Erik ten Hag - Manchester United manager / awaiting clarity from the club over his position

Should ETH be kept on or fired by INEOS


  • Total voters
    2,026
  • This poll will close: .

Licha-Vidic

Last Man Standing 2 finalist 2023/24
Joined
Jan 9, 2023
Messages
1,388
Good article that.

Certainly in terms of stats we're having a peculiar season. Up there in terms of clean sheet but also conceding lots of shots and on the end of a few drubbings. Heavily reliant on one player for goals but with it a brilliant win rate.

Even our goal difference. Would be interesting to know how many teams have finished 3rd with around a +6 goal difference.

These things don't usually go hand in hand.

Liverpool considered to be having a poor season but they've scored more and conceded less than us.

Either way ETH is making it work as well as can be expected in his first year.
Yeah, it all points to unfamiliar set-up or structure. We will break the 44 goals conceded this season yet we seem to play well.

I believe Ten Hag will sort the midfield structure + elite striking acquisition will make us very formidable force.
 

Robbie Boy

Full Member
Joined
Jun 17, 2010
Messages
28,541
Location
Dublin
Are there really people who would rather United fail just to stick up for an old manager? I haven’t seen that. Would be very weird if true, if they are Infact fans of the club.
I mean, I think most people are saying it ironically, as it's the kind of utter bollox that was thrown out to anyone who criticised Ole.
 

Zlatan 7

We've got bush!
Joined
May 26, 2016
Messages
11,971
why?! He was awful.
But this is the thing, he wasn’t always awful! People seem to love hating on him but my memories are that we had a run where it was the first time I’d enjoyed watching us play again, we got a belief back that we could come from behind, record breaking away results, we had some good cup runs, good wins against bigger teams, It fell apart yes but it wasn’t always awful.

I’ve seen posts saying that finally ten Haag has us coming from behind in games since Fergie and that’s just not true, you can hate OGS without having to lie about his time here. And you can also love having ten Haag here without having to hate everything that went on before.
 

Kush

Hyperbolic and will post where they like!!
Joined
Mar 30, 2010
Messages
3,451
Yup, when over half your 'contributions' to this thread were posted after Sunday, it paints a pretty damning picture.
It is very easy to spot the Ole fanboys, they clogged up this forum with their mental gymnastics for over 2 years.

It is simply not worth engaging with them. Ten Hag isn't perfect but he has done an excellent job thus far give the hand he was dealt. Using his low points to claim superior moral ground is just sad.
 

Rusholme Ruffian

Full Member
Joined
Apr 30, 2017
Messages
3,121
Location
Cooking MCs like a pound of bacon
But this is the thing, he wasn’t always awful! People seem to love hating on him but my memories are that we had a run where it was the first time I’d enjoyed watching us play again, we got a belief back that we could come from behind, record breaking away results, we had some good cup runs, good wins against bigger teams, It fell apart yes but it wasn’t always awful.

I’ve seen posts saying that finally ten Haag has us coming from behind in games since Fergie and that’s just not true, you can hate OGS without having to lie about his time here. And you can also love having ten Haag here without having to hate everything that went on before.
Apart from an initial 10 game run where the players obviously felt like a weight had been lifted it was mainly mediocrity. There would be the odd run of games where you (one) tried to convince yourself that things were good, but the tactical decisions never improved, the players never looked any better coached - or fitter - and the rhetoric from Solksjaer was uninspiring and cliched. For everyone bemoaning Sunday's 'worst result ever' they should remind themselves that a few years back Solksjaer took us on our worst run of form since the 1930s - 7 defeats in 10 games - and that wasn't at the end when things were falling apart, that was when he'd been here longer than Ten Hag has. It's weird that some of the same people who have talked about other posters not having 'standards' cos they aren't crying about the Liverpool result didn't seem to worry about standards when we had a manager that everybody in the world could see was not of the standard that United should have had in charge.
 

Zlatan 7

We've got bush!
Joined
May 26, 2016
Messages
11,971
a
Apart from an initial 10 game run where the players obviously felt like a weight had been lifted it was mainly mediocrity. There would be the odd run of games where you (one) tried to convince yourself that things were good, but the tactical decisions never improved, the players never looked any better coached - or fitter - and the rhetoric from Solksjaer was uninspiring and cliched. For everyone bemoaning Sunday's 'worst result ever' they should remind themselves that a few years back Solksjaer took us on our worst run of form since the 1930s - 7 defeats in 10 games - and that wasn't at the end when things were falling apart, that was when he'd been here longer than Ten Hag has. It's weird that some of the same people who have talked about other posters not having 'standards' cos they aren't crying about the Liverpool result didn't seem to worry about standards when we had a manager that everybody in the world could see was not of the standard that United should have had in charge.
You have your memories I have mine, guess that’s football.

the away run, the Europa league run; neither was in the first ten games. We also started coming back from behind when before that I had no faith in us ever turning games around. It wasn’t all bad. Cool to hate the guy I suppose.
 

