Some praise for Jose

The red panther

princess transfer emo
Joined
Aug 8, 2015
Messages
2,855
It's finally starting to come together again for us. The results have been annoying but performance wise we're starting to look like a top team again. We've actually handled the likes of Spurs, Arsenal and Everton quite comfortably recently only to get shafted with late goals through errors.

If we can start putting away our chances and Martial finds his best form then i think we'll be feared once again. We've looked solid at the back, created plenty of good chances and we're fighting like mad. We actually don't look like a spineless team of wimps anymore.

Whether we finish in the top 4 or not, if we keep seeing this progress theoughout the season it'd be madness to consider changing the manager again.
We really need to start putting away our chances, in terms of chances created we are amongst the best teams in the PL. in terms of converting them to goals, we are amongst the worst. That has to start changing and soon.
 
Last edited:

Treble

Full Member
Joined
Sep 11, 2008
Messages
10,550
Wheres the 21 in 30 thread now.

We have lost 2 in 20 (iirc) , he has signed 4 players who have dramatically improved us. Are we there yet, no, but only a blind man wouldn't acknowledge the progress.
True that. The games vs Arsenal and Spurs have shown that the team is starting to play well vs the top teams too.
 

Pogue Mahone

The caf's Camus.
Joined
Feb 22, 2006
Messages
133,899
Location
"like a man in silk pyjamas shooting pigeons
Something which Mourinho probably deserves praise for is the whole Rooney thing. He was flagged as massive issue for any new manager to deal with. Yet here we are, not even Christmas and the club and country captain in August has quietly been relegated to a squad player. With hardly any of the drama, squad unrest and general distraction that many predicted. Kudos.
 

SirAF

Ageist
Joined
Sep 28, 2003
Messages
37,619
Location
Something which Mourinho probably deserves praise for is the whole Rooney thing. He was flagged as massive issue for any new manager to deal with. Yet here we are, not even Christmas and the club and country captain in August has quietly been relegated to a squad player. With hardly any of the drama, squad unrest and general distraction that many predicted. Kudos.
Very good point.

I'm sure that it would have been turmoil had Jose dropped him right away, but he basically gave him enough rope to to the deed himself.
 

Wumminator

The Qatar Pounder
Joined
May 8, 2008
Messages
22,950
Location
Obertans #1 fan.
Something which Mourinho probably deserves praise for is the whole Rooney thing. He was flagged as massive issue for any new manager to deal with. Yet here we are, not even Christmas and the club and country captain in August has quietly been relegated to a squad player. With hardly any of the drama, squad unrest and general distraction that many predicted. Kudos.
And with the games he does get hell break the record and retire happy.
 

Stacks

Full Member
Joined
Jul 10, 2015
Messages
10,905
Location
Between a rock and Gibraltar
So he deserves praise for a good performance and a win yet is free of any criticisme for dropping all those points ?

He will get his praise from me if he can start winning game after game, which is what I expect from a team like United with players like Pogba, Mkhitaryan and Zlatan. He has 1 season to get the motor running, not 2, not 3, just 1, like his predecessors and if he fails to get CL football he should get the sack. I don't care how he gets it but a club like United that spends hundreds of millions on the best players must be in the CL. There are no if's and but's, there is only doing it or not doing it. Even a clown like Wenger who doesn't get to spend a penny has managed to get CL football in every season. If he is a specialist in failure like Mourinho claims, then surely it can't be a problem for one of the best managers in the world to get atleast CL football. We aren't asking for him to win the title, let alone the CL (which is were our true aim should be), it is just getting in the CL and he even has 2 paths to do it, so if he is truely the best man for the job, he should manage it.

So far still 6 of top 4, so he got his work cut out for him
sadly this is a reality.
 

dakingpin1999

New Member
Newbie
Joined
Apr 26, 2014
Messages
198
What praise? I will praise him when he gets top 4 and wins 3 trophies. spending all that money and dropping points against dire opposition is not worthy of praise. Jose is 6-9 points off where he should be. He is still the man for utd, world class and I am right behind him but will save the praise
 

GazTheLegend

Full Member
Joined
Jul 22, 2014
Messages
3,646
Very good point.

I'm sure that it would have been turmoil had Jose dropped him right away, but he basically gave him enough rope to to the deed himself.
Agree completely.

