistent and I've seen enough of him to know hes not the player we all hoped he would become when he joined us.

And on his 19/20 season, he missed a few sitters towards the end of the season and that was enough to shatter his glass like confidence. He missed great chances against Sevilla in the semi
 

JPRouve

can't stop thinking about balls - NOT deflategate
Scout
Joined
Jan 31, 2014
Messages
65,948
Location
France
Sure, and I'm not taking that away from him but do you really think Martial is the forward to propel us to the next level? I'm just sick and tired of waiting for him to be consistent and I've seen enough of him to know hes not the player we all hoped he would become when he joined us.

And on his 19/20 season, he missed a few sitters towards the end of the season and that was enough to shatter his glass like confidence. He missed great chances against Sevilla in the semi
To me there are two things in your post. Is Martial the messiah? No. Is Martial a good squad player for a top team? Yes.

I don't really get why people are always sick and tired of not seeing things that have never been the norm. I wonder what current United fans would have thought about Ole, he never propelled the club to the next level but he was a valuable member of the squad even when he wasn't a starter.
 

Remi's Afro

New Member
Newbie
Joined
Jul 27, 2021
Messages
4
To me there are two things in your post. Is Martial the messiah? No. Is Martial a good squad player for a top team? Yes.

I don't really get why people are always sick and tired of not seeing things that have never been the norm. I wonder what current United fans would have thought about Ole, he never propelled the club to the next level but he was a valuable member of the squad even when he wasn't a starter.
Solksjaer always displayed an exemplary attitude and had fantastic courage and game changing bottle. Two traits Le Sulk needs to learn.
To compare the two is comical tbh.
 

JPRouve

can't stop thinking about balls - NOT deflategate
Scout
Joined
Jan 31, 2014
Messages
65,948
Location
France
Solksjaer always displayed an exemplary attitude and had fantastic courage and game changing bottle. Two traits Le Sulk needs to learn.
To compare the two is comical tbh.
That says a lot...
 

VanDeBank

Ma’am
Joined
May 13, 2021
Messages
4,862
Martial played almost all the time when he was available. Both will play enough games anyways, we will play many games and we have good squad to rotate attackers.
We have Sancho now and a year older Greenwood. Martial won't be first choice on the wing. You're not distinguishing Martial (bottom table) as CF and LW. Edi (top table) became first choice CF after Christmas.

12/29/20HWolves (11.)1:0CF90'
1/1/21HAston Villa (4.)2:1FA ban
1/12/21ABurnley (12.)0:1CF90'
1/17/21ALiverpool (5.)0:0CF29'
1/20/21AFulham (18.)1:2CF190'
1/27/21HSheff Utd (20.)1:2CF24'
1/30/21AArsenal (10.)0:0CF90'
2/2/21HSouthampton (12.)9:0CF145'
2/6/21HEverton (6.)3:3CF190'
2/14/21AWest Brom (19.)1:1CF90'
2/21/21HNewcastle (17.)3:1 Muscle Injury
2/28/21AChelsea (5.)0:0 Muscle Injury
3/3/21ACrystal Palace (12.)0:0CF76'
3/7/21AMan City (1.)0:2 Knock

12/29/20HWolves (11.)1:0CF26'
1/1/21HAston Villa (4.)2:1CF190'
1/12/21ABurnley (12.)0:1LW90'
1/17/21ALiverpool (5.)0:0LW61'
1/20/21AFulham (18.)1:2LW85'
1/27/21HSheff Utd (20.)1:2CF90'
1/30/21AArsenal (10.)0:0LW53'
2/2/21HSouthampton (12.)9:0CF245'
2/6/21HEverton (6.)3:3on the bench
2/14/21AWest Brom (19.)1:1LW66'
2/21/21HNewcastle (17.)3:1CF70'
2/28/21AChelsea (5.)0:0CF11'
3/3/21ACrystal Palace (12.)0:0 Knock
3/7/21AMan City (1.)0:2CF88'
 

AjaxCunian

vexingwijsneus
Joined
Mar 10, 2021
Messages
4,241
Supports
Ajax & United
Martial is also on very big wages, and very often injured.

His 19/20 season was very good, not world class but exactly just right for a Man United first striker. It was something to build on, and take both him and us to the next level. Then somewhere during the EL he started to miss everything and he has never been the same. Same thing for France.
 

roonster09

Hercule Poirot of the scouting world
Scout
Joined
May 10, 2009
Messages
36,758
We have Sancho now and a year older Greenwood. Martial won't be first choice on the wing. You're not distinguishing Martial (bottom table) as CF and LW. Edi (top table) became first choice CF after Christmas.

