40s Retro Football Fantasy Draft | Finished

Gol123

Mouthfull (of) Member
Joined
Jun 23, 2015
Messages
5,117
Supports
Chelsea
:lol:



Already sent most of my stuff yesterday, will finish it in a few hours and then we can start whenever you and Pat are fine with it.



Yes, he is considered as their greatest playmaker ever and also as one of their best players of all time. In fact even @Balu had him in his all time Geman XI. Netzer was the star of the Gladbach side which is considered one of the greatest German club sides ever and a side that went toe to toe with Beckenbauer, Maier, Breitner & Müller's Bayern, winning two Bundesliga titles. He was also the best player in the Germany 1972 side (considered to be Germany's greatest side ever, even when taking the '74 WC winning team into consideration) and was the standout player of the Euro 1972. Unfortunately he doesn't get the credit he deserves as he was just rather a wee bit unlucky in the WCs and European Cups.

He was injured for the 1970 WC and he left Gladbach after falling out with manager Weisweiler in 1973. He didn't have a great debut season at Real (who quite frankly put, used him wrongly) and he also pissed off Schon, the German manager, since Schon had said every player must be playing in Bundesliga to start in the 1974 WC team. He also directly didn't inform Schon of the decision to move to Real and this angered him even further apparently. Schon also preferred the more industrious Overath but if circumstances had been good for Netzer (no injuries or falling out with Gladbach manager and had stayed with Gladbach), I honestly think Netzer would have started the 1974 WC after that blistering 1972 Euros that he had. It's fair to say that the team would have probably performed better with him in it but squabbles over bonuses pay-out, tough training camps etc played their part in Germany's initial poor performances too.

In the European Cup, he gave plenty of brilliant displays, tearing apart Facchetti's Inter Milan and playing a blinder against Beckenbauer's Bayern for Real in the 1975 semi-final, 2nd leg. However, the first match unfortunately scrapped due to a can being thrown onto the pitch and in the second instance Müller's deadliness just gave Bayern the win out of nowhere (it was a fairly even match which was decided by Müller in brutal fashion). Also played a blinder in the UEFA Cup final 1973 but they just lost out to Liverpool after a tactical blunder by the manager in the first leg. All in all, he genuinely showed his pedigree on the biggest stages but just was a bit unlucky not to win an European Cup or to be part of the 1974 WC winning team.

Anyway judge him for yourself and if possible try to watch the video above or better yet, full games of him playing for Germany 1972. It was nothing short of sensational. Always thought Balu was exaggerating a bit when he said that team was one of the most entertaining and free flowing sides in history but he really was spot on with that. It's a crying shame that there isn't much available of Netzer's Gladbach though, who by all accounts were even more stunning to watch.



:lol:
Wow. Thanks for that info. I had never really heard much about him as a great until this draft. Then coming on here and reading how he was better then Beckenbauer in 72 really caught my attention.
 

Balu

Der Fußballgott
Joined
Dec 2, 2010
Messages
15,102
Location
Munich
Supports
Bayern Munich
Anyway judge him for yourself and if possible try to watch the video above or better yet, full games of him playing for Germany 1972. It was nothing short of sensational. Always thought Balu was exaggerating a bit when he said that team was one of the most entertaining and free flowing sides in history but he really was spot on with that. It's a crying shame that there isn't much available of Netzer's Gladbach though, who by all accounts were even more stunning to watch.
Why would you think that? I very rarely do that :(.
 
Reinforcement Details

Moby

Dick
Joined
May 20, 2011
Messages
51,356
Location
Barcelona, Catalunya
Completed Games
Aldo 7-7 mazhar13 (Aldo wins on penalties)
Tuppet 15-4 Gol123
Gio/Theon 10-7 ctp
Balu 8-10 Invictus
harms 7-1 RedTiger
Joga Bonito 8-8 Skizzo/Pat_Mustard (Joga wins on penalties)
Chesterlestreet 10-3 crappycraperson
NM/EAP 11-3 Marty1968

Current Reinforcement Pool
RedTiger
1. Beckenbauer 2. Oblak 3. Maier 4. Fischer 5. McNeill 6. Dobiaš 7. Tony Dunne 8. Sparwasser 9. Mifflin 10. McFarland 11. van der Kuijlen 12. Caju

