There is a limit of 5 tag alerts per post, so if you're exceeding that any users above that threshold won't be alerted (I think). Does that explain the issue?
Please read: Upgrade to XenForo v1.2
- Thread starter Niall
- Start date
If you edit in an @ alert to a post, will it alert the intended recipient?
Try it. Edit your post with one to me and I'll let you know.
No.
Cheers. 