Jesus Christ, how about NO?
We sold him because he was no longer good enough for where we wanted to be. When a player leaves a big team, it speaks volumes to see which level of club shows an interest in that player. Evans joined West Brom. West Bromwich Albion. Not even Everton, West Ham, Newcastle, those mid-level but still big, well regarded clubs. WBA. That was the level of interest in him, which proved we were right to no longer consider him of the right quality to be at United.
Why would we even dream about bringing him back now, about 4yrs later? He's older and around the same quality he was when we sold him. Christ on a bike.