Gol123 1. Van Hanegem 2. Overath 3. Johnstone 4. Hulshoff 5. Kindvall 6. Rubén Marcos 7. Matosas 8. Skoblar 9. Pavoni 10. Ubiña 11. Tomaszewski 12. Nordqvist

Balu 1. G. Müller 2. Vogts 3. Rensenbrink 4. Dobrin 5. Benetti 6. Cuccureddu 7. Holcer 8. Jennings 9. Dinu 10. Magnusson 11. Frosio 12. Cullmans

ctp 1. Rivelino 2. Marzolini 3. Jansen 4. Heynckes 5. Höttges 6. Mészöly 7. Fichtel 8. Más 9. Iribar 10. Libuda 11. Velázquez 12. Toshack

mazhar13 1. Jairzinho 2. Zoff 3. B Dietz 4. Giles 5. Buchan 6. Simões 7. Hurst 8. Hunter 9. Lodetti 10. Hansen 11. Jensen 12. Quine

Skizzo/Pat_Mustard 1. Cruyff 2. Keizer 3. Olsen 4. Gemmell 5. Murdoch 6. Jardine 7. Rexach 8. Hellström 9. Flohe 10. Kolotov 11. Morini 12. Acimovic

Marty1968 1. Gerson 2. Carlos Alberto 3. Rosato 4. Schwarzenbeck 5. Cubilla 6. Grabowski 7. Everaldo 8. Panenka 9. Croy 10. Capello 11. Geels 12. Coutinho

crappycraperson 1. Moore 2. Tostão 3. Bene 4. Van Moer 5. Khurtsilava 6. Bell 7. Urbanczyk 8. Shilton 9. Domenghini 10. Asensi 11. Carrascosa 12. Bertini

All players unpicked in the initial draft are also available for reinforcements.

Current Reinforcement Drafting Order
Joga Bonito
Tuppet
harms
NM/EAP
Gio/Theon
Invictus
Chesterlestreet
Aldo
 
Last edited:

Joga Bonito

The Art of Football
Joined
Jul 14, 2014
Messages
8,243
Why would you think that? I very rarely do that :(.
I recall you saying they are amongst the top 5 most exciting International teams of all time (or something along those lines) which I thought might have been a bit of an exaggeration at that time. I thought they would have been exciting to a certain extent and total football-esque but I honestly wasn't expecting such fluidity and ability on the ball. Watching Beckenbauer & Netzer take the piss out of the opposition was hilarious to watch and the opposition just didn't know what to do with them :lol:. That one-touch footie at 24.06 in the video I uploaded was just :drool:.
 
Last edited:

Mani

Full Member
Joined
Jan 21, 2010
Messages
7,663
Cheers.



Most certainly with the younger, direct and dynamic Schuster. Not so much with the later more dictating Schuster. Ideally you'd want powerful, direct and all-round midfielders alongside Netzer (Neeskens, Tardelli, Breitner etc), more so than the sophisticated ones such as Giresse, Iniesta etc and a Rijkaard rather than a Makelele behind him.

You can see how he encourages the players around him to be direct and always sets up on great 1v1 situations against isolated opposition players. The more vertical, dynamic and direct the players around him the better. Ironically enough I could see him working well with the likes of van Hanegem and Coluna but somehow his time with Overath will obviously leave question marks. He never quite got on with Overath on the field as he did with Beckenbauer for some reason. Probably because Schon tried him in a midfield duo in a 4-2-4 alongside Overath which was never going to work.
Cheers.I get that.Its better to add player who is work alcoholic and in that category Neeseken,Breitner and Tardelli would great.
 

Chesterlestreet

Man of the crowd
Joined
Oct 19, 2012
Messages
19,534
Sneak peek of @Chesterlestreet write-up


I'm bored :annoyed:
Don't hate the Viagra, man.

That said, with people quoting Bataille (not much of a philosopher in a draft context - a shabby provocateur more than anything, certainly not final worthy), I plan on basing my thesis on Kant. Should've been Hume, arguably, given my Bremnerism - but Hume is just too much of a bloody idiot for my purposes. A charlatan, as Coleridge rightly said.

