Redcafe has reached peak stupidity with this argument between WHU's season and ours.
In terms of my post about it, I was trying to answer it from each clubs perspective rather than a 'which would you prefer United to achieve' perspective.
I still went with United having the better season either way. As expectations weren't high, so a top 4 finish and a domestic trophy win was great. And, obviously, that would always be much better
for us than finishing 14th but winning the Conference League.
But I was trying to also look at it from the point of view of a team who rarely ever win trophies - is winning a European trophy, but poor league season, more memorable
for them than a big club getting top 4 and winning a domestic cup?
I still went with us having the 'better' season, but definitely think West Ham have, by the end, had the more 'memorable' season for their clubs standards - in that, they'll live off their cup win longer than ours as it was so long since their last one and should be a hell of a lot longer before their next one compared to ours.
But, yeah, going back to looking at it solely from a United perspective then I wouldn't swap our season for any other PL club other than City, obviously. 3rd place, a trophy and another domestic final was better than anything any other PL team achieved (again, other than that lot).