[kundalini]

Fortunate that Sevilla wasted an opportunity after dispossessing him in our area in the first half. Punished for being asleep late on. Navas' cross deflecting off Malacia into the net via De Gea.

Very poor performance overall.

 

[El Jefe]

He was ridiculously bad at both ends of the pitch. I actually think he was worse in atrack. He had so much space today and I can't think of a single thing he did that was positive

 

[Idxomer]

Come on, let's not exaggerate. Had a good enough game. It was only until the end that shit went sour.

fecked up on their goal and gave them hope for the come back.

Bottled the chance he got, but the pass from Woot went to the wrong feet. Should have done better though.

Absolutely not, he was shit all night.

Also, has he ever made a good cross in his career? Ten Hag had him on corners early in the season which is worse than having Phil Jones on them.

 

[Chinchy98]

Going to get hammered on here. Really poor game - inexcusable defending for Sevilla’s first.

 

[Abhinav]

Poor the entire game and an absolute baffling piece of defending to get them back into the game. Honestly, I was uneasy with his last 2 performances also, especially in possession. Shaw brings calmness with the ball while Malacia brings a lot of uneasiness. He is a decent back-up, but that it.

 

[Oranges038]

Did ok, but that feck up at the end is unforgiveable. What an utter brain fart.

 

[STYLOISRED]

Worst game in a united shirt by a distance. Always seemed unsure of what he was doing throughout the match. And his error for the first goal was amateurish.

 

[PoTMS]

He lost us this tie.

 

[renatosanches85]

Thought he was fine until that utter f*ckup. But that kind of thing simply can't be done by a professional, it's unforgivable.

Apart from when he was dispossessed in the first half and Sevilla should have scored then……

 

[King7Eric]

Thought he was fine until that utter f*ckup. But that kind of thing simply can't be done by a professional, it's unforgivable.

He was easily out worst player even before that feck up. Had an absolute mare tonight.

 

[2 man midfield]

Should’ve made it 3-0. Instead made it 2-1.

 

[Andycoleno9]

I was not seeing some special talent when we signed him and i am not seeing it now.
He is average player. And on top that, one thing is going under radar; AWB is criticised for his attacking play but Malacia is even worse than AWB in that.

 

[sullydnl]

Been a very good signing generally but was bad today, along with a major feck-up.

 

[Floyd]

Score 3-0? No thanks, I rather score 2-1. Awful awful player in attack, AWB way better than him.

 

[Canucantona20]

No Shaw no party

 

[Mailo]

Think he wore the wrong cleats for the pitch. Was slipping a lot.

 

[Ludens the Red]

I genuinely don’t know how you can play for Manchester United and have it in your locker to do that. Amateur shit.. and moments before he had that shot where for some inexplicable reason he went low instead of high. Such a dumb performance.

 

[Erics_Collar]

Been a very good signing generally but was bad today, along with a major feck-up.

Very good?

Get some fecking standards, would you!

 

[arnie_ni]

Been a very good signing generally but was bad today, along with a major feck-up.

Yep agreed. He's been a very capable back up until tonight

 

[Borys]

Very very poor. I'd consider playing Dalot on LB.

He made so many bad choices on the ball it's crazy. Clearly low on confidence.
Defensively was OK apart from that moment...

 

[Reditus]

Easily his worst game for us. But up to now I’ve been impressed with Malacia and is a great back up

just one of those nights

 

[sullydnl]

Very good?

Get some fecking standards, would you!

As a signing of course he's been very good. He cost €15m, is one relatively low wages, let us get rid of the awful Telles, has been a perfectly fine second-choice in his position and is still young enough to keep improving. That's a very good buy.

 

[pascell]

He was far too complacent tonight, you don't get away with it sometimes and tonight was one of those times.

 

[Robaldo]

I don't like laying it on players but he's got the rub of the green on the pitch and with the fans for a lot of this season.

Maguire's own goal was clumsy and unlucky but Malacia's was just slack - really poor.

 

[RedIan]

Hes been pretty reliable up until tonight. He struggled all game with his opposing winger tonight. He switched off thinking the ball was going out, unforgivable schoolboy error. very poor.

 

[Red Shorts]

Going to get hammered on here. Really poor game - inexcusable defending for Sevilla’s first.

Not at all. The consensus was an overall poor game. Little offered attacking or defending.

We have seen too many times he switches off when positioning himself in defence, and does little to provide an attacking outlet.

 

[NK86]

Been a very good signing generally but was bad today, along with a major feck-up.

I would say he's been average to atrocious the last 2 games actually. Just that he highlighted it today with a massive feck up.

 

[fergiewherearethou]

Poor the entire game and an absolute baffling piece of defending to get them back into the game. Honestly, I was uneasy with his last 2 performances also, especially in possession. Shaw brings calmness with the ball while Malacia brings a lot of uneasiness. He is a decent back-up, but that it.

Decent back-up means that you can rely on him when Shaw is unavailable. Not the case unfortunately, he was shaky all game.

 

[arnie_ni]

As a signing of course he's been very good. He cost €15m, is one relatively low wages, let us get rid of the awful Telles, has been a perfectly fine second-choice in his position and is still young enough to keep improving. That's a very good buy.

You aren't allowed any nuance like that

 

[KirkDuyt]

Seeing both him and Hartman (our new academy left back who replaced him) play at the same level tonight, I'm starting to think the new dude is better.

 

[James35]

Not just on this game and with my current mood but I don’t rate him that highly and haven’t since he signed. Fee was cheap though but for me he is a Buttner, Williams, Telles level etc. He is certainly not the next Evra. Hopefully Shaw will be back soon and Malacia can go back to the bench.

 

[Rustyspider13]

Bad game from him. He has shown that same naivety before, can't quite remember which game. Disappointed to see that same mistake from him. Owes an apology to his teammates and needs to improve quickly.

 

[wangyu]

Good moments, bad moments but his error destroyed our game today

 

[Erics_Collar]

As a signing of course he's been very good. He cost €15m, is one relatively low wages, let us get rid of the awful Telles, has been a perfectly fine second-choice in his position and is still young enough to keep improving. That's a very good buy.

What is he very good at?

Being a cheap transfer and on low wages is of no consideration at all if he can't be relied upon when our first choice isn't available.

He's young so he has that, you'd hope he'll improve. But I would be worried that there isn't a single aspect to his game that stands out as an exciting prospect - he's not a defensive behemoth that just needs to improve going forward, nor is he an attacking asset that needs to work on his defensive game. He's an average player with no stand out abilities. I don't see a very high ceiling for him at all.

 

[CM]

It was an awful moment from him, I really don't know what he was thinking. He'd played okay up to that point but he really lost his head after the error.

 

[arthurka]

Should’ve made it 3-0. Instead made it 2-1.

Antony should've made it 3-0 as well. It was a mistake but how the team crumbled in second half wasn't on him.

 

[Isotope]

Worst game he has had this season. And in such important game as well. You can see from the 1st minute he's struggling throughout the game. I'd probably subbed him with Dalot on 2nd half.

But meh..

 

[Eddy_JukeZ]

Abysmal for their 1st goal.

 

[Rossa]

Awareness. It’s not the first time. Evra had a few of those lapses, bug he needs to iron them out quickly.

 

[justboy68]

I like Malacia but he had an absolutely terrible game the whole way through and capped it off with that mistake that could cost us the tie. He was a cheap, young purchase and we are starting to see why. Hope he can bounce back strong.