12/29/20HWolves (11.)1:0CF90'
1/1/21HAston Villa (4.)2:1FA ban
1/12/21ABurnley (12.)0:1CF90'
1/17/21ALiverpool (5.)0:0CF29'
1/20/21AFulham (18.)1:2CF190'
1/27/21HSheff Utd (20.)1:2CF24'
1/30/21AArsenal (10.)0:0CF90'
2/2/21HSouthampton (12.)9:0CF145'
2/6/21HEverton (6.)3:3CF190'
2/14/21AWest Brom (19.)1:1CF90'
2/21/21HNewcastle (17.)3:1Muscle Injury
2/28/21AChelsea (5.)0:0Muscle Injury
3/3/21ACrystal Palace (12.)0:0CF76'
3/7/21AMan City (1.)0:2Knock

12/29/20HWolves (11.)1:0CF26'
1/1/21HAston Villa (4.)2:1CF190'
1/12/21ABurnley (12.)0:1LW90'
1/17/21ALiverpool (5.)0:0LW61'
1/20/21AFulham (18.)1:2LW85'
1/27/21HSheff Utd (20.)1:2CF90'
1/30/21AArsenal (10.)0:0LW53'
2/2/21HSouthampton (12.)9:0CF245'
2/6/21HEverton (6.)3:3on the bench
2/14/21AWest Brom (19.)1:1LW66'
2/21/21HNewcastle (17.)3:1CF70'
2/28/21AChelsea (5.)0:0CF11'
3/3/21ACrystal Palace (12.)0:0Knock
3/7/21AMan City (1.)0:2CF88'
So Martial played ahead of Rashford as a LW in few games. We also have year older Cavani too, lets not forget that and Greenwood is a non entity as a LW. He won't play any game as LW.

If we go with black or white version of what you posted, Martial is a first choice CF, when Cavani plays, he is first choice LW.
 
Joined
May 4, 2021
Messages
439
Location
Tangier
That says a lot...
Some of our fans seem to really dislike our black French players and to spend loads of time making assumptions about their character and ignoring anything they've done well on the pitch in order to justify their belief that the club would be better off just getting rid.

I understand it more with Pogba, that has some basis in fact - even when the venom directed at him is well over the top - but with Martial it just seems like a vendetta.

Just saying...
 

Ayoba

Poster of Noncense.
Joined
Feb 2, 2021
Messages
8,532
To me there are two things in your post. Is Martial the messiah? No. Is Martial a good squad player for a top team? Yes.

I don't really get why people are always sick and tired of not seeing things that have never been the norm. I wonder what current United fans would have thought about Ole, he never propelled the club to the next level but he was a valuable member of the squad even when he wasn't a starter.
Ole as a squad player always delivered, he was a completely different animal mentality wise compared to Martial. I'm fine with martial being a squad player for us, I just don't think he will deliver as he is someone who needs a run of games. Also, are you OK with having a squad player for £250k a week? Surely there's better options out there?
 

Siezard

New Member
Newbie
Joined
Dec 9, 2020
Messages
915
Man Utd set Martial transfer fee, Camavinga's agent 'pushing for deal' and Pogba update
Manchester United boss Ole Gunnar Solskjaer is finalising his plans ahead of the new Premier League season, but there could still be movement in and out of Old Trafford.

From dailystar.co.uk
 

JPRouve

can't stop thinking about balls - NOT deflategate
Scout
Joined
Jan 31, 2014
Messages
65,948
Location
France
Ole as a squad player always delivered, he was a completely different animal mentality wise compared to Martial. I'm fine with martial being a squad player for us, I just don't think he will deliver as he is someone who needs a run of games. Also, are you OK with having a squad player for £250k a week? Surely there's better options out there?
What makes Ole a different animal mentally, Martial has never been given a thing, he has always had to fight for a spot at United and has always welcomed the challenge beating Rashford on more than one occasion under Mourinho. The way people talk about Martial's mentality doesn't match with what has actually happened at United and I assume that none of us know him personally either. So why are people so confident in their seemingly fantasist claims?
 

Marcus

Full Member
Joined
Oct 3, 1999
Messages
6,142
I am not a fan of his. But with Rashford out, there is no harm keeping him. Unless the intention is to sell him to buy another striker. I am all for squad depth.
 

VanDeBank

Ma’am
Joined
May 13, 2021
Messages
4,862
So Martial played ahead of Rashford as a LW in few games. We also have year older Cavani too, lets not forget that and Greenwood is a non entity as a LW. He won't play any game as LW.

If we go with black or white version of what you posted, Martial is a first choice CF, when Cavani plays, he is first choice LW.
Cavani became our first choice CF after Jan 30th (vs Arse). Why do you think he played the full 90min in the league afterwards, with the exception of that 9:0 where he was taken off and rested? I included the games before Arsenal to show how poor Martial was and why Cavani had to step in.