By the time Wayne Rooney was dropped, the media, the matchgoing fans, and social media were all seemingly aligned that it was time to look at other options.

Jose played it perfectly. And strangely when Rooney DOES play now (sparingly) it seems like it's ignited the old fire in him, and brought back a bit of the old Wayne Rooney.
 

marjen

Desperately wants to be like Noodle
Joined
Jul 11, 2009
Messages
8,643
Location
At the back post
Indeed. Plus he set the scene as soon as he took charge by killing the "midfield general" stuff before a ball had been kicked.
Yeah, in hindsight he's played a blinder.

I thought the Rooney situation was probably the biggest single issue to tackle when he took charge. He's solved that one excellently.

Add to that, every one of his signings seem to have come off, and we're looking better and better in terms of performances, I'm optimistic.

I think we have a decent chance of recovering 4th spot/winning the EL, which would enable us to go for the title next season (this season it's over).
 

itso 7

New Member
Joined
Jul 10, 2011
Messages
4,840
Location
harare,zimbabwe
Something which Mourinho probably deserves praise for is the whole Rooney thing. He was flagged as massive issue for any new manager to deal with. Yet here we are, not even Christmas and the club and country captain in August has quietly been relegated to a squad player. With hardly any of the drama, squad unrest and general distraction that many predicted. Kudos.
Agree with that, even though I would take him over Martial right now on the left, and the way he dealt with the whole issue shows the importance of "big club" experience because someone like Moyes would have tiptoed around the issue and allowed it to cost him his job. Very good observation.
 

itso 7

New Member
Joined
Jul 10, 2011
Messages
4,840
Location
harare,zimbabwe
So he deserves praise for a good performance and a win yet is free of any criticisme for dropping all those points ?

He will get his praise from me if he can start winning game after game, which is what I expect from a team like United with players like Pogba, Mkhitaryan and Zlatan. He has 1 season to get the motor running, not 2, not 3, just 1, like his predecessors and if he fails to get CL football he should get the sack. I don't care how he gets it but a club like United that spends hundreds of millions on the best players must be in the CL. There are no if's and but's, there is only doing it or not doing it. Even a clown like Wenger who doesn't get to spend a penny has managed to get CL football in every season. If he is a specialist in failure like Mourinho claims, then surely it can't be a problem for one of the best managers in the world to get atleast CL football. We aren't asking for him to win the title, let alone the CL (which is were our true aim should be), it is just getting in the CL and he even has 2 paths to do it, so if he is truely the best man for the job, he should manage it.

So far still 6 of top 4, so he got his work cut out for him
Wenger is reaping the benefits of stability, the same thing you are denying Mourinho and one which Ferguson exploited even when his squad's quality was dire. We can't afford to remain in perpetual rebuilding mode and we have seen enough to conclude that Mourinho knows what he is doing. Right now what the club needs to communicate to the players and the fans is the fact that the manager is here to stay and that those players who don't buy in to his methods face the chop otherwise we will end up with a billion pounds worth of average talent whilst remaining stuck in mid table mediocrity. As things stand the performances have improved, we are seeing guts and fight from the team and the gap between us and the challengers is still manageable so why not let him build? His signings have been top notch but we all acknowledge the fact that there is a lot of work to do before we reach the point where we can be satisfied with our squad, I think we are about three signings away from becoming a top team - a Carrick replacement, a prolific wide forward and possibly a striker (should Martial and Rashford not progress).
 

finneh

Full Member
Joined
Jun 28, 2010
Messages
7,318
Indeed. Plus he set the scene as soon as he took charge by killing the "midfield general" stuff before a ball had been kicked.
Very good point. We heard a few comments early on that were clearly briefed to the press but they seem to have been quickly and effectively shut down. We now seem to have a player who should be useful in the squad role he clearly deserves. Touch wood this will be the end of the non-story until at least the Summer.

On another note we still need to improve our finishing. Pogba, Ibrahimovich and Martial all had good opportunities that were wasted (along with a bit of bad luck with the free kick and a couple of really good saves). That lack of ruthlessness has cost us 12 points already against Burnley, Stoke, Arsenal, Everton, West Ham & Liverpool and will continue to cost us. One of the solutions in my view is to try to fit Mata into the team, he's our best finisher and at a time when we're creating but not converting that's vital. He should get his chance with Mkhitaryan out for the next couple of weeks, but I'd like to see them together.
 

