Surprising?
Lukaku to be somewhere at the top in top speed (long distance, off the ball) isn't surprising. Seen glimpse of it in games.
Dalot having the highest top speed is surprising for me, haven't seen that in games. His agility and acceleration are rapid of course, but also top speed?! wow.
The rest are as expected.
Bailly and Pogba doesn't have high top speed, so clear in games. Both of them are so agile and quick accelerating in short to mid distances. Pogba is way fast on-the-ball than off-the-ball. Jones and Smalling having high top speed is the same thing, seen it many times in games - those many times where they hurriedly sprint back to defend counters, very fast.
I think similar to Shaw, Bailly is also instructed to not give 100%, we know his injury record, which explained his slightly lower number. I swear I've seen him sprint long distance way faster than Lindelof ever did in games. Should be somewhere at 11 to 12.
Case of Shaw though. Before that big injury he had, he was so rapid in games, definitely will be one of top best high up this list. Since then, can't see that rapid top speed any more so his normal speed now should be more at 13 to 15 -- he's a lot slower now for me in games when sprinting but not that slow because he's still fast enough than the snails and still have his good acceleration. And I believe what Shaw claimed "
the coaches told him to not give 100% in the speed test" (something like that) is true as a precaution to not risk his injury (the test is ran during pre-season and there were reports of Shaw getting a knock in trainings, he also got injuries during this time twice iirc).
What's more important?
Acceleration, agility/change of directions, repetitions of movements and on-the-ball quickness are far more important than just top speed in football matches.