Also, Pelé is the best player in the draft. He really is. Actually. So feck you.
 

mazhar13

Kermit Inc. 2022
Scout
Joined
Sep 10, 2013
Messages
36,884
Location
Toronto, ON, Canada
It's quite tough for me to vote in most of these matches. Most of the matches have been fairly even so far with very, very few clear winners around. This is quite a good tournament so far.
 

Chesterlestreet

Man of the crowd
Joined
Oct 19, 2012
Messages
19,534
Player profiles:

(Updated as we go along)

Ray Clemence

Five league titles, two FA Cups, three times winner of the European Cup, three times winner of the UEFA Cup, declared the best goal keeper...ever by Total Football magazine. The last part is ridiculous, of course, but it is nevertheless interesting and an indication of how highly many rate Clemence.

Played with Hughes and Smith at Liverpool, winning the '77 EC with both players.


Terry Cooper

Generally regarded as the best left back in England in the late 1960s/early 1970s and an important part of Revie's famous Leeds vintage of that era. An expert at overlapping and inter-playing with his winger, Cooper had an excellent cross on him. Won the league and the FA Cup with Leeds, plus the UEFA Cup twice – and would have won more too if his career hadn't slowed down due to a nasty injury.

Jan Pivarnik

Winner of Euro '76 with Czechoslovakia, Pivarnik was an offensive, aggressive fullback who won the league twice with Slovan Bratislava. Like many of the era, he didn't play outside his domestic league until he was well past his prime. Pivarnik was named Czech footballer of the year in 1974 and two years later he made the team of the tournament in Euro '76, alongside Beckenbauer and Krol.


Emlyn Hughes:


https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Emlyn_Hughes

Tommy Smith:

If Smith isn't named Footballer of the Year, football should be stopped and the men who picked any other player should be sent to the Kremlin.

- Bill Shankly
Tommy Smith was easily the hardest player I faced. I ran into him once and he knocked every ounce of breath out of me. I tried to get up and look like he hadn't hurt me, but he had.

- Jack Charlton
http://www.lfchistory.net/Players/Player/Profile/413
Note on Hughes and Smith: For me an added benefit of picking this legendary Liverpool pair is their versatility. Both players can be fielded both as centre halves and as fullbacks (and even at a push further up the pitch in some sort of DM role).

Billy Bremner:

There were those who said we would be crushed when we were forced to field a weakened side in our UEFA Cup tie at Hibernian in the autumn of 1973. Billy wanted to make them eat their words, and he did. His performance at Easter Road that night in November was the finest I have ever seen from any individual in all my years in the game. It was a classic exhibition of reading the game, controlling the game of passing, of incredible confidence, Billy, playing in a new role for him of sweeper, was a revelation. Even the furiously partisan Edinburgh crowd had to rise to their feet to cheer this miniature gladiator off the field at the end.

It is one thing in football to have that star quality which makes you stand out from the crowd. It is quite another thing to have star personal quality and leadership qualities so strong you would follow him to the ends of the earth. But that is Billy Bremner. No manager could wish for a greater leader or a greater player. If I was in the trenches at the front line, the man I would want on my right side is Billy Bremner.

- Don Revie

Volodymyr Muntyan

A player who mastered multiple midfield roles (central, attacking, even defensive and wide – or wide-ish at least, in Lobanovsky's version of the 4-4-2) and who was characterized both by his tenacity and his technical proficiency. An allrounder who proved himself as such at the highest level with both the USSR national team and Dynamo Kyiv (both under Maslov and Lovanovsky). He won seven league titles and the Cup Winner's Cup with DK, while also making deep runs in the European Cup proper, including a narrow S-F exit to M'Gladbach in '77 (the year a trio of his team mates here won it for Liverpool).

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Volodymyr_Muntyan#Honours

Mario Corso

Considered one of the finest Italian wingers ever, most famous for his left peg, il piede sinistro de Dio, with which he frequently both shot and passed the ball in the “dead leaf” style perhaps most immediately associated with Didi. Corso, however, had more strings to play on: A fast, technically superb and intelligent player, he was a crucial component in Helenio Herrera's famous (infamous, some would say) Inter side, with which Corso won multiple trophies, two European Cups on the trot (and two successive wins against Independiente in the following Intercontinental Cups) most notably. His career for Italy was less impressive on the face of things, but most would agree that this state of affairs wasn't down to footballing reasons as much as personal differences (and preferences).

