It's this giorno guy just destroying the forum with his nonsense.
Victor Lindelöf
- Thread starter FromTheBench
- Start date
-
In the latest episode of the United Hour Podcast, Nik (@Rood) was joined by comedian Ali Woods to look back at the best and worst moments of a rollercoaster season with the annual United Hour Awards.
Has Ten Hag been sacked yet? We're not sure and we hope not, but it's looking more likely as the days pass.
Who should replace him and why is it taking so long to make a decision?
- Status
On topic:
I'd be interested in who he replaces in the lineup or whether he is nailed on for a starting spot?
And when he comes in, I wonder if we will let one of Rojo/Jones/Blind will be sold to balance the squad..
Offtopic:
If there is one thing that I love about the Caf, then that's the revisionism that goes around here.
How could anyone tag Carrick as "world class" when we signed him is beyond me. I'm sure half the Caf saw Memphis and Morgan Schneiderlin as the best signings we could have made that season and now a lot of posters would be the first to brand them "useless"
I'd be interested in who he replaces in the lineup or whether he is nailed on for a starting spot?
And when he comes in, I wonder if we will let one of Rojo/Jones/Blind will be sold to balance the squad..
Offtopic:
If there is one thing that I love about the Caf, then that's the revisionism that goes around here.
How could anyone tag Carrick as "world class" when we signed him is beyond me. I'm sure half the Caf saw Memphis and Morgan Schneiderlin as the best signings we could have made that season and now a lot of posters would be the first to brand them "useless"
I still don't get why we would make this move. Smalling, Bailly, Jones, and Rojo have all shown they are capable for us. We have Blind as a backup in cast anyone else gets hurt, plus talented young players like Tuanzebe if everyone gets hurt.
There was nothing to comment on from the first half really, he is a nice passer of the ball, really crisp with either foot, but he had no defending to do as Benfica were dominant. I switched off before the second half started so maybe he had more defending to do then.
I meant from the player / manager / official from the club. Even an answer such as 'No comment' would be telling.
Mourinho probably wants more than "capable".
We can't say anything for sure, but it's unreasonable if he has release clause and we pay over that clause for the selling club, when we have to compete in wage offer for the player with other interested clubs.
Ah, that makes sense, Ta.
Tweet
— Twitter API (@user) date
Absolutely crazy to suggest that Carrick was world class when we signed him. Wasn't even in the top 5 midfielders in the PL at the time so how was he world class? If he was he would have been starting for England at least.Carrick was already a WC DM/CM when you signed him, he just got even better afterwards. Is Blind a world class DM already? I mean, sure, he might reach that level, but do you think it likely?
I really must have only seen his bad games then
Casemiro is a pure destroyer who only gets to play because we have kroos and modric next to him and 3 forwards with a poor workrate. When even one of those 3 is out, we're actually better off with kovacic in his place. And he IS a truly great destroyer anyways
Agree with the general point but I wouldn't judge Carrick at all based on how he was used by the English national.
Not when he bought him though. Hagreaves was very good during that period. And not to mention it's hard to drop either Lampard or Gerrard during that period.
Carrick has the honour to work with the finest midfielder of his era. Whoever comes at United won't find Scholes to show them the ropes
Hardly a dismissal is it.
That YouTube heading is wrong at no point does he dismiss Lindelof he says "lets see what happens if we buy a player we buy a player, we wont be buying two, three, four"
Yeah, only link I could find unfortunately.
No we don't ! We need the best to get back to the top I couldn't care if they are from China Brazil or Sweden
We need a certain amount in the squad as per the rules of the league and Europe. Smalling would be kept but I think it'd be over Blind than Rojo as I can't see Blind being Mourinhos long term left back.
agree with you on this but if jose sees Lindelof as a player him capable of turning into a world class player then why not. jose's record with signing defenders is pretty good, with the latest being bailly.
I think Jose bought Baily as a partner to Smalling. However, I think he has grown some doubts about Smalling recently and Mourinho does not like to have doubts about his defense. Smalling will not go but his position is not guaranteed any more.
Any thoughts about the Semedo rumours?Today's game seemed like a goodbye. Had a good game btw best in a while
His agent has now confirmed that he has a a transfer proposal, but won't reveal the interested club. To add to the rumours... Man Utd was represented at the Stadium Light, although that is pretty common
He is my fav Benfica's CB and will be an important loss. Really hate when we weaken the squad mid-season and it has happened almost every year... Matic, David Luiz, Enzo Perez all transfered in January. I'd say there are very good chances this deal will be confirmed
A final note about the price... Anything above 30m€ is fair and will be accepted (welcomed
Didn't Mourinho say he wasn't going to buy anyone from the Portugese league?
