Of course, I’m just not buying the narrative that his recent goals are due to him improving. How many shots has he had where he hit the keeper? How many chances has he had? Very few. You cannot base anything on fine margins until there’s an adequate sample size.
11
Season Average Rating
- Appearances
- 43
- Goals
- 13
- Assists
- 2
- Yellow cards
- 2
-
Hello, Guest! We have two new competitions (with taglines and awards as prizes) starting for the new Premier League season.
A new Premier League Predictions competition is starting now. Click here to enter to submit predictions for MD1.
A new Last Man Standing competition is starting now. Click here to enter to submit predictions for MD1.
For Last Man Standing you have until the 16th August to submit your predictions. Submissions will be open for the next 20 days, 13 hours, 1 minute, 39 seconds, and will close on Aug 16, 2024 at 20:00.
Bonus: for fans of Odds or Evens, the thread will be going up mid-August with a deadline for after the transfer window shuts.
- Status
I wonder if the Lino could do a half flag or some other signal or something - basically to indicate its a tight one.... might just help give fans/players a pause?
If he hit 20 goals in all comps it’d be a fantastic first season.
For reference - Nunez got 15 in all comps his first season.
For reference - Nunez got 15 in all comps his first season.
Delighted for him, would have 5 or 6 more goals if Martinez, Shaw & Casemiro hadn't missed so much football.
Did he score many headed goals for Atlanta?
Did he score many headed goals for Atlanta?
5 goals and 2 assists in his last 6 games (since the new year started). I think something that plays a part in his turn in form is getting some rest between matches. He joined with his back slightly fecked and didn't get much rotation during the frantic periods of the season owing to Martial's injury problems.
One a week until the end of the season will do him fine.
One a week until the end of the season will do him fine.
Only situation like that, that i can think off right now, is against Liverpool. His shot hit Alisson that game. He could have done better but Alisson is a fantastic goalkeeper who will make impressive saves.
Sorry, can see how it sounded a bit arrogant. Of course he’s improved, but that’s not the main reason that he’s begun scoring now, I think. He’d very likely have scored the same goals had he gotten the same chances in September.
Is he reborn as a dragon yet 
How is your “feck VAR” position justified in this instance?
Because without VAR you could celebrate instantly?
I was watching highlights as I missed the game and even then I was like "hang on, surely this will be checked"
I don’t keep those stats but I recall shots from reasonably close range that didn’t result in a score. Now they are. But I do agree that we’re comparing small sample sizes, the first half of the season compared to the second half of the season, which not even halfway through yet. But the uptick in firm is noticeable.
I do this for basically every single goal that isn't a longe range belter now. Just waiting for some infraction to be pulled up in replay.
VAR doesn’t stop you from celebrating instantly though - that’s why I’m struggling to understand the justification for your position - in this context at least.
To clarify - you give more consideration to your apprehension at celebrating instantly than potential bad/wrong decisions deciding games/seasons?
obviously the implementation of VAR isn’t without error, but imagine losing season defining games to offside goals - because “instant celebration”. What?
Do you go to live games?
That goal was no different to the pre VAR days though? We knew it would be tight and I looked to the lino before celebrating. Sure, with VAR you wait a little more, but I celebrate every goal unless it's obviously off.
I'm confused as to how it's no different?
Pre VAR - you have to wait a second for the players or commentator to mention an offside flag - now you could have two mins of everyone ambling about before you get the dreaded VAR cut to the screen. You can't relax until the game kicks off.
This was me. Feck VAR.
I guess because the 'live' goal looked tight but the replay immediately showed it was fine so I didn't really think of VAR. I celebrated as it went in but in both cases I am subconsciously waiting for a few seconds for a whistle.
My problem with VAR for TV watching pales in comparison to it's effect on watching us home and away anyway.
Well, it's more like, how can I fully celebrate a goal if I think it will be disallowed? Hard to get lost in the moment of a goal if you're convinced that the VAR will disallow it anyway.