Escobar

Shameless Musketeer
Joined
Jun 8, 2004
Messages
30,206
Location
La-La-Land
I dont know why he wouldnt deserve praise. So many things he improved already but we all know that things will take time, especially after the horrible 3 years
 

K2K

Full Member
Joined
Jun 7, 2015
Messages
18,367
Location
"Can Manchester United score? They always score"
Something which Mourinho probably deserves praise for is the whole Rooney thing. He was flagged as massive issue for any new manager to deal with. Yet here we are, not even Christmas and the club and country captain in August has quietly been relegated to a squad player. With hardly any of the drama, squad unrest and general distraction that many predicted. Kudos.
Credit to Rooney too for not kicking a fuss

I remember reading a passage from Steve Gerrards autobiography about how he had to stop himself from punching Rodgers when he was told he was dropped from the United game. That's a sense of entitlement that some players seem to have.
 

Philadelphian

New Member
Newbie
Joined
Sep 4, 2014
Messages
837
As you see his teams play more often, you get the feeling that he's not really a tactician at all. That all he really does is put the strongest collection of players he possibly can into a team and then try to create some sort of a seige mentality. There's no style or philosophy at all to how we're playing. It all just looks better because we have a few better players in the team.

There's been no semblance of balance whatsoever in attack until Henrik came into the team and started showing his individual qualities, which made others around him start to look better.
 

SomeRandomPerson

Full Member
Joined
Dec 8, 2014
Messages
299
As you see his teams play more often, you get the feeling that he's not really a tactician at all. That all he really does is put the strongest collection of players he possibly can into a team and then try to create some sort of a seige mentality. There's no style or philosophy at all to how we're playing. It all just looks better because we have a few better players in the team.

There's been no semblance of balance whatsoever in attack until Henrik came into the team and started showing his individual qualities, which made others around him start to look better.
I think you're being incredibly unfair here. I know that this isn't necessarily a counter to the point you are making but one thing should be obvious to anyone who has seen us this season: our players (with the obvious exceptions of Martial and Rashford, who both sparkled under LvG) have all improved tremendously under Mourinho. Phil Jones and Marcos Rojo seem completely rejuvenated and the signing of Eric Bailly has proven to be a masterstroke; that's the centre half problem seemingly sorted. Mata, Herrera and Valencia are all having very good seasons, and combined with Pogba (I didn't see enough of Juve last season to know where he is at compared to last season) and with Carrick at the base, we look solid in midfield against most teams. Our attack is also clearly much better than it has been for three years. What is lacking is a bit of ruthlessness, both in terms of taking chances and in terms of seeing games out, we tend to invite pressure late in games recently.

In terms of tactics, I had the same criticism at the start of the season. While Pep came in and you could immediately see his print on the team, we seemed to be showing no coherence or style of play. It also took Mourinho time to identify Pogba's best role and the importance of Michael Carrick. But now you can see the work they put in training. Defensively, the fullbacks tuck in to form a compact back four and the winger tracks back, so that if we give space, it's in the wider areas and not centrally. Going forward, we are definitely a lot more direct in the transition from defence to attack. This is something we still need to work on, but the cup win vs West Ham with Martial and Mkhitaryan bombing on was very reminiscent of Mourinho's Real team with Di Maria, Ozil, Marcelo and Ronaldo. It's taking time- which goes against Mourinho's reputation as a manager for the short term- but we seem to be on the right path. Seems incredible given the amount we've spent, but just a couple of more signings (probably less if Martial can get going, him and Mkhi running at teams is the stuff of dreams) and we're on, the obvious problem of the Carrick replacement needs sorting.

Obviously Julian Weigl seems the obvious option, but I doubt Dortmund will be very willing, certainly not for a reasonable price, not to mention he's still got a long way to go. Another name a friend of mine (who's your typical hipster football know-it-all) has been talking about a lot recently is Monaco's Tiemoue Bakayoko (sp?). He's apparently a very good midfielder, good at shielding thr back four, spreads play from deep quickly etc. Monaco seem to be absolutely tearing it up going forward judging by their results so he must be decent. Any followers of French football know if he's any good? Would he be a worthy signing?
 

