I’ve never been a fan of arguing the toss about transfer fees but surely you have to take into account the fact that Zaha only just signed a new long term contract. That puts the onus on Arsenal to make an offer that CP can’t refuse. Hence coming in with a 40m bid really is kind of laughable.
Plus you seem to have got the age thing back to front. Younger players are typically cheaper, as there’s still a chance they won’t deliver on their potential. A signing with fewer unknowns, at their peak as a footballer, will usually be more expensive.
Maybe so. I look at someone like Everton selling Stones for 50m and buying Bolasie for 26m and think the situations here are pretty comparable. Bolasie was obviously a better player then, in his prime, and more important to the club, but as he'd proven himself over the years to be nowhere near the top tier, he was nowhere top tier prices. Stones showed himself to be potentially top tier but there's still a significant risk 3 years on that he'll never make it. Or a world class Aubameyang being sold in his prime for 58m while a potentially world class (but currently inferior) Dembele goes for nearly double that, and 6 months later a potentially world class (but currently much inferior) Pulisic was sold for 50m.
It depends on how you judge the players I suppose. I don't know anything about AWB but I understand he's expected to be top tier, while Zaha's firmly established himself as being a long way off. I'd expect them to go for similar values and would be amazed if any club considered him to be worth nearly double.
I like you have very little interest in transfer values, but this "transfer market's gone crazy" line that gets thrown out every year always ignores the many, many players who go for unexceptional fees, before and after exceptional fees. Yes Ndombele has just went for 55m, but at the same time Andre Gomes went for 25m or Dendoncker just went for 12m. Some players with huge potential go for huge money while some players with great potential go for considerably less. Fred for 50m was huge money, and people start pointing to it as "well that's just the going rate these days" - but then Torreira and Seri were signed for half that, or a (notably older, but better) Moutinho went for one tenth of that, and they weren't "rated" particularly differently.