VAR has its uses for offside though - which is why I would be for a "soft signal" from Linesman when a goal is scored on a tight offside.
However VAR now also gives you the opportunity to lose season defining games by ridiculous handball decisions and/or other terrible calls - so I think "feck VAR" is a totally valid statement in general
Not really a ‘feck VAR’ situation though, more the opposite. If everyone thought the goal was offside, we’d simply just get a flag and we all move on, later lamenting that the replays showed it was indeed on and we were robbed. VAR, in this instance, ensured you got the chance to celebrate at all!
He’s not particularly good aerially at all I’d say, definitely one of his obvious areas to improve I think.
Well in this instance VAR stopped us from celebrating instantly as the lino didn't flag.
But yes, in a situation where the lino had flagged we'd have been robbed.
this isn’t specific to VAR, though. You were convinced VAR would disallow it because you thought he was offside - and if you think a goal will be disallowed, your ability to celebrate and get lost in the moment is hampered either way - outside of “I hope we can get away with this bad call”
Thus me saying “VAR implementation isn’t without error, but I’m confused by that stance and your justification in this instance and context.”
This doesnt happen in a vacuum though. The lino didn’t flag so that it could be checked by VAR. The commentators on my stream even emphasised so.
Considering the number of people that thought he was off, high chance that gets flagged without VAR.
In TV your eye can mostly see it whether it's off straight away so its not an issue and the replays come up almost instantly, live at games it's a disaster you celebrate then are left waiting for minutes sometimes before you know
I'm struggling to understand that you don't seem to think an enormous part of football has been lost in celebrating goals as they go in because we instead, very often, have to wait a few minutes now, and it colours every goal that goes in now because you wonder if it'll stand.
Semi automatic offside exists... I can live with fouls being missed/dives being called, but the tech is there for pretty much instant offside checks. Wouldn't change yesterday's reaction, he looked off in real time
Agree to disagree on this - in a non-VAR world, yeah you don't celebrate instantly, but 2 seconds later when you realise there's not flag you can go bonkers (a prime example would be Quinton Fortune's goal against Middlesbrough in a 4-3 win 20 odd years ago if you remember that). Where as with VAR you have to wait until the replay (or in the stadium until the check is over) to properly celebrate, at which point the magic has gone.
Nah that's not how it works - if the linesman doesn't think its offside, he doesn't flag - simple as that.
Goals always get checked so its irrelevant to that process if he flags for a goal or not.
My guess before the season for him was roughly 15 goals... Keep this up and he could we'll hit 20 in all competitions. If he gets a 1 in 2 record for the rest of the season and stays fit, he'll get close to it.
Apparently Real are interested
You’re probably struggling to understand that because it’s not a position I’ve taken, argued against or even spoken on - since it’s not what I’m discussing in the exchange I’m having in this thread
I actually don’t remember that goal, I’ll look it up. But again, consideration to apprehension at celebrating instantly > potential bad/wrong decisions deciding games/seasons?
In which case - this seems to be confirmation to my question above, then?
Drogba's offside goal against us that decided the title was a heartbreaker, but I'd still take how football was back then over VAR. VAR has made it an immensely less enjoyable experience.
6 of our next 7 games are very winnable, so he could be on 15 goals by then with 9 games remaining minimum assuming we beat Forrest in the cup.
20 is definitely achievable.
Next step is for him to start scoring more than once in a game (in the league). His last 4 have come quite early in games and he’s barely threatened the goal after them. Increasing his goalscoring moments during games is an objective for both him and the rest of the team.
If you watch him off the ball, he makes loads of runs but nobody passes to him.
On Reddit there's a highlight package of United chances and you can see him constantly making runs.
Garnacho in particular is a little greedy and lacking vision although obviously I like him and he's a great talent.
Apology accepted. I agree that his finishing has not been the issue. I think the whole team needed half a season to adjust playing with a striker after playing for so long without one. It shouldn't have taken this long but it is what it is. We've got a solid front three (depending on Rashford's mood) now that needs to be built upon.
- Status