JSykes

Full Member
Joined
Aug 24, 2013
Messages
125
Location
Skopje, Macedonia
As you see his teams play more often, you get the feeling that he's not really a tactician at all. That all he really does is put the strongest collection of players he possibly can into a team and then try to create some sort of a seige mentality. There's no style or philosophy at all to how we're playing. It all just looks better because we have a few better players in the team.

There's been no semblance of balance whatsoever in attack until Henrik came into the team and started showing his individual qualities, which made others around him start to look better.
Same logic could have always gone against Alex Ferguson, though I don't necessarily agree with it. It's not a clear cut tactical philosophy but it's not a lack of tactics whatsoever. Del Bosque I think once famously referred to Fergie as a tactical anarchist. I don't think we ever had a clear-cut pure tactical philosophy under him, but it seemed to work just fine. Also, building a match plan around a player's individual qualities is completely fine and we've done that a lot with Ronaldo and Ruud van Nistelrooy. It's pragmatism, it is different from how most top clubs operate, but it has worked for us in the past. And if it makes the boat float, well, I have no problem whatsoever with it.
 

SirAF

Ageist
Joined
Sep 28, 2003
Messages
37,619
Location
As you see his teams play more often, you get the feeling that he's not really a tactician at all. That all he really does is put the strongest collection of players he possibly can into a team and then try to create some sort of a seige mentality. There's no style or philosophy at all to how we're playing. It all just looks better because we have a few better players in the team.

There's been no semblance of balance whatsoever in attack until Henrik came into the team and started showing his individual qualities, which made others around him start to look better.
:lol:
 

ryansgirl

Full Member
Joined
Nov 4, 2001
Messages
2,914
Location
where the sun rises
I'm not a fan of Mourinho but you can't say he is not a tactician. He could never have won what he has in football without that ability.

I still want to see him build a team that embodies the spirit of Manchester United and is not a collection of highly expensive foreign players such as the Chelsea teams he was successful with, and the Manchester City team that won the title, with the accompanying mechanical feel. I do not want this to become the norm at United. Good on him and the lads, however, for squeezing out the Spurs win. It has taken off some of the pressure, and will have helped morale.
 

GazTheLegend

Full Member
Joined
Jul 22, 2014
Messages
3,646
As you see his teams play more often, you get the feeling that he's not really a tactician at all.
While I don't entirely disagree with what you're saying, I distinctly recall Chelsea players talking about how they would go into team briefings and be given comprehensive data on the players they were likely to line up against before any given match, those players strengths and weaknesses and what they were likely to do.

Jose may be considered a "reactive" tactician if there is such a thing and may well be the best in the world at devising ways to beat any opposition - how else could he have beaten that Barcelona side which was the greatest of all time.
 

Philadelphian

New Member
Newbie
Joined
Sep 4, 2014
Messages
837
While I don't entirely disagree with what you're saying, I distinctly recall Chelsea players talking about how they would go into team briefings and be given comprehensive data on the players they were likely to line up against before any given match, those players strengths and weaknesses and what they were likely to do.

Jose may be considered a "reactive" tactician if there is such a thing and may well be the best in the world at devising ways to beat any opposition - how else could he have beaten that Barcelona side which was the greatest of all time.
Yea that makes sense. Tactician was the wrong choice of words in hindsight. He studies, analyzes and reacts accordingly. Just different from the Klopps, Guardiolas, LvG's, etc. - which isn't a bad thing.
 

ThomasEmil

Invisible Herrera Watcher
Joined
Dec 4, 2013
Messages
5,435
Location
Denmark
Guess I'd praise him for coping him with all that's come his way since the beginning. Think about it; the team harmony and training must have been dreadful, adding that to a press leaks, tax cases, enormous expectations and a high amount of pressure to succeed upon his Chelsea experience.
That really takes a lot of character when you accumulate it all and think about it
 

WR10

Correctly predicted France to win World Cup 2018
Joined
Jul 19, 2009
Messages
5,644
Location
Dream
2 losses in 18 and we are throughly out playing 'top teams' - that's something we haven't said in many years. With a little bit of luck in the past few draws and we'd be 2nd/3rd.
 

sammsky1

Pochettino's #1 fan
Joined
Feb 10, 2008
Messages
32,841
Location
London
Bit late for that no?
Not really. Thats stage 2 of the journey.

