Red Dreams
Full Member
How long is he injured for?
Is he injured?How long is he injured for?
thought he came off holding his hammy.Is he injured?
Silva was fine, he has a new role, controlling more centrally and spraying passes. I thought Silva and KDB were their best players today with Fernandinho. Basically the midfield 3.While I think he's very good, I think his presence doesn't help Silva.
It's hard to get the optimum level from ever player, I guess.
He has always controlled games and played the killer passes to boot. I believe he's a better playmaker than De Bruyne who is a master of end product; whether it be from set-pieces or through his finishing. De Bruyne, Özil and Coutinho are these moderns attacking midfielders who provide great moments instead of dictating the play for long periods, which I think is the hardest thing to do in football. Silva is more akin to an old school playmaker like Zidane.Silva was fine, he has a new role, controlling more centrally and spraying passes. I thought Silva and KDB were their best players today with Fernandinho. Basically the midfield 3.
If he's not already, I think De Bruyne is going to be better than Silva was a couple seasons ago at his peak.He has always controlled games and played the killer passes to boot. I believe he's a better playmaker than De Bruyne who is a master of end product; whether it be from set-pieces or through his finishing. De Bruyne, Özil and Coutinho are these moderns attacking midfielders who provide great moments instead of dictating the play for long periods, which I think is the hardest thing to do in football. Silva is more akin to an old school playmaker like Zidane.
I prefer Silva, but respect what De Bruyne can offer.
I was wondering the exact same thing, it seems so bloody obvious he was destined to be great. That was a big error!I will never understand why we haven't bought him last season because it was clear for the club that Di Maria would leave.
Who is to say he would have chosen us though?I will never understand why we haven't bought him last season because it was clear for the club that Di Maria would leave.
Nail on head - The weight on his passing is greatIf Mourinho insists on playing 4-2-3-1 and with a #10, then he should just watch a few tapes of KdB's performance today for what he should be buying. Masterclass in playing between the lines.
He probably had more individual good moments in this one game as a #10 than Rooney has in 5-6 matches as a #10, and herein lies some of the problem we have.
I could have sworn Silva was killing us as a number 8 yesterdayWhile I think he's very good, I think his presence doesn't help Silva.
It's hard to get the optimum level from ever player, I guess.
And I'd even add they made each other better.I could have sworn Silva was killing us as a number 8 yesterday
They dovetailed really well together, I think if Guardiola gets the balance right this city team should get to the latter stages of the CL, I really like what he's doing with city.And I'd even add they made each other better.
Kdb was crap in this fixture last season, Rojo held him with lock and key, perhaps we should give our player some time.Nothing against Pogba, but KDB looked more like a 89m player yesterday than him to be honest
He didn't look like a big money signing in this corresponding fixture last season when Marcos Rojo had him in his pocket. It can happen.Nothing against Pogba, but KDB looked more like a 89m player yesterday than him to be honest
It can, but that was more due to the role De Bruyne was playing and Pellegrini's shoddy tactics imo. De Bruyne played to his strengths today and it showed.He didn't look like a big money signing in this corresponding fixture last season when Marcos Rojo had him in his pocket. It can happen.
I prefer KDB and if I could have one it'd be him, but it's not fair to compare two players over 1 match, different styles of players tooNothing against Pogba, but KDB looked more like a 89m player yesterday than him to be honest
And you can neatly switch that logic to govern Pogba yesterday I would imagine.It can, but that was more due to the role De Bruyne was playing and Pellegrini's shoddy tactics imo. De Bruyne played to his strengths today and it showed.
Very true.And you can neatly switch that logic to govern Pogba yesterday I would imagine.
True. In the same fixture last season, Rojo managed to take him completely out of the game. He was arguably worse than Pogba in his derby debut.He's a very good player, but as usual there's a lot of kneejerking going on.
Oui. I shudder to think what adding Gundgan on their good day will add. Against a team sleeping like we did first halfAnd I'd even add they made each other better.
Nah, having the skills wouldn't be enough to be considered among the all time greats. You need to combine it with prestigious trophies. Despite his talent, he still has so so much to accomplishHis ability to spot spaces in the oppositions defensive set up is sensational, and his ball striking reminds me of Zidane. Sadly he doesn't have the great frenchmans skill or he'd be well on his way to all time greatness.
I hated every second of it and felt like my bowels were turning to water every time he touched the ball . I agree with the sentiment though and I see where you're coming from with the Sharpe comparison although I remember Sharpe as a faster, more orthodox winger as opposed to de Bruyne's roving attacker/playmaker type. I do see similarities though with that knack for clever touches in and around the box and moreover that sense that something dangerous is going to happen every time they pick up the ball in the final third.Reminded me of the vibrant and skillful Lee Sharpe at his best.
Despite suffering becuase of him, I even enjoyed KDB's performance, it was that good.
Admitted he was aided by the space we have him but he ruthlessly exploited that gift.
He will thrive under Guardiola and get even better. As much as one can as a United fan, I'm looking forward to seeing him develop this season.