He may well be.And people think Greenwood's the better player.
People are surprised he didn't come to United yet many treat their club and everything about it like shit and like suddenly we are total crap.
Erling Haaland | Dortmund player
- Thread starter Samid
- Start date
People are surprised he didn't come to United yet many treat their club and everything about it like shit and like suddenly we are total crap.
Yeah he'll get some Cardiff type player, amIrite?
In all seriousness, Greenwood would have made an absolute mockery of those defenders given the same space.And people think Greenwood's the better player.
If you were scouting him for the first time you'd report back that the signs were very positive but you'd need to seem him play a game against an actual defence before you could give any sort of opinion.
Exactly. It's as if shitting on United makes them feel better.
I think that he will probably get the sack. The club will need a scapegoat at the end of the season and that won't be the guy who forced the manager to face the season with no midfield and RW.
Then the new manager will come in and he will be properly 'supported' but of course the year after as he will need to assess the squad first. Don't worry though Woodward will renew contracts to the likes of mata and lingard
Greenwood is a pretty good talent, no point down rating him while talking about Haaland. It's Greenwood's first season with the first team, not playing regularly and actually has pretty good numbers despite the team being a hot mess.
That only sparks the hype. But let's all calm down. Nobody questions his talent and surely he'll be a success at Dortmund. He is the one who got away. No point blaming anyone especially Ole. If there's any area where we're actually doing okay, it's our strike force.
Not great? Name 5 teams in the top 4 leagues who are better?
I thought Ole is the biggest problem and once we solve that everything will be better.
We fcuked this one up.
It is known
Not saying that at all. He may have preferred Dortmund anyway.
However if the £60m release fee in 2022 is true, and I have no reason to believe it isn't, then it's for the best. He could have been taken off us by City or Liverpool. How would that have felt? Feck that. Dortmund are going to lose him for sure.
Fergie didn't allow clauses like that, I would;ve been disappointed if Ole did. If he really didn't want to come here, he would have quashed those rumours early on, and his dad wouldn't have bothered to tour our facilities.
I just can't see him spending his whole career in the bundesliga like lewandowski.
Such an over done move from Hummels to gotze to lewandowski.
Such an over done move from Hummels to gotze to lewandowski.
I never said that. Ole is out of depth but the real problem is the guy who gave him the job. The same guy who allowed him to start the season with promises of ample financial support but no cm
The defense is absolutely horrible, but he was devastating with the opportunities he was given, like he usually seems to do. I'm looking forward to seeing how he does the rest of the season. If the release clause is true, I wonder if Dortmund will try or even manage/desire to sell early because the reported figure is low compared to some of the sales they've made for their best talents.
What a simple way of looking at it, it's like not chatin a girl up because your worried shell leave you before even approaching her. You never know she might like simple ugly looking blokes!
You’re very embarrassing.And people think Greenwood's the better player.
I highly doubt that, his contract is setup to either make Dortmund sell him after 18 months for a crazy fee or sell him for peanuts after 30 months. If it’s the 30 month option then the fees to his Dad and Raiola will be astronomical. If he carries on like this then Bayern won’t be paying the fee it would take.
That said, I’ll reserve judgement on today’s game because the defending was absurd, he was just waiting on the half way line to get free run ins on goal.
Well, being an asshole is stupid. Have a nice evening.
I thought that your inside info shit was the stupidest thing you could come up with but here we are.
This one is gonna hurt everytime he scores a goal isnt it? Hopefully every Greenwood goal feels like aloe vera on the burns
Out of interest who are all these young players Dortmund have developed? So I can compare.
In defense of the club and OGS we only had a shout because of OGS, no player with the choices of Haaland would come near us at the moment, we are a mess.
How did United scew this up? I Genuinely wonder why this is a common sentiment. Is the narrative that United lowballed his wages? Wouldn't guarantee a starting spot? Its Ole's fault? I thought he chose Dortmund to develop further and move on fairly quickly to the next step.
How so? Bowing to the demands of Raiola would have been pretty crazy. Were we supposed to co-own him with Raiola and his dad, and allowing him to leave in 2-3 years time to earn them all another payday?
No we didn’t.
The way I see it there’s two scenarios.
1. We refused to agree to Raiola’s crazy demands, which supposedly contained a release clause, and Raiola getting a big sum of the next transfer, or
2. Haaland chose Dortmund for professional reasons.
Either way, we didn’t feck this up. Too bad we didn’t get him though, but overpaying, or agreeing to silly demands should not be something we do.
What confuses me is why we weren’t in for him in the Summer if Ole knew what a talent he was?
We have good strikers. We just need more creativity in midfield
Is a player allowed to switch clubs two windows in a row?
Can switch as many times as he wants, can play for two clubs in registered competitions.
I hope the clubs spin keeps you warm at night, he didn't come here because HE didn't want to not because we wouldn't agree with a release clause.
Absolutely. It’s just a little odd that we so last minute decided ”this lad is good, but he’s already decided to go Dortmund, quick on plane to try and get him”.
Surely if Ole knew he was that good we should have wrapped this up in the Summer with no competition once Lukaku left.
Ok, wasn’t sure as I thought I’d heard that a player can only switch clubs once per calendar year, or season.
And Kostur, of course a player can play for two teams in a season, my question was pertaining to three clubs in a single year.
and RAB: hindsight is 20/20. Most were taken aback by how mental Haaland’s season has been. I imagine Ole wouldn’t bring him to the pressures and competition at United without knowing whether he was ready. For everybody’s sake. To make this out to be some fumble is stretching it.
The mind-blowing thing about this kid is how he has this Ronaldo habit of constantly forcing attacking decisions for his own team. Tirelessly creates angles and runs in between defenders which forces your own team to attack and more often than not results in a shot on goal.
He's going to be a goal machine. He's obsessed. He's got the same obsession that Ronaldo figured out in his mid twenties...
He's going to be a goal machine. He's obsessed. He's got the same obsession that Ronaldo figured out in his mid twenties...
We should have bent over for him, he's obviously very very good. Now he will never play for us as the next stop for him will be Bayern, Barca, Madrid.
Oh stop the frigging bleating. He wanted BD over us for his development, end of.
CM and a wide right player is what we need more than a CF. Get over it
He could have had 4 goals if Sancho had passed instead of passing the goalie to score himself (it was a low-risk move from Jadon so no complaints there). Talk about getting yourself into finishing positions.
And he can happily go there as well and I still wont give a feck.
United should bend over for nobody, specifically that cnut Raiola. He's playing in a shit league against shit defenders however had he come to the PL and on the off chance he makes it at United, we should give others the opportunity to force a move at a cut price while he makes an astronomical name for himself off of our brand? feck off.
Agreed. The meltdown in this thread is ridiculous.
He said that?