Just like SAF, first we have to learn how to win again. Once that culture is embedded, we can attempt
fast wing attacking play with young players, some local...

Totally unrealistic to expect both at the same time
 

Mindhunter

Full Member
Joined
Jul 26, 2013
Messages
3,630
As you see his teams play more often, you get the feeling that he's not really a tactician at all. That all he really does is put the strongest collection of players he possibly can into a team and then try to create some sort of a seige mentality. There's no style or philosophy at all to how we're playing. It all just looks better because we have a few better players in the team.

There's been no semblance of balance whatsoever in attack until Henrik came into the team and started showing his individual qualities, which made others around him start to look better.
I don't see how I can take this post seriously. He worries more about the opposition? Hell yes he should. Does he do it too much? Yes, maybe he can tone it down a bit but not to the level of Guardiola who played a high line against Jamie fecking Vardy with suspect defenders.

I have no problem with his style of management as long as we can play attacking football and win trophies. The first part is happening, the second will take time but definitely happen.
 

shamans

Thinks you can get an STD from flirting.
Joined
Oct 25, 2010
Messages
18,226
Location
Constantly at the STD clinic.
Something which Mourinho probably deserves praise for is the whole Rooney thing. He was flagged as massive issue for any new manager to deal with. Yet here we are, not even Christmas and the club and country captain in August has quietly been relegated to a squad player. With hardly any of the drama, squad unrest and general distraction that many predicted. Kudos.
Rooney also has to take some credit for that. He is has been dealing with it quite well so far. Most on here made it sound he would be left "angry and confused".
 

Bobcat

Full Member
Joined
Feb 2, 2014
Messages
6,388
Location
Behind the curtains, leering at the neighbors
I don't see how I can take this post seriously. He worries more about the opposition? Hell yes he should. Does he do it too much? Yes, maybe he can tone it down a bit but not to the level of Guardiola who played a high line against Jamie fecking Vardy with suspect defenders.

I have no problem with his style of management as long as we can play attacking football and win trophies. The first part is happening, the second will take time but definitely happen.
Yeah, i'd rather have a pragmatic manager who may consider the opposition to much, instead of a idealist who gets shafted in big matches because he refuses to diverge from his system
 

El Zoido

Full Member
Joined
Jun 7, 2013
Messages
12,342
Location
UK
As you see his teams play more often, you get the feeling that he's not really a tactician at all. That all he really does is put the strongest collection of players he possibly can into a team and then try to create some sort of a seige mentality. There's no style or philosophy at all to how we're playing. It all just looks better because we have a few better players in the team.

There's been no semblance of balance whatsoever in attack until Henrik came into the team and started showing his individual qualities, which made others around him start to look better.
This post is mental and does a huge disservice to Jose and the management staff. Have a word with yourself.
 

Massive Spanner

Give Mason Mount a chance!
Joined
Jul 2, 2014
Messages
28,151
Location
Tool shed
As you see his teams play more often, you get the feeling that he's not really a tactician at all. That all he really does is put the strongest collection of players he possibly can into a team and then try to create some sort of a seige mentality. There's no style or philosophy at all to how we're playing. It all just looks better because we have a few better players in the team.

There's been no semblance of balance whatsoever in attack until Henrik came into the team and started showing his individual qualities, which made others around him start to look better.
So far in this thread I've been very much "Come on, it's one/two games, let's hold off until we actually string a run of results together" - I still think that's the case, however, that post is absurd. The idea that we don't look like far more of a team, that's we're not a better footballing side, and that we're not improving under him, is dreadful.

People must have a seriously short memory because watching us play now is like your balls being tickled by feathers compared to under LvG which was like them being ground down by sandpaper. We are far from perfect yet, no doubt, and it's still unbelievably frustrating at times, but it's frustrating because we're not getting the results despite playing well (Everton aside). Under LvG we weren't getting the results and we were ball-achingly awful and boring to watch.
 

Rozay

Master of Hindsight
Joined
Oct 22, 2012
Messages
27,164
Location
...
I'm probably repeating myself, but I am absolutely overjoyed with Mourinho so far. I think we are completely transformed, and for me, it is still very clear that he has been the best manager in the PL since Sir Alex.