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mario_Corso#International


(I won't rely on him for goals primarily, but he was, as one might imagine, a great free kick taker).

Peter Lorimer

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peter_Lorimer

Jimmy Greaves

124 goals in 157 games for Chelsea.

220 goals in 321 games for Spurs.

44 goals in 57 games for England (including a record six hat-tricks).

More goals than any other player in the history of the English top-flight.

But this is my favourite, actually. Greaves' brief spell in Milan was for various reasons a fiasco. He only played a dozen times for AC. But he bloody well managed to score nine goals in that dozen.


(A selection of his goals).

Mike England

Edson...something or other, some Brazilian bloke.
 
Last edited:

NM

Full Member
Joined
May 8, 2011
Messages
12,351
@Aldo @Marty1968

I have my profiles done.. will need till tomorrow morning EST to do my tactics as it is 1 am here. sorry for the delay
 

Chesterlestreet

Man of the crowd
Joined
Oct 19, 2012
Messages
19,534
@Aldo

Stuff sent, just start whenever. I can't promise to be extremely active (and the write-up had to be done in a jiffy here), due to other commitments, but I will try to participate as much as I can.
 

Gio

★★★★★★★★
Joined
Jan 25, 2001
Messages
20,341
Location
Bonnie Scotland
Supports
Rangers
We need to take responsibility to generate interest. There aren't many experts in 1960s and 1970s football not taking part.
 

Chesterlestreet

Man of the crowd
Joined
Oct 19, 2012
Messages
19,534
It's been a sheer piss-take so far - and I'll gladly take some of the blame, but I've been working pretty much constantly, and I can't sit down and engage in fantasy football into the night now (a man has to eat and sleep).

So, there it is - bloody shame, but sometimes the timing just can't be helped. Hopefully there will be some discussion tomorrow (poll doesn't close until four-ish or so in the afternoon, I think.
 

Skizzo

Full Member
Joined
Jan 27, 2013
Messages
12,537
Location
West Coast is the Best Coast
Sometimes you have to just spam and post yourself. Obviously if you don't have time, then there's not much you can do.

I spent periods of time posting to myself in the match thread, then tagged 15 or so people to try and have them pop in and drum up some discussion. All for nought in the end, mind :mad:

Then again, we did have twice as many pages as the next closest match.
 

harms

Shining Star of Paektu Mountain
Staff
Joined
Apr 8, 2014
Messages
28,038
Location
Moscow
I just missed the game, I thought that it wasn't up yet :D
 

Moby

Dick
Joined
May 20, 2011
Messages
51,356
Location
Barcelona, Catalunya
Updated the reinforcements details with the finalised order and pool.

@Tuppet can now proceed with the first pick.

Standard rules - 8 hours for a pick. 2 rounds of drafting.
 

Chesterlestreet

Man of the crowd
Joined
Oct 19, 2012
Messages
19,534
I've but a vague idea who's actually through here:

Aldo
Chester
Invictus
Joga
Tuppet
EAP/NM

...and the last three?
 

Joga Bonito

The Art of Football
Joined
Jul 14, 2014
Messages
8,243





Here's a remarkable stat about Der Kaiser. In a 10 year period from 1966-1976, the beginning of Beckenbauer's career in the Bundesliga till he went to America, Der Kaiser never finished outside the top 5 of the ballon d'Or, bar once in 1969 when he finished a dismal 7th. He won it twice, finished runners up twice, came third once, fourth four times and fifth once.
 