Martial never played "ahead" of Rashford LW. Rash was moved to the right to accommodate Martial. What are you on about with Greenwood LW? You really don't understand Mason could come in on the right and Sancho moves left? (which is his best position) How is Martial gonna be first choice LW this season with Rashford back in Nov?

My point about Greenwood is that is that he'll have another season under his belt. 19y->20y is a big difference. Cavani's back from a good Copa and was fantastic for us after Martial's injury. There's no reason to doubt he won't have at least one more good season in him:


4/4/21Brighton (16.)2:182'
4/11/21Spurs (6.)1:3190'
4/18/21Burnley (16.)3:1145'
4/25/21Leeds (10.)0:05'
5/9/21Aston Villa (9.)1:3125'
5/11/21Leicester (4.)1:224'
5/13/21Liverpool (6.)2:490'
5/18/21Fulham (18.)1:1187'
 

roonster09

Hercule Poirot of the scouting world
Scout
Joined
May 10, 2009
Messages
36,758
Cavani became our first choice CF after Jan 30th (vs Arse). Why do you think he played the full 90min in the league afterwards, with the exception of that 9:0 where he was taken off and rested? I included the games before Arsenal to show how poor Martial was and why Cavani had to step in.

Martial never played "ahead" of Rashford LW. Rash was moved to the right to accommodate Martial. What are you on about with Greenwood LW? You really don't understand Mason could come in on the right and Sancho moves left? (which is his best position) How is Martial gonna be first choice LW this season with Rashford back in Nov?

My point about Greenwood is that is that he'll have another season under his belt. 19y->20y is a big difference. Cavani's back from a good Copa and was fantastic for us after Martial's injury. There's no reason to doubt he won't have at least one more good season in him:


4/4/21Brighton (16.)2:182'
4/11/21Spurs (6.)1:3190'
4/18/21Burnley (16.)3:1145'
4/25/21Leeds (10.)0:05'
5/9/21Aston Villa (9.)1:3125'
5/11/21Leicester (4.)1:224'
5/13/21Liverpool (6.)2:490'
5/18/21Fulham (18.)1:1187'
If Cavani playing as CF makes him first choice then Martial playing as LW makes him first choice too or lets say Ole values to play him. He could have easily played Rashford as LW, Greenwood as RW but he moved Rashford to accomodate Martial. Shows how highly he rates him.

Not sure what those tables mean or meant to say. Also no matter how you try to put it, Cavani is year older which will have impact on his performance considering his age.

You don't have to pull any games to show Martial was poor, no one argued he was even decent. It was a shit season for him all season except very few games.

Only difference is few thinks it's him back to normal and others including me argued it wasn't just a blip and he will be back to his best.
 

TempusFugit

New Member
Newbie
Joined
Oct 16, 2020
Messages
247
According to Simon Peach, Inter were ready to offer 50 million pounds for him. I'm sure quite a few posters wouldn't have hesitated to get rid of him for that price :D
 

VanDeBank

Ma’am
Joined
May 13, 2021
Messages
4,862
Martial is also on very big wages, and very often injured.

His 19/20 season was very good, not world class but exactly just right for a Man United first striker. It was something to build on, and take both him and us to the next level. Then somewhere during the EL he started to miss everything and he has never been the same. Same thing for France.
What same thing for France? 1 goal in 27 apps (1200min).

Some of our fans seem to really dislike our black French players and to spend loads of time making assumptions about their character and ignoring anything they've done well on the pitch in order to justify their belief that the club would be better off just getting rid.

I understand it more with Pogba, that has some basis in fact - even when the venom directed at him is well over the top - but with Martial it just seems like a vendetta.

Just saying...
Just because you're incapable of understanding why someone wouldn't rate Martial/Pogba as much as you do, doesn't mean they're racist. I'm black myself, but don't let that get in the way of enjoying the view from up there.

If Cavani playing as CF makes him first choice then Martial playing as LW makes him first choice too or lets say Ole values to play him. He could have easily played Rashford as LW, Greenwood as RW but he moved Rashford to accomodate Martial. Shows how highly he rates him.

Not sure what those tables mean or meant to say.

You don't have to pull any games to show Martial was poor, no one argued he was even decent. It was a shit season for him all season except very few games.

Only difference is few thinks it's him back to normal and others including me argued it wasn't just a blip and he will be back to his best.
The tables were a response to you saying Cavani and Martial will be rotated equally. Why would that be when Cavani became our main CF after Martial was stinking it up? The tables show that happening.

Yes, Greenwood was dropped early on in the season. But let's not forget Greenwood scored 7 goals in one month at the end of the season. That's Martial's season total. In that form, Greenwood deserves to be ahead of Martial (which could still be 3rd choice when Rashford gets back and Sancho does well)

How do you not get Sancho will be big difference this season? Do you think we spent 85m for a squad player?
If you think Martial will be first choice LW instead of Rashford or Sancho, just say so, so I can stop wasting my time.