He has shown everything I want, he's been progressive in his style of play, he has been brave and bold where necessary, he has made excellent signings, and he has gotten a bit extra from players who are not particularly good. In my honest opinion, we are maybe the third best team in the PL at the moment, behind Chelsea and Arsenal. We have been very unlucky with recent results, but the manager has gotten it nearly all right. We have bossed games and created chances against both the likes of Burnley and the likes of Arsenal.

He has handled Rooney brilliantly. All other managers since Fergie have bottled it, but Rooney showed during the early assessment stages that he is not one of his men to lead the team, and has been dropped. Not only that, but he hasn't cowardly restored him to the team following some draws, or even a Rooney goal here and there, which is more impressive. He has still stuck to his decision, and it is probably much harder to exclude Rooney when every journo is asking if he'll be 'back in the team following his goal last week'.

He also hasn't been too sentimental with Luke Shaw. He hasn't just kept him out there every game because he feels sorry for him as he's been injured. He gave him a few games uncontested, but his performances have clearly dropped, and he has been taken out of the side like any other. He'll be back of course, but I do like the calls he's made. Even maintaining Jones and Rojo since Bailley's return. Also the right thing to do, and gives players confidence.

Injuries permitting, I can see good things ahead for us. At the very least, we look unlikely to wilt and die, and win, lose or draw, I back us to give anyone a good game at least. After recent years, it is very reassuring to know that not any old team will come to Old Trafford and play us off the park.
 

Janson

Full Member
Joined
Oct 29, 2016
Messages
6,028
Location
Sweden
Has done a good job so far imo. Handled the Rooney situation brilliantly and it looks like it was positive for Mikhi not to be thrown in if he wasn't ready. It has taken long to find his first eleven but now it's pretty much nailed on. Only remaining question mark is LW and wether Bailly should be incorporated in the team in some capacity.

Tactically, I don't see what he could have done differently. Sitting back against top teams is the most effective way to play imo. Nobody would be complaining about it if we would have been better on the counter. People want Rashford as striker when playing this way but they need to realise we need Zlatan to hold the ball when we get it back to be able to deploy our pacey wingers.

433 is obviously the way to go in order to get the best out of this team, allthough it doesn't suit Mata. It looks like there is still use for him in Mourinhos plans though. He is more useful against teams where we expect to dominate possession anyway and he doesn't offer much defensively.

It will be great for our confidence if we can string a few wins together now that we have easier fixtures coming up. I'm only worried about if our starting eleven will survive this period without burning out, as it doesn't look loke Mourinho plans on rotating.
 
Last edited:

Raees

Pythagoras in Boots
Joined
May 16, 2009
Messages
29,469
If Jose isn't a tactician.. especially at his peak, I don't know who is.

He's the only top manager in the EPL who changes his tactics each game depending on who he plays.

Conte has it in his locker to do it but again likes to dominate and keeps a certain philosophy.

Doesn't mean Jose is better than anyone else, but he is certainly more tactical than anyone else.

Klopp, Pep, Wenger.. they're more philosophers than tacticians. They have a certain vision for how they want the game to be played and stick to it. In terms of tactics, I'd say Pep and Wenger especially are quite naive. Pep is great at producing tactics which allow him to dominate any given game, but when he is outmaneuvered.. he tends to run out of ideas and will not deviate from his masterplan to get a result - for me not the sign of a master tactician at this moment in time.
 

devilish

Juventus fan who used to support United
Joined
Sep 5, 2002
Messages
61,681
I am impressed by Mou so far. Instead of reinventing the wheel, he brought 4 top quality players that strengthened the team's spine. I never thought we'd win the league. Moyes/LVG (especially the latter) left a mess which was too big to sort in few months. Maybe a younger Ibra could have papered the cracks (which I think that was Mou's plan all along) but that was a long haul from day 1.

What worries me is the club's attitude.

a- we haven't learnt from our mistakes just yet and any United manager is still free to dump his mates on our club's payroll without any form of accountancy whatsoever. The power vacuum between the football side and the financial side need to be sorted by us bringing in a top quality DOF.

b- Will Mourinho be sacked if he doesn't make it to top 4?
 

