I think he should be given a spot on the bench and given minutes here and there to see how he fares. Now Mourinho is gone I see an opportunity for our younger players under Ole. It's also fantastic that McKenna will be there to coach and give advice on the youth.
Mason Greenwood
- Thread starter Utdstar01
- Start date
-
In the latest episode of the United Hour Podcast, Nik (@Rood) was joined by comedian Ali Woods to look back at the best and worst moments of a rollercoaster season with the annual United Hour Awards.
Has Ten Hag been sacked yet? We're not sure and we hope not, but it's looking more likely as the days pass.
Who should replace him and why is it taking so long to make a decision?
- Status
As I said Before I would love to see him at Ajax for a year. A team that loves to attack and are struggling for a Center forward. Dohlberg hasn't rediscovered his form since his injury and Huntelaar is pushing on
Maybe and maybe not. Loads of kids go out on loan and don't get games, sit in the reserves, deal with changes in managers. It's Russian roulette.
It's different for every player. It worked for Evans and Welbeck but not for most of the others who went out.
The majority of people on here, me included, don't see players grow, develop and mature day in and day out.
Let the coaches and clubs work out the best career route for each player. They won't all get it right of course but that's their job.
Greenwood turned 17 just 2 months ago, going out on loan would be a ridiculous idea and is never going to happen. If he doesn't break into the first team squad this year he'll be with the u23's next season, if he finds that level as easy as the youth team then I'd imagine United may look at loaning him out. I suspect he'll be with the first team from next August anyway if he continues to develop like he has done so far.
He's like our third choice striker at the moment and we like to use our 2nd choice as a starter out wide while our first choice is struggling.
So why would we loan him?
So why would we loan him?
Think next year is when we will see him properly in and out of the first team.
If Ajax is desperate to win the league, they must get Greenwood, he's perfect striker for their style of play, Ajax/Barca DNA.
great shout
Would like him to get some cameo appearances if we get some nice FA cup draws this year, and a view to a bigger role next year. I'd say best case scenario if he keeps progressing like this than by the 2020/21 season we can hope for a decently active role, but not really before then. He just turned 17... By the end of next season he might be included more and more as a sub, but unlikely to be more. Anyway, hope he keeps his head down and progresses properly. Martial, Greenwood, Rashford would be a brilliant future.
I think his running style is deceptive, he never really looks like he's flat out sprinting but he has a really long stride so actually covers the ground extremely quickly. I'd say he's probably quicker than most over a distance & it's very rare to see him beaten for pace.
HeheThese things can never be scheduled in this manner. All we can control is when a player is introduced to the first team. What happens after that is largely up to him. If Greenwood makes an instant impact in the first team and scores goals, then we won’t wait another two years before we play him properly. Just as we didn’t wait a further two years with Rashford, Monaco didn’t with Mbappé and so on and so forth with every other highly talented teenager that broke into the side.
The trajectory you described is like that of much less talent than Greenwood - the path the likes of Fletcher or Neville would take. The Rooneys and Owens of this world don’t follow such paths, but it’s up to them.
Wow as good a hat trick i will ever see. Genuine question - Is he one of our own like Rashford or did we pluck him from some other club's academy?
Think I read somewhere that he's been with us since he was 8/9, so I'd guess we're his only club.
Cheers lads. Another one of our own. Hope to see him and Marcus up top together one day 
Everyone has a different opinion on youth players like this.
1 - go out on loan to X to gain experience
2 - stay at the club at learn from our players here and get in when you deserve it
As excited as I am about the kid, he needs to have people around him with a sensible head and do what he feels is best for him.
Personally I'd love it if we made a decision and said something like sign a new 4 year contract but go out on loan to a club like RBL / Dortmund to ply your trade for a guaranteed 2 years and have that stability but in a weaker league and away from the glory of the PL / United - although I doubt they'd agree to that.
As for the hattrick - it was a youth hattrick. Very well taken but the tricks and skill wouldn't beat many top defenders or keepers at the PL or CL in my opinion
1 - go out on loan to X to gain experience
2 - stay at the club at learn from our players here and get in when you deserve it
As excited as I am about the kid, he needs to have people around him with a sensible head and do what he feels is best for him.
Personally I'd love it if we made a decision and said something like sign a new 4 year contract but go out on loan to a club like RBL / Dortmund to ply your trade for a guaranteed 2 years and have that stability but in a weaker league and away from the glory of the PL / United - although I doubt they'd agree to that.
As for the hattrick - it was a youth hattrick. Very well taken but the tricks and skill wouldn't beat many top defenders or keepers at the PL or CL in my opinion
Yeah, but he just turned 17. That's incredibly young no matter how good he is. Messi only really got a first team role for Barcelona once he turned 18 (the summer before the 05/06 season) and he made 25 appearances in all competition that season. That timeline would basically him being the 2nd half of next season having an impact on the squad, and again, only really establishing himself in the first team as a bigger role until the 2020/21 season. He turns 19 in that season. Mbappe only turned into a starter and a key player for Monaco after he turned 18, and he's a once a generation talent. Rooney started off early because of how developed he was physically. Ronaldo was 18 and a half when he joined United. Sancho right now for Dortmund is turning 19 in a few months. He only started getting a bigger role with Dortmund this season, when he was again, 18.5. Greenwood is a year and a half from that age.
Of course he's incredibly talented, but people need to realize that 2 months ago he was 16 years old. People progress quickly at a young age, but even as a very promising youngster who develops quickly, you can't expect anything out of him til the 2nd half of next season as a best case scenario, when he is a few months past his 18th birthday. How often do you see a freshly turned 17 year old literally do anything at a first team level? Simply getting a sub appearance and not being thrown around like a kid will be a positive.