Joga Bonito

The Art of Football
Joined
Jul 14, 2014
Messages
8,243
Aldo 1. Best 2. Chumpitaz 3. Pirri 4. Israel 5. Ademir da Guia 6. Boninsegna 7. Furino 8. Prati 9. Stepney 10. Lawler 11. F. Cruz 12. Sala
Chesterlestreet 1. Pelé 2. Greaves 3. Bremner 4. Corso 5. E. Hughes 6. Lorimer 7. Muntyan 8. Smith 9. Cooper 10. Pivarnik 11. Clemence 12. England
Invictus 1. Eusébio 2. Mazzola 3. Haan 4. Suurbier 5. Perfumo 6. Weber 7. Bonev 8. Bransch 9. Carpegiani 10. Viktor 11. Rildo 12. Fazekas
Gio/Theon 1. Figueroa 2. Cubillas 3. Deyna 4. Clodoaldo 5. Bulgarelli 6. Rocha 7. Ancheta 8. Mazurkiewicz 9. Asparuhov 10. Shalamanov 11. Anczok 12. Meroni
NM/EAP 1. Facchetti 2. Riva 3. Jair 4. Stiles 5. Luis Pereira 6. Martin Peters 7. Bosquier 8. Yakimov 9. De Sisti 10. Anquilletti 11. Rudakov 12. Valdes
harms 1. Krol 2. Florian Albert 3. Van Himst 4. Roth 5. Blankenburg 6. Lennox 7. Dzodzuashvili 8. G. Mühren 9. Bedin 10. Kaplychnyi 11. van Beveren 12. Penev
Tuppet 1. Rivera 2. Džajić 3. Shesternyov 4. Causio 5. Lubański 6. Piazza 7. Bo Larsson 8. Lovchev 9. Fazlagic 10. Julio Meléndez Calderón 11. Leao 12. Sotil
Joga Bonito 1. Law 2. Netzer 3. A.Ball 4. Wimmer 5. Gadocha 6. Greig 7. Byshovets 8. Sieloff 9. Reaney 10. Kapellmann 11. Nigbur 12. Madeley

@Aldo Could you also post this under the reinforcement details post, so that it's easier to track the current teams.
 

Balu

Der Fußballgott
Joined
Dec 2, 2010
Messages
15,102
Location
Munich
Supports
Bayern Munich
Why start a new list for the reinforcements instead of just continuing the orginal one with 13. and 14. like we always did?
 

Tuppet

New Member
Joined
Feb 9, 2014
Messages
3,622
Location
West Coast
Aldo 1. Best 2. Chumpitaz 3. Pirri 4. Israel 5. Ademir da Guia 6. Boninsegna 7. Furino 8. Prati 9. Stepney 10. Lawler 11. F. Cruz 12. Sala
Chesterlestreet 1. Pelé 2. Greaves 3. Bremner 4. Corso 5. E. Hughes 6. Lorimer 7. Muntyan 8. Smith 9. Cooper 10. Pivarnik 11. Clemence 12. England
Invictus 1. Eusébio 2. Mazzola 3. Haan 4. Suurbier 5. Perfumo 6. Weber 7. Bonev 8. Bransch 9. Carpegiani 10. Viktor 11. Rildo 12. Fazekas
Gio/Theon 1. Figueroa 2. Cubillas 3. Deyna 4. Clodoaldo 5. Bulgarelli 6. Rocha 7. Ancheta 8. Mazurkiewicz 9. Asparuhov 10. Shalamanov 11. Anczok 12. Meroni
NM/EAP 1. Facchetti 2. Riva 3. Jair 4. Stiles 5. Luis Pereira 6. Martin Peters 7. Bosquier 8. Yakimov 9. De Sisti 10. Anquilletti 11. Rudakov 12. Valdes
harms 1. Krol 2. Florian Albert 3. Van Himst 4. Roth 5. Blankenburg 6. Lennox 7. Dzodzuashvili 8. G. Mühren 9. Bedin 10. Kaplychnyi 11. van Beveren 12. Penev
Tuppet 1. Rivera 2. Džajić 3. Shesternyov 4. Causio 5. Lubański 6. Piazza 7. Bo Larsson 8. Lovchev 9. Fazlagic 10. Julio Meléndez Calderón 11. Leao 12. Sotil 13. Muller 14.
Joga Bonito 1. Law 2. Netzer 3. A.Ball 4. Wimmer 5. Gadocha 6. Greig 7. Byshovets 8. Sieloff 9. Reaney 10. Kapellmann 11. Nigbur 12. Madeley 13. Beckenbauer 14.

@harms
 

harms

Shining Star of Paektu Mountain
Staff
Joined
Apr 8, 2014
Messages
28,038
Location
Moscow


Joga Bonito 1. Beckenbauer
Tuppet 1. Muller
harms 1.
NM/EAP 1.
Gio/Theon 1.
Invictus 1.
Chesterlestreet 1.
Aldo 1.

@harms
I love you! And he is the perfect pick for you, no doubt, much better than Cruyff with Rivera here