U99ted
Full Member
- Joined
- Jan 1, 2013
- Messages
- 2,351
Scousers denied a late winner? I like it.
He was interfering by having to move his feetShould have stood. De Gea is moving to his right, can see the ball and even without Sigurdsson being there, he wouldnt have saved it. He was beaten by the deflection. Sigurdsson is not interfering with play. Its a goal
Worst thing ever to happen in football. Everton were robbed
How on earth were they robbed? The player was miles offside and interfering with play so much that he had to actively get out of the way to let the ball in. He was also directly in De Gea's line of sight. It's as blatant an offside as you''ll see.De Gea was beaten by Maguire’s deflection, think Everton was robbed here.
Go check Evertons goal at Old Trafford earlier in the season, karma if you ask me.Did you lot sacrifice Paul Pogba to the VAR gods this season? Unbelievable!
I think I agree. Sigurdson moved over the ball too. VAR is fine, good even, it ads to the excitement.Clear offside. Not sure how it's even controversial. Because it's in the last minute the rules don't apply?
Because it came off Lindelof I always was under the impression if the ball came off your own player then offside is basically a non factorHe had to lift his feet out of the way for the ball to go in, how can it not be offside?
Hes offside from the shotBecause it came off Lindelof I always was under the impression if the ball came off your own player then offside is basically a non factor
It's only if the ball originally moves goalwards from a defender that offside isn't a factor, like a passback or scuffed clearance. It would be mental if you couldn't be offside from deflected passes and shotsBecause it came off Lindelof I always was under the impression if the ball came off your own player then offside is basically a non factor
He should be allowed to chin the cnut now.The handball call was ridiculous but I think Fred was booked because he protested in the ref's face
This logic makes zero sense whatsoever.He’s not interfering with play imo. De Gea wasn’t saving that.
How on earth were they robbed? The player was miles offside and interfering with play so much that he had to actively get out of the way to let the ball in. He was also directly in De Gea's line of sight. It's as blatant an offside as you''ll see.
Thank Christ ye're not in the VAR room.
Exactly he’s interfering & clearly the goal should be disallowed.Yep.
Exactly. It is as simple as thatHes offside. You dont need the keeper making a save for it to be off.
Him lifting his legs to let it through is interfering in play imo.
I'm sure you would be angry. You would also be wrong. You can't expect the game to be reffed as per rules you've made up in your head.Then the rules are stupid. It would have been a goal anyway had he not been in that position so in my opinion it doesn’t influence the outcome. I would be angry if it was at the other end of the pitch.
We would be mad but we wouldn't be rightThat was a proper goal, De gea had clear view of the ball his vision wasn't obstructed by the player who also didnt touch the ball change its course or anything.
If it was the other way round and they disallowed us that goal we would be mad.
Balls it adds to the excitement.I think I agree. Sigurdson moved over the ball too. VAR is fine, good even, it ads to the excitement.
Was De Gea's ability to make a save affected in any way by Sigurdsson? I dont think so.We would be mad but we wouldn't be right
Take out VAR and then what ? The ref still gives that stupid handball and you still concede the goal (that only happened in your head btw).It's a joke. If Everton had scored from that freekick where Fred was wrongly adjudged to have handballed it, we could do nothing. Then Everton score a perfectly fine goal and VAR somehow contrives to mess it up.
Still, when it's in our favour I'll take it.
How does he have a clear view when Gylfi literally has to move his legs to get out the way?Probably yes.
Of course he was on the ground in an offside position, but the deflection from Maguire was the most important thing. De Gea had a clear view, he hasn't touched the ball and de Gea was going into the other direction because of the deflection.