This season is way too soon for him. Next season, more likely the second half of the season. He'll be 18 still by the time the 2020/21 season starts, don't forget.
I don't expect Greenwood to ever go on loan. He won't need it. He'll train with the first team and he's good enough that he'll be given regular first team cameos in the near future.
I agree
Rashford wouldn't have got the opportunity he did if it wasn't for a injury crisis and LVG having the courage to play him. I think Greenwood should be given a taste of first team football and I think we may just have the guy in charge to give him a opportunity now.
Messi had growth issues and was given steroids due to being tiny. That's the reason he was held back from what i've read.
Rashford was 18 years and 4 months when he got his chance basically. Young players do just need to be given a chance sometimes, like Rashford was. But you look at any of the great players recently or any of the ones who broke through for United. How many did it before 18? Giggs was the season he turned 18. Scholes when he turned 19. Ronaldo was 18.5 when he joined United. Messi was after 18. Mbappe really broke through with a first team role after he was 18. Beckham was 19/20. The Brazilian Ronaldo turned 18 at the start of his first season in Europe. The list goes on. The most any of these had as 17 year olds (especially those that just turned 17) was the random sub appearance in meaningless games with the pressure off. Greenwood might get that close to the end of the season, but its unreasonable to expect more. Hes still at the very least a year away from having any type of impact. More likely would be the 2nd half of next season and then the 2020/21 season (if he continues to progress quickly without any hiccups). He just turned 17. That really cant be emphasized enough if they think hes in the situation where he just needs a chance. There is playing youth, and then there is trusting someone who just turned 17 to be able to hack it in the premier league right away. The list of players that was able to do that is basically Rooney and nobody else in the recent past.
Rashford never needed a loan and he's developing along fine. If the boy is good enough, he'll play here regardless of age and training with top class players everyday
My point was, Rashford when he got his opportunity it was due to pure luck. He was playing in the u-18s at the time, when we had a injury crisis and LVG had the courage to throw him into the deep end. Rashford bypassed the under 23 team and was thrown into the deep end because we had a guy at the club in LVG who had the courage to do that. Many including myself didn't think he was ready, but until a young player who is exceptionally talented is given a opportunity we can only speculate.
Ryan Giggs made his debut aged 17 yrs and 3 months against Everton as a sub.
Michael Owen was barely 17 when Liverpool first team coach Roy Evans was quoted as saying "if you're good enough, you're old enough" then handed a 17 year old Owen his debut in a game he scored in a few months later. I can give you other examples too.
I'm not saying we should throw Greenwood straight into the first 11. But he should be considered as a bench option considering we don't have a clinical CF at the club. He falls into the exceptional talent category and should be given minutes here and there imo.
Owen is an interesting example because even though he was absolutely brilliant at a young age, he was overplayed and eventually ruined by the injuries he picked up over the years. Arguably he'd have been better off playing less. Having said that, he definitely showed he was good enough to play in serious games and I suspect Greenwood wouldn't be a million miles away were he to get the chance. Natural finishers who also have tricks, pace and strength as well as two fantastic feet don't come along all that often. He needs to pick up some minutes in easy games really though to show he's ready.
That hatrick goal just reminded me of Giggs' goal against QPR in 1994.
Man, I wish we had a striker like RVP right now.
Wish Greenwood becomes like this in the future. He is like a fast forward version of RVP.
P.S. Arsene Wenger is the real MVP of the 12/13 season.
Wish Greenwood becomes like this in the future. He is like a fast forward version of RVP.
P.S. Arsene Wenger is the real MVP of the 12/13 season.
Agreed
Please wait wait wait English players are always massively overhyped. This kid has not even played first team football yet. Mbappe is 19 only two years older and the way he tool the football world by storm by performing and scoring big goal in a semi final CL run and being a key player in a record breaking Monaco team along with a wc medal and finals goals is incredible. Like I said let's not overhype him. His name should not even be in the same sentence as mbappe.
Yeah I'm all for feeling good about the kid. But let's refrain for crazy comparison's.
Yeah, it was a pretty crazy comment which is why I didn't bother refuting it. Mbappe is a freak.
The only comparison to be had which I feel is valid is how everything Greenwood tries, he pretty much does with quality. It's a trait similar to Mbappe. Same goes for decision making. However, it's another thing to look like that at youth level and look like that at first team level. The game speeds up on you and gives you less time to think which obviously makes kids look like, well, kids.
Deafepl, here is Mbappe at 15 years old
You know what I loved about Greenwood's last performance? I loved that he tried to chip the keeper from distance. He's not afraid to test his limit right now.
Madness. We still need to try and win matches. Right back at ya!
He is a talented lad no doubt but the English kids tend to be very very very overhyped by English fans and media which is why I don't like to judge them on youth level and wait to see how they adapt and play when it becomes fast paced first team football.
People go crazy with the idea of sending our youngsters on loan. Mason should stay here, he's just 17.
The fact that he was selected for first team duty against Valencia under Mourinho just shows how highly rated he's within the club. I'd love for him to be given a chance but he's hardly played u23 football too, some patience would be nice.
The fact that he was selected for first team duty against Valencia under Mourinho just shows how highly rated he's within the club. I'd love for him to be given a chance but he's hardly played u23 football too, some patience would be nice.
Shola Shoretire looks more impressive than Mbappe at 15 imo. Not saying Shoretire will be on the same level but from that vid i'd say Shoretire looks better.
And I believe Shoretire is 14
Can you guys calm down and stop comparing every kid with Mbappe. Guy is a freak and what he did at such young age is just remarkable.
I could make a compilation video of half the kids in our academy that would make them look better than both those players. Comparing player's via Youtube is complete nonsense.
Cameos
Let's not compare him to Mbappe before he's even played first team football.
- Status