breakout67
Full Member
- Joined
- Apr 17, 2017
- Messages
- 9,050
- Supports
- Man City
World Cup hasnt been the highest level for almost 2 decades. Corruption and more smaller teams has killed the prestige of the World Cup.
In his defense we are normally really short on numbers upfront when he gets the ball as Mou likes to defend with 11 people.. Also I can safely say that his 1 v 1 is one of the best that I have seen so for me he is well up there with Pete. Where he stands out from any other goalkeeper is his reactions and shot stopping they are out of this world, the only thing where I think he could really improve is his penalty saving. I just don´t get why he doesn´t save more of them..He’s not better than peter yet. I think he still needs to improve his distribution. Peter could start such great counter attack with amazing throws. Ddg only really kick the ball out really unless short throw.
DDG also not as great on one on one situation, peter was able make himself bigger and tighten the angle.
However, DDG shot stopping and ractions is better than peters.
How do you explain her performance in the 1992 European Championships then?Schmeichel had a better defence, team and tactics in front of him. Also a better manager making all the decisions. He had less to do every match because we attacked a lot more. Swap them round and we’d be worse off now
No United fans saw VdS as world class at Fulham, before he proved it with us. No one put put Neuer as one of GOAT Gk, before his move to Bayern.It's entirely nonsensical to judge a goalkeeper on his team's trophy haul.
Well that's clearly not true, for either of them.No one cared about VdS at Fulham, before he proved it with us. No one put put Neuwer as GOAT, before his move to Bayern.
Clearly? Yeh. I didn't see many thought Neuer as one of the GOAT when he was at Schalke. None in here thought VdS was world class or one of GOAT when he was at Fulham either.Well that's clearly not true, for either of them.
Neuer was extremely highly rated at Schalke, loads of people on here were shitting themselves in excitement at us potentially getting him. VdS was also extremely highly rated having been successful at Ajax and Juve. You're just completely wrong here.Clearly? Yeh. I didn't see many thought Neuer as one of the GOAT when he was at Schalke. None in here thought VdS was world class or one of GOAT when he was at Fulham either.
Ha. Ok then.Neuer was extremely highly rated at Schalke, loads of people on here were shitting themselves in excitement at us potentially getting him. VdS was also extremely highly rated having been successful at Ajax and Juve. You're just completely wrong here.
I think Schmeichel made more mistakes because he came of his line a lot more and came for high balls, he got lobbed quite a few times I remember aswel. DDG is the best shot stopper I’ve ever seen. His reflexes are unbelievable. Big Pete command of his area and presence was world class. It’s such a tough one to call.DDG is better than Schmeichel.
1) He makes no mistakes - whereas Big Peter had 2-3 of the worst kind every season
2) His distribution is much better - even if Schmeichels throws were brilliant
What Schmeichel did better than anyone was the 1 on 1 situation - even Shearer and Wright admitted they were scared of him when they were through on goal.
I remember us playing Schalke in the CL (semis?) and people saying we were going to have a tough time beating Neuer because he was so good. As you say, when there were rumours of him being our VdS replacement we were all giddy with excitement. I remember more than one comparison to The Great Dane, funnily enough. The entire reason Neuer was being linked to us and moved to Bayern was because he was considered world class, and essentially too good to be at Schalke.Neuer was extremely highly rated at Schalke, loads of people on here were shitting themselves in excitement at us potentially getting him. VdS was also extremely highly rated having been successful at Ajax and Juve. You're just completely wrong here.
It will take someone in the ilk of Lionel Messi to beat Georgie boy tbh, on pure talent even Cristiano was not like Best, even for high praises Bestie had for the lad.How feasible is to argue that David De Gea is the best player we ever had? Not just goalkeeper. Guy's been world class for almost five seasons now, arguably the best keeper in the world. Whom have we had to lay claim to a 'best....' in the world?
Ronaldo is the only recent example and that was just two seasons too.
Edit: Just voicing out thoughts.
Are you saying that if VdS kept staying at Fulham, people would still put him as one of the best ever after he retired? And so would Neuer if he's still at Schalke?I remember us playing Schalke in the CL (semis?) and people saying we were going to have a tough time beating Neuer because he was so good. As you say, when there were rumours of him being our VdS replacement we were all giddy with excitement. I remember more than one comparison to The Great Dane, funnily enough. The entire reason Neuer was being linked to us and moved to Bayern was because he was considered world class, and essentially too good to be at Schalke.
Both Neuer and VdS were considered world class goalkeepers when they were at Schalke and Fulham respectively, with perhaps the only caveat being that VdS was deemed to be in the winding down phase of his career, before ultimately proving everyone wrong and going out after an incredible six year spell with us. VdS was already considered to have been a world class goalkeeper, up there with the best ever, before he'd even moved to Fulham. His time with United just cemented that.