Rightnr

Wants players fined for winning away.
Joined
Jan 25, 2015
Messages
14,764
You have your memories I have mine, guess that’s football.

the away run, the Europa league run; neither was in the first ten games. We also started coming back from behind when before that I had no faith in us ever turning games around. It wasn’t all bad. Cool to hate the guy I suppose.
I'm so happy we got rid of that fraud, so I don't have to explain for the nth time why these runs are pathetic and suitable for a Spurs supporter to be proud of
 

Rusholme Ruffian

Full Member
Joined
Apr 30, 2017
Messages
3,121
Location
Cooking MCs like a pound of bacon
a

You have your memories I have mine, guess that’s football.

the away run, the Europa league run; neither was in the first ten games. We also started coming back from behind when before that I had no faith in us ever turning games around. It wasn’t all bad. Cool to hate the guy I suppose.
is it 'cool' though? Is it really?!

Didn't the away run come during lockdown, when essentially all the same? And we bottled the Europa. Considering you said yesterday that even if we finish this season 3rd in the league and with 2 cups you would view the season as a disappointment, it's really strange to hear the kinds of things that you do class as good memories!!
 

croadyman

Full Member
Joined
Mar 9, 2018
Messages
35,320
If he can win the Europa league, and finish 3rd aswell as already having the caraboa then that’s a very good season in his first season in England. Beats klopp and guardiola anyway.
Pot 1 for Champions League too,still tough ask with Roma (Jose) Juve and Lego Pep still knocking around in it
 

Zlatan 7

We've got bush!
Joined
May 26, 2016
Messages
11,971
is it 'cool' though? Is it really?!

Didn't the away run come during lockdown, when essentially all the same? And we bottled the Europa. Considering you said yesterday that even if we finish this season 3rd in the league and with 2 cups you would view the season as a disappointment, it's really strange to hear the kinds of things that you do class as good memories!!
Where did I say they were good memories? It’s just my memories of solsjkaers time here, it wasn’t all bad was my point when you said it was awful.

we may not have won the final but we got there, people are loving a Europa league run this year yet there’s a poster above mocking it as a spurs run when talking about the ‘fraud’. That was my point.

I also didn’t say it would be a dissapointment ffs. I said it wouldn’t be looked back on as a great season in years to come just for winning the carling cup and getting top four, you were going off on the hypotheticals, I’m not getting into that again
 

LordSpud

Full Member
Joined
May 22, 2017
Messages
2,553
We just have to iron out the Midfield structure to stop conceding alot of chances, then everything will be perfectly fine.


Please read the article.

He's working miracles at the moment. We have to remember he's barely getting any time on the training ground because of the short time between games. I cant wait to see after the summer when hes got new reinforcements in, more time over the summer to implement new ideas and then not such a mad schedule next season where we can actually keep working on new tactics.
 

Isotope

Ten Years a Cafite
Joined
Mar 6, 2012
Messages
23,772
That's obvious.

He shipped off CR7 who now regularly scores hat-tricks in one of the best leagues in Asia. He didn't do shit to keep positive characters like PogPog and J-Lin who both did wanders for our social media accounts. Instead, he populated squad with questionable, overly aggressive characters like The Butcher, Blondie, Dutch Donkey and that overpaid old sieve discarded by Madrid.

What an insecure looser. Probably cause he's bold and has a stutter.
:drool: This 100% summed up EtH's time here.
 

Zlatan 7

We've got bush!
Joined
May 26, 2016
Messages
11,971
He's working miracles at the moment. We have to remember he's barely getting any time on the training ground because of the short time between games. I cant wait to see after the summer when hes got new reinforcements in, more time over the summer to implement new ideas and then not such a mad schedule next season where we can actually keep working on new tactics.
Defintely! I’m excited to see how the play progresses over time. How we are winning so many games already is amazing but i expect the style of play to get better too with more suitable and better players and time to actually train methods. Certainly seems capable of it.
 

Escobar

Shameless Musketeer
Joined
Jun 8, 2004
Messages
30,310
Location
La-La-Land
If he can win the Europa league, and finish 3rd aswell as already having the caraboa then that’s a very good season in his first season in England. Beats klopp and guardiola anyway.
If you consider where he had to start, it would be a great achievement
 

Gazza

Full Member
Joined
Jul 25, 2000
Messages
32,644
Location
'tis a silly place
It's just really fecking weird. He has 23 posts in here: 12 have come since Sunday, not one to praise ETH when he won the League Cup and some of his posts in here are bigging up Ole's away record. That's a pretty clear agenda, and he's not the only one, others who only became active in here after Sunday, have suddenly disappeared after last night. Not a word of praise from any of them :rolleyes:
:lol: @Tom Cato it looks pretty bad for you here. Credibility shot.
 

pogbasformerbarber

Full Member
Joined
Jul 23, 2022
Messages
450
Very telling quote from ETH on being unsure the fan reaction at OT after the Liverpool game:

"I was curious about that and I was pleased by the response from the crowd to the team," Ten Hag added. "From minute one they were behind the team, the team gave energy by performance and they gave it back. There is a great bond between the team and the fans and we are pleased by that."