Stacks

Full Member
Joined
Jul 10, 2015
Messages
10,905
Location
Between a rock and Gibraltar
Indeed. Plus he set the scene as soon as he took charge by killing the "midfield general" stuff before a ball had been kicked.
I sure did enjoy that. Rooneys sense of entitlement was getting out of hand. We have Pogba, Herrera is showing he can put in midfield performances Rooney could only dream of, whilst Carrick has a better midfield skill set. I remember Herrera couldn't get games as Rooney had to play AMC or CM. Jose exposed Rooney for his shiteness. played it perfectly. I respect Rooney has put in better performances recently but he got too complacent.
 

Adebesi

Full Member
Joined
Dec 6, 2006
Messages
19,159
Location
Sanctity, like a cat, abhors filth.
I am impressed by Mou so far. Instead of reinventing the wheel, he brought 4 top quality players that strengthened the team's spine. I never thought we'd win the league. Moyes/LVG (especially the latter) left a mess which was too big to sort in few months. Maybe a younger Ibra could have papered the cracks (which I think that was Mou's plan all along) but that was a long haul from day 1.

What worries me is the club's attitude.

a- we haven't learnt from our mistakes just yet and any United manager is still free to dump his mates on our club's payroll without any form of accountancy whatsoever. The power vacuum between the football side and the financial side need to be sorted by us bringing in a top quality DOF.

b- Will Mourinho be sacked if he doesn't make it to top 4?
You cant really say that about a) without knowing what goes on in the private meetings between Woodward and Mourinho. Yes he has been allowed to bring his own people in, but neither you or I know about the accountability. We have discussed the DOF and the triad or whatever it is called before, and I agree something like that could be beneficial and is worth looking at and discussing (though as i have said before I think finding the right people is another problem and I dont think Ive heard any really compelling answers on that so far) but that doesnt mean its the only way to go. A DOF isnt the only way of providing accountability.

There are obviously pros and cons to every arrangement and letting Mourinho bring in the people he wanted should create the best environment for him to thrive while he is here. In a sense we might be trading the orderly transition we would hope to get if we brought in a DOF, for a more harmonious working environment for Mourinho while he is here that we have by not having a DOF - which can also be seen as the annoying guy looking over his shoulder and potentially trying to force players on him that he doesnt want. Obviously it doesnt have to be like that and if it works it can presumably be harmonious and advantageous for all parties, sharing out the workload and allowing people to focus on what they are good at. But it also seems to be a recipe for creating needless conflict and politicking within the club by creating rival power factions. This comes back to the point about getting the right people in, and it is not a debate that can ever be settled on a messageboard as we would never know how, for example, Giggs and/or SAF would work in those kinds of roles, alongside Mourinho, unless we actually got them in and saw what happened.

I agree b) is the million dollar question and there is a good chance we will see in due course, though I am still hopeful we can do it, it is too early to conclude all the clubs above us will rack up more points than us from here on in. There is plenty left for everyone to play for. I personally hope and believe we will stick with Mourinho even if we miss out. I am all for accountability, but I think we risk becoming too trigger happy with our managers, expecting too much from them too quickly, and assuming spending £100m+ in a summer automatically gives you the right to a top 4 place, regardless of what came before. Obviously we need to see a return on that investment, and all the investment we have made in the last 3 years, but these things dont happen overnight.

I agree with everything else you say. I am also impressed by Mourinho, I like the way he has us playing, I like the signings he made and how they are settling. I think we just need to be patient now.
 

Stacks

Full Member
Joined
Jul 10, 2015
Messages
10,905
Location
Between a rock and Gibraltar
I am impressed by Mou so far. Instead of reinventing the wheel, he brought 4 top quality players that strengthened the team's spine. I never thought we'd win the league. Moyes/LVG (especially the latter) left a mess which was too big to sort in few months. Maybe a younger Ibra could have papered the cracks (which I think that was Mou's plan all along) but that was a long haul from day 1.

What worries me is the club's attitude.

a- we haven't learnt from our mistakes just yet and any United manager is still free to dump his mates on our club's payroll without any form of accountancy whatsoever. The power vacuum between the football side and the financial side need to be sorted by us bringing in a top quality DOF.

b- Will Mourinho be sacked if he doesn't make it to top 4?
If we had taken our chances in games we should win all day long (4 home draws in succession is a joke) we would very much be in the title race. It isn't like we are chasing Real Madrid. We threw points away so we are where we are. Costa has been the difference maker for Chelsea winning them points.