I think many United fans would agree that we should have signed Edwin a lot earlier, avoiding the years where we had Bosnich, Barthez, Caroll and Howard as our first choice keepers.
I think he'd be regular in discussions about "forgotten greats," yes.Are you saying that if VdS kept staying at Fulham, people would still put him as one of the best ever after he retired? And so would Neuer if he's still at Schalke?
Ah those aren't the mistakes I am talking about. I am talking about the weak shots from 20 yards he dropped (Think John Sheridan had one when we lost to Wednesday by 3-2) or the times he rushed off his line and missed when trying to kick the ball (he had one against Ipswich when Kiwomya scored and did it again when we got knocked out of the FA Cup a few years later). Or when we lost 3-0 to Everton in 1992 - he came out of the area, took the ball on his chest - and then lost it to Maurice Johnston who scored.I think Schmeichel made more mistakes because he came of his line a lot more and came for high balls, he got lobbed quite a few times I remember aswel. DDG is the best shot stopper I’ve ever seen. His reflexes are unbelievable. Big Pete command of his area and presence was world class. It’s such a tough one to call.
He did make a few mistakes. He had a bad first half of the season in 99. I always remember the one against Munich in the last few minutes when we were 2-1 up, and I think he got lobbed against Fenabache and we lost are unbeaten European record at home.Ah those aren't the mistakes I am talking about. I am talking about the weak shots from 20 yards he dropped (Think John Sheridan had one when we lost to Wednesday by 3-2) or the times he rushed off his line and missed when trying to kick the ball (he had one against Ipswich when Kiwomya scored and did it again when we got knocked out of the FA Cup a few years later). Or when we lost 3-0 to Everton in 1992 - he came out of the area, took the ball on his chest - and then lost it to Maurice Johnston who scored.
He was a brilliant keeper - but he had 1-2 HUGE howlers that lead to goals - every season.
He did make a few mistakes. He had a bad first half of the season in 99. I always remember the one against Munich in the last few minutes when we were 2-1 up, and I think he got lobbed against Fenabache in 97 I think and we lost are unbeaten European record at home.
Still big Pete for me, DDG is getting there but has a way to go yet.feck it, it's true, certainly in my lifetime anyway.
If he stayed at Fulham, I think he'd be remembered as "Good Gk who couldn't cut it in big league". He moved to Juve when he was 29 y.o. If he's that "great", big teams and especially us wouldn't wait until he's 34 y.o. to move to us. It's not like our Gk situation was that good either. We had Tim Howard, and later on alternating with Andy Carroll, before we signed VdS.I think he'd be regular in discussions about "forgotten greats," yes.
VdS was part of an all-time great Ajax side that won the CL and reached the final of another, losing only on penalties. They won three consecutive league titles with him in goal, conceding the fewest goals of any team in the league for all three seasons, he then won a 4th league title with them in 97/98, conceding almost half as many goals as Feyenoord, who conceded the 2nd fewest.
He was then Juventus' first choice for two seasons, where he was once again part of the league's best defence, despite the team not managing to win the league while he was there. It was only the world-record purchase of Buffon that saw him leave Juve.
The Fulham move was a shock to many, but he was still performing very well even with comparatively lower quality teammates. For example, in his first season there, despite Fulham finishing 13th, only 4 teams conceded more goals than them.
This isn't to say that his stature has not been elevated by his time at United, but to say that a keeper with his record prior to his move to United wouldn't be regarded as an all-time great is a bit farcical, as far as I'm concerned.
As for Neuer, he was Germany's first choice before his move to Bayern, conceding only 3 goals in the 2010 World Cup. Unless Schalke were winning things, he'd just be viewed to be wasting his career if he was still there.
I disagree. I don't think he'd be the first name on any best GK list, but I think he's someone who'd be mentioned very frequently as one that people forget about. You can't completely disregard the fact that he was the GK for an Ajax side that was among the best in Europe for a spell, winning a Champions League, or that his spells at Ajax and Juventus also happened to coincide with seasons in which they were conceding far fewer goals than their domestic competition. He also won a 130 caps for Netherlands, until this year, being their most capped player.If he stayed at Fulham, I think he'd be remembered as "Good Gk who couldn't cut it in big league". He moved to Juve when he was 29 y.o. If he's that "great", big teams and especially us wouldn't wait until he's 34 y.o. to move to us. It's not like our Gk situation was that good either. We had Tim Howard, and later on alternating with Andy Carroll, before we signed VdS.
Always like those, but I am not gonna go all time, I will limit it to the past 20/25 years. Mine would be Schmeichel, Buffon, Kahn, Neuer and Van der Sar. Never rated Casillas all that much.Who are the 5 best keeper's of all time
Come at me.
Edit: feck off Buchan!