I was struck by ETH using the term "we" here...it's a small thing, but not insignificant IMHO. I feel like the difference between ETH and so many other managers (especially some of our post-SAF ones) is that he is an authority figure to the players and demands that respect and position...but he also considers himself PART of the team. He's in it with his players, and the players feel that.

It's a subtle thing, but can often be a huge part of a manger getting through bad periods. Players don't feel a separation between themselves and the manager. There's no scapegoating. Everyone is in it together and good and bad performances are on everyone...not just the players. It can go miles towards long term success and not losing the dressing room.
 

Olecurls99

Full Member
Joined
Jan 6, 2021
Messages
2,168
Very telling quote from ETH on being unsure the fan reaction at OT after the Liverpool game:

"I was curious about that and I was pleased by the response from the crowd to the team," Ten Hag added. "From minute one they were behind the team, the team gave energy by performance and they gave it back. There is a great bond between the team and the fans and we are pleased by that."

I was struck by ETH using the term "we" here...it's a small thing, but not insignificant IMHO. I feel like the difference between ETH and so many other managers (especially some of our post-SAF ones) is that he is an authority figure to the players and demands that respect and position...but he also considers himself PART of the team. He's in it with his players, and the players feel that.

It's a subtle thing, but can often be a huge part of a manger getting through bad periods. Players don't feel a separation between themselves and the manager. There's no scapegoating. Everyone is in it together and good and bad performances are on everyone...not just the players. It can go miles towards long term success and not losing the dressing room.
Very good point
 

The Oracle

Full Member
Joined
Jun 22, 2020
Messages
1,123
Very telling quote from ETH on being unsure the fan reaction at OT after the Liverpool game:

"I was curious about that and I was pleased by the response from the crowd to the team," Ten Hag added. "From minute one they were behind the team, the team gave energy by performance and they gave it back. There is a great bond between the team and the fans and we are pleased by that."

I was struck by ETH using the term "we" here...it's a small thing, but not insignificant IMHO. I feel like the difference between ETH and so many other managers (especially some of our post-SAF ones) is that he is an authority figure to the players and demands that respect and position...but he also considers himself PART of the team. He's in it with his players, and the players feel that.

It's a subtle thing, but can often be a huge part of a manger getting through bad periods. Players don't feel a separation between themselves and the manager. There's no scapegoating. Everyone is in it together and good and bad performances are on everyone...not just the players. It can go miles towards long term success and not losing the dressing room.
It's a great mentality to have. We all have each other's backs. Brilliant.
 

Solius

¯\_(ツ)_/¯
Staff
Joined
Dec 31, 2007
Messages
87,382
Very telling quote from ETH on being unsure the fan reaction at OT after the Liverpool game:

"I was curious about that and I was pleased by the response from the crowd to the team," Ten Hag added. "From minute one they were behind the team, the team gave energy by performance and they gave it back. There is a great bond between the team and the fans and we are pleased by that."

I was struck by ETH using the term "we" here...it's a small thing, but not insignificant IMHO. I feel like the difference between ETH and so many other managers (especially some of our post-SAF ones) is that he is an authority figure to the players and demands that respect and position...but he also considers himself PART of the team. He's in it with his players, and the players feel that.

It's a subtle thing, but can often be a huge part of a manger getting through bad periods. Players don't feel a separation between themselves and the manager. There's no scapegoating. Everyone is in it together and good and bad performances are on everyone...not just the players. It can go miles towards long term success and not losing the dressing room.
Also both times he's won Manager of the Month he's made sure to pose with all his staff. He makes everyone feel included and part of the journey.
 

romufc

Full Member
Joined
Apr 30, 2019
Messages
12,788
It's a great mentality to have. We all have each other's backs. Brilliant.
You can tell how much the fan reaction meant to Ten Hag, he clearly didnt want all the hard work to bond the fans and players to be thrown away with 1 game.

You can see from his programme notes and post match interview, where he said he is grateful for the fans for showing support.

He comes across really genuine.
 
Joined
Jul 31, 2015
Messages
23,038
Location
Somewhere out there
You have your memories I have mine, guess that’s football.

the away run, the Europa league run; neither was in the first ten games. We also started coming back from behind when before that I had no faith in us ever turning games around. It wasn’t all bad. Cool to hate the guy I suppose.
Hang on? Talking about having your own memories :lol:

Did we not come from behind under Mourinho? Did the club not even do an article on it?

