The jury is still out on Galbraith. He could be a scholes clone or he could be a Norwood. At the moment it looks too easy for him at Doncaster so he needs to see at a higher level
37
- Status
Yeah same here. Made it even more surprising he made it as a centre mid.
It's another big difference. Garner in the U23's at least has always been a CM. To my knowledge anyway.
Think he might have been a CB at times in U18's and below.
Above conversation reminds me of Ben Pearson. He looked amazing in the U23s and has had a decent career but he looked so so good at that level. It’s very hard to tell. Also there’s So much luck involved in getting a break into the first team. For example Say this greenwood stuff may well have opened up a position for Hannibal now to actually contribute and get a fair crack before the end of the season. Elanga gets bumped up even more in importance. What were the odds on something crazy like that happening?
Different positions.
I don’t think there’s too much wrong with giving young central players their developmental minutes on the wings
Greenwood's also playing out of position on the wing.
I don't think Pearson had the technical ability of Garner though.
He was better than Garner physically but we know what happens to that physical edge once they step up. The edge isn't there anymore.
Not that I'm 100% on Garner. Is he confident enough to play at this level? Does he have that personality. Is he physical enough?
Spoke to Forest fan that thinks he can't do the job as holding midfielder, he thinks he's better in his attacking department and his talent is more box to box. Can anyone confirmed? Considering he used to score lot of goals in midfield U21, not surprised if his talent is more box to box.
Starting for Nottingham Forest vs Leicester City in the FA cup
He played as a B2B in his last season with the U23s and admittedly he did look very good in that role.
Its interesting hearing the talk of him being a b2b and mayb3 slightly better attacking. For me one of the key things that stood out last year in his loan was actually how good his tackling was as well as his ability to break up play.
I think the key thing holding him back is he doesnt seem to have the personality to assert himself on a game.
I think the key thing holding him back is he doesnt seem to have the personality to assert himself on a game.
His deliveries from set pieces are fantastic
Get the lad back to Manchester proper quality and can take a set piece.
Just got an assist from a corner after I posted that 
He can take a corner, bring him back! 
Get him back for his set pieces alone.
So good, bossing the midfield.
Two great corners in a row. Can’t believe I’m complimenting putting a half decent ball into the box but looking at our current players, apparently it’s pretty difficult. Also some tidy play around the box a few minutes ago.
How does Fred get a start over this lad.
Shows for the ball
Comfortable on the ball
Great pass selection
Set pieces are quality
Physical
Shows for the ball
Comfortable on the ball
Great pass selection
Set pieces are quality
Physical
He's looking great.
That's why we held off on buying a midfielder.
Murtough masterclass
Murtough masterclass
He's a magnificent passer of the ball.
He looks very good every time I see him. Whether or not he can step up to regular PL and European outings is a fair question but I'd like to see him given a chance some time soon. Plus his set pieces are a different level to ones we usually serve up.
Because Fred was much better before the season started and still is the better player.
Looking very comfortable today.
The boy Johnson also looks like one to watch!
The boy Johnson also looks like one to watch!
I know some prefer the look of Levitt or Galbraith but can't see it myself, I've always felt Garner was the best of the 3.
Think Burnley had a bid for him turned down last month, my guess is he along with Brereton Diaz will be in the PL next season.
It seems to me more and more that there’s not a huge amount of difference between the championship and PL at the middle level. You have quite a few players in the championship taking home lower to mid level PL wages. It’s great league to test young players now and it looks to have done Garner no harm at all.
I've not seen Fred play like this against maddison and tielmans.......
Very true these days. Championship benefits hugely due to the league structure and the money distribution. A lot of diamonds there.
Considering the number of potential midfield exits from us this summer, think even with a couple of purchases, there is a place for him in the squad. He has had invaluable loans and will be the right age this summer to come back. Personally dont think he is good enough to be what we need, but neither are our current options.
Give him a squad position and a couple fo seasons to break through or sell hiim, I dont think he beenfits from another loan next year
Give him a squad position and a couple fo seasons to break through or sell hiim, I dont think he beenfits from another loan next year
Playing very well , he can knock out the Scousers in the next round
It’s time to either sell or use enough to improve him. Perfect time for either approach. Same thing with Williams. They are boosting their price out on loan. No point bringing them back for 5 games a season.
Huddersfield are scousers?
Why would we sell him? That would be utter madness
The whole team have played well but I wouldn’t say that Garner has stood out particularly
Really like what I'm seeing from his movement in this match on the defensive end, his crossing seems pretty good as well getting an assist. If we don't sign someone like Rice or we lose Pogba this summer, I hope he stays at Man Utd and gets his chance next season.
The boys placed more passes than anyone else in the team and twice as many crosses (5/7 completed). Give him a PL loan next season, maybe Palace or Brighton if they keep their managers.
This. Garner would boss Fred on current form.
I disagree about another loan. Today he has held his own against a midfield of Ndidi, Tielmans and Maddisson. None of our current midfielders has been able to do that. Bring him back and give him a chance. To give him the best chance of succeding we need to get a good relacement for Matic. He is best as as a box to box
- Status