Or was that just for the first summer transfer window?
Or was that just for the first summer transfer window?
I think he said he didnt wanna buy anyone thats Portuguese. Think he said it jokingly if I remember correctly.
the rules do care
Didn't we have one of the best defences in the league last year?
I that was mainly due to us being so negative and needing De Gea to bail us out in the majority of games. Recently we haven't really been allowing teams to have many shots on goal while also playing a more attacking game
With the way Rojo and Jones have been playing and if you add Baily and Smalling to the mix, both capable in their own right, we are going to have a bit of a glut at the CB. Not that its bad to have too much quality at such an important position but just saying.
I would like us to get a world quality RB. Whoever that might be. Valencia has been brilliant in that role but its just that I dont want to see Darmian playing anymore. Just doesnt cut it for me.
RB and DM are our immediate needs. RB can be English. DM most likely no lol.
I would like us to get a world quality RB. Whoever that might be. Valencia has been brilliant in that role but its just that I dont want to see Darmian playing anymore. Just doesnt cut it for me.
RB and DM are our immediate needs. RB can be English. DM most likely no lol.
Sky now saying Man united not close to signing lindelof with more interest in deal shown by Benfica.
Trying to make money off of our backs, my guess is they are pushing for this deal to happen in January because of the 30m summer clause and that they have found someone just as good as him to come in for like 8m. Let's bribe their scouts and get that guy
Trying to make money off of our backs, my guess is they are pushing for this deal to happen in January because of the 30m summer clause and that they have found someone just as good as him to come in for like 8m. Let's bribe their scouts and get that guy
Because you want for your defence to have clear cut first choice players in every position. Smalling, rojo and jones are decent but all have very clear deficiencies (smalling anything on the ball plus some intelligence, rojo being inconsistent and loves 2 footed tackles and probably a bit too small physically for Mou, Jones always being injured). Bailly is the only one who looks like being a starting 11 player with potential to be world class. If Mourinho feels Lindelof has that potential then it makes sense, because that would be our clear partnership. Smalling, jones and rojo will never be long term key players.
Last sentence, you don't think he's worth the money? Or you need it?Today's game seemed like a goodbye. Had a good game btw best in a while
His agent has now confirmed that he has a a transfer proposal, but won't reveal the interested club. To add to the rumours... Man Utd was represented at the Stadium Light, although that is pretty common
He is my fav Benfica's CB and will be an important loss. Really hate when we weaken the squad mid-season and it has happened almost every year... Matic, David Luiz, Enzo Perez all transfered in January. I'd say there are very good chances this deal will be confirmed
A final note about the price... Anything above 30m€ is fair and will be accepted (welcomed
Bailly is rash, can be overagressive.
And what makes you think Lindelof doesn't have any weaker areas? Benfica dont have the best defensive record in their league, Porto are very slightly ahead and 3rd best in their champions league group.
Mourinho has made it clear he doesnt pick the players.
Lindelof seems like a Zouma type signinf. If he gets him I won't be suprised to see him close out games in midfield.
I don't think Tuanzebe and Williams have a chance under Mourinho. Its sad. I wish he was a bit like LVG when it came to trusting kids. TFM would've got more minutes by now. Its all about building a winning team though with Mourinho. If you're good enough he'll play you but the young players who'll get chances will already have had some first team experience or will be on high salaries (Rashford, Martial). I doubt Rashford would've made any first team appearances if Mourinho was in charge last season. We can thank LVG for that
A replacement for Fellaini then? Although I would like TFM to grow into the role over time
I really am not, just saying my mind. If we're paying 40 million for a player that means Mourinho sees him as a starter probably.
Couple of games in Primeira and couple in CL.
So you have no meaningful basis to make that judgement then.
Tuanzebe and RoShaun are 19 and 18 respectively, neither have even had a meaningful loan yet, there's no reason they should be anywhere near our first team squad yet.
TFM has signed a new deal with us, I'm fairly confident he's in Jose's plans, it won't be at CB though, he'll probably grow to be an option in midfield and will be used in a similar way to Loftus-cheek.
Really? Not sure if you're aware of the fact that the lad just started playing constantly in first team this season. He's got maybe 30 appearances for Benfica, not like he's on 100 apps already.
- Status