Supporting Ole was exactly like being a Spurs fan, an away run here, a cup run there, meh league points totals every season and no silverware.
 
Last edited:
Joined
Jul 31, 2015
Messages
23,038
Location
Somewhere out there
Considering you said yesterday that even if we finish this season 3rd in the league and with 2 cups you would view the season as a disappointment
Feck off @Zlatan 7 you never said that???

You think an away run and a Europa League were good memories yet you’d consider third and 2 cups a “disappointment”?
I’m not having you said that, even Cato wouldn’t be that see through.
 

el3mel

New Member
Joined
Oct 23, 2016
Messages
43,736
Location
Egypt
Ole apologists are just so tiresome. They can't get past the fact their manager failed and just can't move on. I guess they're annoyed they spent 3 years defending this crap passionately and now all this was in vain and they were proven wrong at the end but come on..learn how to move on.
 

Robbie Boy

Full Member
Joined
Jun 17, 2010
Messages
28,541
Location
Dublin
It's a great mentality to have. We all have each other's backs. Brilliant.
It's a fantastic mentality.

Little things he has done, like having all the staff pose together with the League Cup, shows how classy he is. The guy has galvanised the whole club, instilled a winning mentality and helped to heal a very fractured fanbase.
 

Zlatan 7

We've got bush!
Joined
May 26, 2016
Messages
11,971
Feck off @Zlatan 7 you never said that???

You think an away run and a Europa League were good memories yet you’d consider third and 2 cups a “disappointment”?
I’m not having you said that, even Cato wouldn’t be that see through.
Never said that they were good memories, Jesus Christ and I never said anything about a disappointment. Honestly the stuff that gets made up for a jump on is quite funny.
 

Zlatan 7

We've got bush!
Joined
May 26, 2016
Messages
11,971
Hang on? Talking about having your own memories :lol:

Did we not come from behind under Mourinho? Did the club not even do an article on it?

Supporting Ole was exactly like being a Spurs fan, an away run here, a cup run there, meh league points totals every season and no silverware.
Fair enough, we came back under mourinho too. So it isn’t a recent thing.

I just know myself that it was more enjoyable time than anything else post Fergie, and this season is more enjoyable again.
 

No Idea For Nickname

Patroness Saint of the anti-RAWKites
Joined
Jan 1, 2015
Messages
19,809
Location
Split, Croatia
Logged in, was thinking "look at how many pages about Erik and we won yesterday".
Hmm. Must be something wrong.

Started reading, Ole this, Ole that.
Move on, he left, stop being so hurt.

I wonder if you guys talked about Erik in Ole's thread this much when Ole was the manager. Bite you bastards.
 
Joined
Jul 31, 2015
Messages
23,038
Location
Somewhere out there
Never said that they were good memories, Jesus Christ and I never said anything about a disappointment. Honestly the stuff that gets made up for a jump on is quite funny.
fair enough, did seem far fetched.
My fave time watching United since Fergie is by far this season, and before that it’s Mourinho/Pogba/ Zlatan’s first season, by some distance too. We won cups that season, drew so many games we should’ve easily won and felt like we were going somewhere.
The Ole/Phelan honeymoon was great, so much fun, but even that turned into an absolute clusterfeck for the final 10 games or so, a sign of something that was to happen each and every season under them.
Always felt we were running in quick sand with them after that and that every good run would inevitably end with a run of relegation form. The whole thing felt so “Spursy”.
 

Olecurls99

Full Member
Joined
Jan 6, 2021
Messages
2,168
Logged in, was thinking "look at how many pages about Erik and we won yesterday".
Hmm. Must be something wrong.

Started reading, Ole this, Ole that.
Move on, he left, stop being so hurt.

I wonder if you guys talked about Erik in Ole's thread this much when Ole was the manager. Bite you bastards.
:lol: He bit
 

Zlatan 7

We've got bush!
Joined
May 26, 2016
Messages
11,971
q
fair enough, did seem far fetched.
My fave time watching United since Fergie is by far this season, and before that it’s Mourinho/Pogba/ Zlatan’s first season, by some distance too. We won cups that season, drew so many games we should’ve easily won and felt like we were going somewhere.
The Ole/Phelan honeymoon was great, so much fun, but even that turned into an absolute clusterfeck for the final 10 games or so, a sign of something that was to happen each and every season under them.
Always felt we were running in quick sand with them after that and that every good run would inevitably end with a run of relegation form.
That’s a fair and balanced post and agree that season was good, my username came from the Zlatan signing. Maybe the mourinho era left such a sour taste it increased my enjoyment of the ole reign, untill the end obviously.

But we both agree this season has been the best and most enjoyable, it’s nice to like everyone in the team again, Maguire being a bit iffy and even he’s not a bad character, just drives nails into me watching him play.