Henry was the PK, at least in his prime. Maybe Bergkamp took some but after Henry became established he was the main PK taker IIRC, but my memory gets hazy prior to 2005-06.
Personally, I don't understand the issue some have with the list
@do.ob made, it's a valid list to compare all these names and considering the penalties as a separate category. The fact that Rashford won most of those penalties isn't destroying any argument because, as it's been mentioned before, others on the list have won the penalties but didn't take them for various reasons, least of which is the idea they couldn't score it themselves.
It's just a very strange defensive instinct to perceived criticism of Rashford when it's just context.