I think there's a huge grey area around Potter at Chelsea. They have spent a further £250m since he got sacked and hired a recognised good coach, and yet they still struggle. Chelsea are a team of young, inexperienced players that were literally thrown together by a guy that doesn't know football. Given everything that went on at Chelsea, including the forced take over by the UK government, I think it's to simplistic to deduce from all of that, that the manager 'collapsed under the weight'.
I think that job is the biggest poisoned chalice right now.
I’ve felt the United job has been a poisoned chalice for very similar reasons.
Many people say the glazers running of United plays little to no role in uniteds results/performances. An owner putting the wrong people in charge of running the club can be just as disruptive as an owner who acts like a clown.
Potter would have done no better with us. We spend less then chelsea did when he managed them and had a decade of our own circus clown owners. Like making Woodward the CEO because he made the glazers rich, nothing to do with his competency in the role.
Some fans can only see “glazers have undermined our managers/squads” as something like “therefore our managers did not fail”. I think it’s because they can only focus on the manager position.
United owners have been sh*t. Like Boehly, who threw more money than the glazers at it, spending money doesn’t mean you are properly supporting a manager or getting the squad what it needs.
INEOs will hopefully correct that , but if you excuse Potter for Chelsea’s dysfunction, then people can’t really have a higher bar for ETH that had more issues to handle. Potter had to handle ridiculous amount of spending, not all managers would hate that. ETH has had players dramas , injury issues and the club future all on top of the club dysfunction.
I’m gonna caveat it by saying , I’m not saying that ETH gets a pass. I’m saying if you give Potter a pass, you need to apply the same understanding to ETH.
Potter and Southgate are not clear upgrades. I won’t get into the rabbit hole debates some of the less objective posters try to drag me into.